Here is another example of why we need more independent reporting on global health and development. A study from the Public Library of Science found that many global health initiatives are still effectively siloed efforts that focus on single diseases or institutions and do not, despite claims to the contrary, support overall health systems.
And yet, as I have seen in my own travels through Malawi, Lesotho, South Africa and Zambia, improving health systems is precisely what is needed in many poor countries and impoverished areas. "Health system strengthening" has become the new catchphrase but, according to the PLOS report and the lived experience of many in the global health field, there has been no real change in action to support this goal.
One positive trend: the researchers note that while their funding came from the Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, "the funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript." This slightly more detailed conflict-of-interest statement should be adopted more widely when reporting or writing about global health.
Related post:
Who Pays for Global Health News and Why?
Showing posts with label #ghnews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #ghnews. Show all posts
Thursday, 4 June 2009
Tuesday, 19 May 2009
Who Pays for Global Health News and Why?
To maintain credibility, news coverage of global health and development issues must be independent because who pays and why dramatically influences the process of what gets told. This is a sleeper issue that does not get enough attention. As a health journalist, I know we have been down this road before—with respect to misleading consumer news coverage of medications and research studies—and it’s not pretty. In the end, it actually hurts people and wastes money.
It hit me last night why I am so passionate about this topic. I went to a presentation about how to improve health care news coverage in the U.S., which was mostly about how many health news reports don’t cover basic issues like costs, availability or provide even a hint of context about whether something is truly broadly beneficial. The event was sponsored by the New York City chapter of the Association of Health Care Journalists, of which I am a member.
One of the presenters, Gary Schwitzer, a former CNN journalist and current journalism professor who founded HealthNewsReview.org, jokingly suggested that I might throw spitballs at him while he was at the podium. (The other presenter was Harry DeMonaco, who helps Boston's Massachusetts General Hospital decide what treatments are both beneficial and cost-effective.) Instead, Schwitzer provided me with an aha! moment.
For more than 20 years, I have worked in an environment where pharmaceutical and medical device companies have a huge vested interested in getting their products covered by the mainstream media in the best possible light.
As Gary Schwitzer and Harry DeMonaco noted, the economic incentives are so great that the influence extends even to what appears in medical journals. Drugs are often compared against placebo instead of current effective treatments, for example, because the results are more dramatic that way. No one can take a chance on a new medication being scientifically shown to be just as good or only marginally better than a less-expensive one.
Add to that human nature—it is very hard to be objective about something to which you have dedicated lots of your time and energy. So naturally, someone who is a principal investigator on a study is going to be enthusiastic about the work and its potential for alleviating human suffering.
I know that—as do many of my colleagues in the health journalism field. And I hope that I have taken account of those sorts of positive psychological and economic biases in my reporting by looking for more outsides sources, bringing a respectful-but-still skeptical attitude to most research studies.
Just as importantly, I benefited from the structural divide that was set up within TIME Magazine that kept the advertising side separate from the editorial side precisely so that I could be as independent as possible in doing my job.
So here I am, trying to get more news coverage—both online and offline—of important issues in global health and development and I find the same built-in biases that make health-reporting trickier than you might at first think.
There is a built-in bias in almost any story about non-government organizations against considering what governments are doing in health. Every story about a specific disease has a built-in bias against discussing primary care systems or the non-medical interventions (like better schools or roads or robust legal and civil rights for women) that could conceivably have an even greater impact.
The consequences are very real. To give just one example, I will never again be able to read another laudatory story about the “generous donation of medical supplies” without thinking about the amount of donated material that I saw in Malawi last year that had either passed its expiration date or was actually useless—and needed to be discarded, all at the expense of the receiver. This is the sort of problem that missionaries 50 years ago dubbed “junk for Jesus.” It makes the folks back home feel virtuous but it is a burden for the supposed beneficiaries.
Given the costs and the way things are going these days in journalism, there is bound to be money coming from interested parties whether in the form of grants, advertising or even accepting a ride in an aid convoy, to cover global health issues. That’s all the more reason to set up rigorous firewalls so that funders and advocacy groups don’t get editorial approval over the final product. News organizations also need to make those policies public so that the larger community can judge for itself how well they are doing.
Budding global health news organizations—or content providers—also need to be more creative about who they tap as funders/advertisers. Maybe recruit the folks who like to fund transparency projects, for example, instead of going after global health or single-issue advocacy money.
There may also be ways of crowd-funding global health news coverage that we haven’t explored.
But I know we need to be paying as much attention to managing these conflicts within the coverage of global health news as we are to “monetizing content,” to use the current buzz-phrase. And it's just as much an issue for citizen journalists/participatory media as for legacy or professional journalists.
Related posts (updated on May 20,2009)
Click #ghnews label for other posts on covering global health
See also "Pro-Publica and Conflicts of Interest"
Read Ivan Oransky's live tweets from Monday night's AHCJ event with Schwitzer and DeMonaco.
It hit me last night why I am so passionate about this topic. I went to a presentation about how to improve health care news coverage in the U.S., which was mostly about how many health news reports don’t cover basic issues like costs, availability or provide even a hint of context about whether something is truly broadly beneficial. The event was sponsored by the New York City chapter of the Association of Health Care Journalists, of which I am a member.
One of the presenters, Gary Schwitzer, a former CNN journalist and current journalism professor who founded HealthNewsReview.org, jokingly suggested that I might throw spitballs at him while he was at the podium. (The other presenter was Harry DeMonaco, who helps Boston's Massachusetts General Hospital decide what treatments are both beneficial and cost-effective.) Instead, Schwitzer provided me with an aha! moment.
