Thank you to all who participated in our little "global health blogging experiment." Nine posts on "prevention vs. treatment" were published--out of an expected 12. Respectable numbers for an all-volunteer effort.
I do not have much time to write today, alas, but wanted to leave you with at least one thought. I was particularly intrigued that Liz Borkowski pointed us to a larger story--the gradual abandonment of anti-tobacco/anti-smoking programs in the U.S. That's the kind of piece--big and slow-moving--that can be very hard to get a grip on in the traditional media. And precisely the sort of thing that can thrive on the web.
An example comes to mind from well outside the global health sphere--how the folks at Talking Points Memo aggregated their own reporting with that of disparate professional journalists to tell the story of the number of US attorneys who had been fired under the Bush Administration for not toeing the line politically. (The TPM, incidentally, also won a George Polk Award for Journalism for its work.)
Anyway, I hope folks look at the other entries and post their own responses/analyses/constructive critiques. So, without further ado, here are the other global health posts on "prevention vs. treatment."
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
Friday, 30 January 2009
Thursday, 29 January 2009
Prevention vs. Treatment: A False Choice
The long-running debate over the relative importance of prevention or treatment is the theme that at least a dozen global health bloggers are exploring today. In many ways, the debate represents a false choice; a well-functioning health system requires both prevention and treatment. But how do you strike the right balance? Is the measuring stick simply the one provided by economics? Or do equity and fairness also play a role?
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” or so the old saying goes. But we don’t always practice what our folk wisdom preaches.
The U.S. medical system, as currently set up, rewards cardiac surgeons at a much greater rate than it does programs for avoiding weight gain or controlling high blood pressure.
About 5% or less of the U.S. budget on health care is spent on prevention, according to Don Wright of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Most of the rest is spent on treatment—and, I would venture to guess, paper work.
And yet, you can bet that if I ever experience a gripping pain in my chest or back, accompanied by nausea and perhaps an overwhelming sense of anxiety—classic signs of a heart attack in women—I am going to get myself to an emergency room right away to get treated and be mighty thankful if the specialists at the cardiac catheterization lab can open up any blocked arteries.
The year I spent at Harvard taught me a lot about how academics argue the prevention vs. treatment debate. Indeed, just a few years ago there was that rare thing in public health—a big public debate between some folks at the Gates Foundation on one side and some at Harvard on the other about whether prevention or treatment was the better—read more “cost-effective”—approach to tackling HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Eventually the Harvard side won the argument—especially once the cost of anti-retroviral therapy dropped dramatically. What made the difference was the fairness issue: How could you withhold treatment when so many were dying?
A few months in rural Malawi gave me a whole other perspective. There I learned that tremendous strides have been made in decreasing maternal death rates at the Embangweni Mission Hospital through a variety of efforts—not least of which was an emphasis on both prevention and treatment.
It did not happen by accident and it did not happen overnight. When the effort began, several years ago, there was only a single sink in the labor and delivery room. So improving the physical plant was a priority in terms of providing better treatment. Embangweni Hospital also worked really hard to get the right people in the ward—namely more nurses and clinical officers—and keep up their training. Alas, hard experience also taught them they had to make the ward off-limits to many of the grandmothers or “gogos,” who would slip their daughters and daughters-in-law a powerful herbal concoction to induce labor but that also increased the risk of potentially fatal uterine rupture.
On the prevention side, community health nurses have been working throughout the South Mzimbe region for the past ten years to provide prenatal care to pregnant women. To give just one example, the community health workers I met, like Joyce Ngoma and Tamala Chirwa, work hard to identify women who may have trouble delivering—because they are carrying twins or the fetus is not positioned properly. The nurses advise those women to go to the hospital early so that they can be watched more closely and scheduled for a caesarean operation, if need be.
Each side—prevention and treatment—benefits from the other. With fewer pregnant women showing up at the hospital in crisis, the clinical officers and nurses there are able to save more mothers' lives. The nurses in the field can see that their efforts have saved lives and are encouraged to do more prevention work.
Today's posts on Prevention vs. Treatment from other global health blogs (as I learn of them):
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” or so the old saying goes. But we don’t always practice what our folk wisdom preaches.
The U.S. medical system, as currently set up, rewards cardiac surgeons at a much greater rate than it does programs for avoiding weight gain or controlling high blood pressure.
About 5% or less of the U.S. budget on health care is spent on prevention, according to Don Wright of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Most of the rest is spent on treatment—and, I would venture to guess, paper work.
And yet, you can bet that if I ever experience a gripping pain in my chest or back, accompanied by nausea and perhaps an overwhelming sense of anxiety—classic signs of a heart attack in women—I am going to get myself to an emergency room right away to get treated and be mighty thankful if the specialists at the cardiac catheterization lab can open up any blocked arteries.
The year I spent at Harvard taught me a lot about how academics argue the prevention vs. treatment debate. Indeed, just a few years ago there was that rare thing in public health—a big public debate between some folks at the Gates Foundation on one side and some at Harvard on the other about whether prevention or treatment was the better—read more “cost-effective”—approach to tackling HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Eventually the Harvard side won the argument—especially once the cost of anti-retroviral therapy dropped dramatically. What made the difference was the fairness issue: How could you withhold treatment when so many were dying?
A few months in rural Malawi gave me a whole other perspective. There I learned that tremendous strides have been made in decreasing maternal death rates at the Embangweni Mission Hospital through a variety of efforts—not least of which was an emphasis on both prevention and treatment.
It did not happen by accident and it did not happen overnight. When the effort began, several years ago, there was only a single sink in the labor and delivery room. So improving the physical plant was a priority in terms of providing better treatment. Embangweni Hospital also worked really hard to get the right people in the ward—namely more nurses and clinical officers—and keep up their training. Alas, hard experience also taught them they had to make the ward off-limits to many of the grandmothers or “gogos,” who would slip their daughters and daughters-in-law a powerful herbal concoction to induce labor but that also increased the risk of potentially fatal uterine rupture.
On the prevention side, community health nurses have been working throughout the South Mzimbe region for the past ten years to provide prenatal care to pregnant women. To give just one example, the community health workers I met, like Joyce Ngoma and Tamala Chirwa, work hard to identify women who may have trouble delivering—because they are carrying twins or the fetus is not positioned properly. The nurses advise those women to go to the hospital early so that they can be watched more closely and scheduled for a caesarean operation, if need be.
Each side—prevention and treatment—benefits from the other. With fewer pregnant women showing up at the hospital in crisis, the clinical officers and nurses there are able to save more mothers' lives. The nurses in the field can see that their efforts have saved lives and are encouraged to do more prevention work.
Today's posts on Prevention vs. Treatment from other global health blogs (as I learn of them):
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
Tuesday, 27 January 2009
Community Organizing Meets Global Health Blogging
Towards building a social network around global health news.
At least a dozen global health bloggers have publicly said they will be posting on the broad theme of "prevention vs. treatment" this Thursday, January 29, 2009. (Feel free to join in!) This is part of an experiment that grew out of a Twitter conversation to see if we can coordinate posts in a kind of "global health blog carnival" to increase awareness of global health issues. I'll be posting about my experience in Malawi and reflecting on whether the prevention vs. treatment debate is really a false choice.
But there are some larger questions here that I would like to explore: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web? What can we do to nurture it? Do economic realities dictate that this will have to be a volunteer led endeavor, at least for a while?
Or, another way of putting that last question: Is news about global health subject to the same market failures that afflict products for global health (e.g. free-market forces alone will not lead to new tuberculosis medications and other drugs that affect mostly the poorest people in the world)?
Some preliminary thoughts on the first question: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web?
Although blogging has been around for a while, we haven't really had the critical mass of bloggers interested in global health issues until recently.
International news coverage has suffered terribly in the retrenchment affecting the journalism industry. There are efforts to do something about that. The Gates Foundation is funding more coverage of global health issues at National Public Radio, Public Radio International and on television's The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer. The new kid on the block is Global Post, which I am happy to say, has a global health correspondent in South Africa. And let's not forget Global Voices Online, whose international health reporting is growing.
The British newspaper The Guardian is partnering with AMREF, an NGO dedicated to medical relief in Africa, to report development news from the Ugandan village of Katine. (See Laura Oliver's post on a UK journalism blog for news on the project's growing pains. Larry Hollon also has thoughts at Perspectives.)
I suspect we have only scratched the surface. In my view, a true social network for global health news would go far beyond encouraging comments, cross-linking, blog carnivals and re-tweeting. But those are the first steps.
Note to self and others: the news innovation barcamp for entrepreneurial journalists at the University of Missouri last week may give us some ideas for how to share ideas, organize efforts. They have created an online site for collaboration among groups of like-minded people (journalists and non-journalists) who want to explore new ideas for news coverage but have low or no budgets for experimentation.
At least a dozen global health bloggers have publicly said they will be posting on the broad theme of "prevention vs. treatment" this Thursday, January 29, 2009. (Feel free to join in!) This is part of an experiment that grew out of a Twitter conversation to see if we can coordinate posts in a kind of "global health blog carnival" to increase awareness of global health issues. I'll be posting about my experience in Malawi and reflecting on whether the prevention vs. treatment debate is really a false choice.
But there are some larger questions here that I would like to explore: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web? What can we do to nurture it? Do economic realities dictate that this will have to be a volunteer led endeavor, at least for a while?
Or, another way of putting that last question: Is news about global health subject to the same market failures that afflict products for global health (e.g. free-market forces alone will not lead to new tuberculosis medications and other drugs that affect mostly the poorest people in the world)?
Some preliminary thoughts on the first question: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web?
Although blogging has been around for a while, we haven't really had the critical mass of bloggers interested in global health issues until recently.
International news coverage has suffered terribly in the retrenchment affecting the journalism industry. There are efforts to do something about that. The Gates Foundation is funding more coverage of global health issues at National Public Radio, Public Radio International and on television's The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer. The new kid on the block is Global Post, which I am happy to say, has a global health correspondent in South Africa. And let's not forget Global Voices Online, whose international health reporting is growing.
The British newspaper The Guardian is partnering with AMREF, an NGO dedicated to medical relief in Africa, to report development news from the Ugandan village of Katine. (See Laura Oliver's post on a UK journalism blog for news on the project's growing pains. Larry Hollon also has thoughts at Perspectives.)
I suspect we have only scratched the surface. In my view, a true social network for global health news would go far beyond encouraging comments, cross-linking, blog carnivals and re-tweeting. But those are the first steps.
Note to self and others: the news innovation barcamp for entrepreneurial journalists at the University of Missouri last week may give us some ideas for how to share ideas, organize efforts. They have created an online site for collaboration among groups of like-minded people (journalists and non-journalists) who want to explore new ideas for news coverage but have low or no budgets for experimentation.
Monday, 26 January 2009
Links: Journalism, Development, Antibiotic Resistance
Two important news items that should be getting more attention. The first is on a "midnight rule" change from the former Bush Administration that is just coming to light. The other is on a unique partnership between a journalistic outfit and a global development organization.
Well, this is bad news
Maryn McKenna tells us "the FDA has quietly reversed a decision it took last summer, and will allow cephalosporins, a human medicine, to be used without restriction in food animals." McKenna takes the time to put the news in context and add some of her own reporting--good journalistic habits. About that headline . . .
Media and Development
Excellent post from Larry Hollon at Perspectives about an "agreement between the African Medical and Research Foundation (AMREF) and the Guardian, the London-based daily newspaper, to document a development program in Katine, Uganda." I was most struck by Larry's concise summary of the high expectations and journalistic conflicts that accompany such projects.
Well, this is bad news
Maryn McKenna tells us "the FDA has quietly reversed a decision it took last summer, and will allow cephalosporins, a human medicine, to be used without restriction in food animals." McKenna takes the time to put the news in context and add some of her own reporting--good journalistic habits. About that headline . . .
Media and Development
Excellent post from Larry Hollon at Perspectives about an "agreement between the African Medical and Research Foundation (AMREF) and the Guardian, the London-based daily newspaper, to document a development program in Katine, Uganda." I was most struck by Larry's concise summary of the high expectations and journalistic conflicts that accompany such projects.
Friday, 23 January 2009
Links: Ebola, Toilets and Corruption, Iodized Salt
Filipino tests positive for Ebola
From Reuters in Manila: "At least one person has tested positive for the Ebola-Reston virus in the Philippines, where the disease has broken out in pigs at two farms north of the capital, the government said on Friday."
Are Working Toilets A Good Anti-Corruption Indicator?
From the BBC's Mark Doyle: Reading official reports about corruption can be so boring. Doyle's lighthearted look at whether working toilets indicate progress against corruption in Sierra Leone.
The Challenge of Iodized Salt
From Alanna Shaikh, who just moved toUzbekistan Tajikistan: A quick look at why it is so hard to make iodized salt universally available.
From Reuters in Manila: "At least one person has tested positive for the Ebola-Reston virus in the Philippines, where the disease has broken out in pigs at two farms north of the capital, the government said on Friday."
Are Working Toilets A Good Anti-Corruption Indicator?
From the BBC's Mark Doyle: Reading official reports about corruption can be so boring. Doyle's lighthearted look at whether working toilets indicate progress against corruption in Sierra Leone.
The Challenge of Iodized Salt
From Alanna Shaikh, who just moved to
Thursday, 22 January 2009
Broken Links at DotGov Sites
Are broken web links at U.S. government sites going to be a feature of all future changes in Administration? I'm having trouble finding some of the links I had saved on a couple of global health issues from official U.S. government sites. Shouldn't we have some web continuity between Bush and Obama Administrations?
I can no longer get at a press release about human rights from Dec. 10, 2008 that was on the whitehouse.gov site. I get redirected to the Obama briefing room, not even a "page has been moved" message. Very Ministry of Truth.
Yesterday, Maryn McKenna found a broken link to whitehouse.gov that used to tell about the President's Malaria Initiative. No refer pages to where the pages are archived (although the Malaria Initiative itself is still available at fightingmalaria.gov).
I thought, okay, that is the White House--a very political place. But then in writing up my post about the Iranian AIDS doctors who were just sentenced to prison terms for trying to foment a velvet revolution via international HIV meetings (you can't make this stuff up, unfortunately), I realized that a link to an official statement from U.S. State department about the Alaei case was broken. The error message read "We're sorry. That page can't be found and may have been moved."
Since the statement was made by the Bush Administration, the contents had been moved to an archive site. Okay, fine, but at least give me the refer. I had to go and search by eyeball (keyword search Alaei brought up nothing) to find the archived statement.
That's when I started to worry. What about all the press releases at the Centers for Disease Control? Are all those links broken, too? Fortunately, as of Jan. 22, 2008, the CDC's RSS feed for press releases about vaccinations, mortality data, etc. is intact.
I used to think saving links to U.S. government web sites was a safe thing to do because, well, it's the government, they have to preserve those web pages--right? It is a matter of public record. And press releases are part of the public record. But what if the government webmasters preserve the pages and destroy the links? Makes keeping track of things mighty difficult.
It's a different kind of way of politicizing the record--every bit as Orwellian as deleting the word "abortion" as a search term from the Popline database last spring. Fortunately, that was fixed.
Is there a technological fix for broken links, too? Can the new Administration put up their stuff without losing the links to the old information? It is the same government of the same country, after all--just different temporary leaders.
Do you have any other examples of broken government links about global health post-Obama transition?
I can no longer get at a press release about human rights from Dec. 10, 2008 that was on the whitehouse.gov site. I get redirected to the Obama briefing room, not even a "page has been moved" message. Very Ministry of Truth.
Yesterday, Maryn McKenna found a broken link to whitehouse.gov that used to tell about the President's Malaria Initiative. No refer pages to where the pages are archived (although the Malaria Initiative itself is still available at fightingmalaria.gov).
I thought, okay, that is the White House--a very political place. But then in writing up my post about the Iranian AIDS doctors who were just sentenced to prison terms for trying to foment a velvet revolution via international HIV meetings (you can't make this stuff up, unfortunately), I realized that a link to an official statement from U.S. State department about the Alaei case was broken. The error message read "We're sorry. That page can't be found and may have been moved."
Since the statement was made by the Bush Administration, the contents had been moved to an archive site. Okay, fine, but at least give me the refer. I had to go and search by eyeball (keyword search Alaei brought up nothing) to find the archived statement.
That's when I started to worry. What about all the press releases at the Centers for Disease Control? Are all those links broken, too? Fortunately, as of Jan. 22, 2008, the CDC's RSS feed for press releases about vaccinations, mortality data, etc. is intact.
I used to think saving links to U.S. government web sites was a safe thing to do because, well, it's the government, they have to preserve those web pages--right? It is a matter of public record. And press releases are part of the public record. But what if the government webmasters preserve the pages and destroy the links? Makes keeping track of things mighty difficult.
It's a different kind of way of politicizing the record--every bit as Orwellian as deleting the word "abortion" as a search term from the Popline database last spring. Fortunately, that was fixed.
Is there a technological fix for broken links, too? Can the new Administration put up their stuff without losing the links to the old information? It is the same government of the same country, after all--just different temporary leaders.
Do you have any other examples of broken government links about global health post-Obama transition?
Iranian AIDS Docs Get 3 and 6 Years in Prison
While the rest of the world was focused on the peaceful transition of power in the U.S., Iranian AIDS doctors Kamiar and Arash Alaei learned on January 20 that they had been sentenced to three years and six years, respectively, in prison, according to Physicians for Human Rights.
The Alaei brothers' case is one of several recently in which professionals and religious minorities have been falsely accused of fomenting revolution. Lawyer and Nobel Laureate Shirin Ebadi's Human Rights Defenders Center was raided and shut down by police in December (Los Angeles Times). Her former secretary was arrested earlier this month in a roundup of six B'hai women (B'hai News).
(Update: The LA Times says Sylvia Hartounian, 33, a reproductive medicine specialist, was sentenced along with the Alaei brothers.)
Radio Free Europe has a good summary article that ties all these moves to internal Iranian politics--trying to sow fear among the Iranian electorate ahead of presidential elections in June.
The Washington Post quotes an unnamed Iranian official as saying the brothers' treatment is part of a "full-fledged intelligence war" between the U.S. and Iran. "A soft revolution has been programmed against our country and carried out in some instances, but it was suffocated in the cradle," the Iranian official was quoted as saying.
Further update (1/29/2009): For deep context, listen to Jeb Sharp's excellent podcast on Public Radio International's "The World" about the long-term damage to US-Iranian relations caused by the 1953 coup engineered by the CIA.
Related posts:
Jailed Iranian Docs
Jailed AIDS Docs Tried in Secret
Sentences Expected for Iranian AIDS Docs
The Alaei brothers' case is one of several recently in which professionals and religious minorities have been falsely accused of fomenting revolution. Lawyer and Nobel Laureate Shirin Ebadi's Human Rights Defenders Center was raided and shut down by police in December (Los Angeles Times). Her former secretary was arrested earlier this month in a roundup of six B'hai women (B'hai News).
(Update: The LA Times says Sylvia Hartounian, 33, a reproductive medicine specialist, was sentenced along with the Alaei brothers.)
Radio Free Europe has a good summary article that ties all these moves to internal Iranian politics--trying to sow fear among the Iranian electorate ahead of presidential elections in June.
The Washington Post quotes an unnamed Iranian official as saying the brothers' treatment is part of a "full-fledged intelligence war" between the U.S. and Iran. "A soft revolution has been programmed against our country and carried out in some instances, but it was suffocated in the cradle," the Iranian official was quoted as saying.
Further update (1/29/2009): For deep context, listen to Jeb Sharp's excellent podcast on Public Radio International's "The World" about the long-term damage to US-Iranian relations caused by the 1953 coup engineered by the CIA.
Related posts:
Jailed Iranian Docs
Jailed AIDS Docs Tried in Secret
Sentences Expected for Iranian AIDS Docs
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)