For more than 20 years, I have worked in an environment where pharmaceutical and medical device companies have a huge vested interested in getting their products covered by the mainstream media in the best possible light.
As Gary Schwitzer and Harry DeMonaco noted, the economic incentives are so great that the influence extends even to what appears in medical journals. Drugs are often compared against placebo instead of current effective treatments, for example, because the results are more dramatic that way. No one can take a chance on a new medication being scientifically shown to be just as good or only marginally better than a less-expensive one.
Add to that human nature—it is very hard to be objective about something to which you have dedicated lots of your time and energy. So naturally, someone who is a principal investigator on a study is going to be enthusiastic about the work and its potential for alleviating human suffering.
I know that—as do many of my colleagues in the health journalism field. And I hope that I have taken account of those sorts of positive psychological and economic biases in my reporting by looking for more outsides sources, bringing a respectful-but-still skeptical attitude to most research studies.
Just as importantly, I benefited from the structural divide that was set up within TIME Magazine that kept the advertising side separate from the editorial side precisely so that I could be as independent as possible in doing my job.
So here I am, trying to get more news coverage—both online and offline—of important issues in global health and development and I find the same built-in biases that make health-reporting trickier than you might at first think.
There is a built-in bias in almost any story about non-government organizations against considering what governments are doing in health. Every story about a specific disease has a built-in bias against discussing primary care systems or the non-medical interventions (like better schools or roads or robust legal and civil rights for women) that could conceivably have an even greater impact.
The consequences are very real. To give just one example, I will never again be able to read another laudatory story about the “generous donation of medical supplies” without thinking about the amount of donated material that I saw in Malawi last year that had either passed its expiration date or was actually useless—and needed to be discarded, all at the expense of the receiver. This is the sort of problem that missionaries 50 years ago dubbed “junk for Jesus.” It makes the folks back home feel virtuous but it is a burden for the supposed beneficiaries.
Given the costs and the way things are going these days in journalism, there is bound to be money coming from interested parties whether in the form of grants, advertising or even accepting a ride in an aid convoy, to cover global health issues. That’s all the more reason to set up rigorous firewalls so that funders and advocacy groups don’t get editorial approval over the final product. News organizations also need to make those policies public so that the larger community can judge for itself how well they are doing.
Budding global health news organizations—or content providers—also need to be more creative about who they tap as funders/advertisers. Maybe recruit the folks who like to fund transparency projects, for example, instead of going after global health or single-issue advocacy money.
There may also be ways of crowd-funding global health news coverage that we haven’t explored.
But I know we need to be paying as much attention to managing these conflicts within the coverage of global health news as we are to “monetizing content,” to use the current buzz-phrase. And it's just as much an issue for citizen journalists/participatory media as for legacy or professional journalists.
Related posts (updated on May 20,2009)
Click #ghnews label for other posts on covering global health
See also "Pro-Publica and Conflicts of Interest"
Read Ivan Oransky's live tweets from Monday night's AHCJ event with Schwitzer and DeMonaco.
Thursday, 12 March 2009
Wanted: A Social Network for Global Health News
Towards building a social network for real global health news on the cheap.
The promise: the Web allows anyone to have a voice.
The reality: the Web is actually narrowing the bounds of conversation. We’re recreating in the digital world the same categories and divisions that exist in the real world—only stronger. (See James Evans' recent analysis in Science for supporting evidence in scientific publishing online. On a related note, check out this study about "the winner's curse.")
Case in point: global health news coverage. This topic always falls between the cracks in the mainstream press—somewhere between “world news” and “health news.” Those offline categories are simply getting stronger in the online world. News categories are not yet miscellaneous enough, as David Weinberger describes.
In my experience, most global health news is actually promotional, not journalistic in nature.
A possible solution and the reason for this message: organizing the folks who are already writing about global health news online for free. Note: this is not going to pay anybody’s bills but since we are doing it anyway (as a way of keeping online notes for a book, learning, self-promotion, etc.), why not make it as powerful as it can be?
Some background: the fact that we were able to cover global health news at all was a happy result of the inefficiencies in the advertising model that financed most of the news business until very recently. Yes, most of the health advertising in TIME Magazine, for example, came from pharmaceutical companies but the firewall between edit and the publishing side, my own interests and those of several colleagues plus the fact that drug companies were okay with the fact that their ads reached both people who wanted their medications as well as those who did not, allowed us to write about global health and other less obviously remunerative articles. Keyword-based advertising has changed all that but that’s a topic for another post. (See Ethan Zuckerman for a really clear introduction to the value of advertising inefficiency, especially the part about how Bloomingdales underwrites the New York Time's Africa coverage)
After spending a lot of time thinking about this and talking to lots of people, I’m starting to accept that foundations are NOT going to pay for global health news coverage. And there probably is not a very good business model for it either. Oh yes, certain sections will get peeled off—anything having to do with mobile phones, pharmaceuticals or risk management. Plenty of opportunities for targeted advertising, subscriptions or commercial contracts there.
But the same market failures that have hobbled the development of new TB drugs over the past 50 years also affect the production and coverage of in-depth global health news.
Note, I am not talking about creating an educational service—like Kaiser’s globalhealthreporting.org. Nor am I envisioning a PR newswire for global health—like globalhealthtv.com (which was developed by a PR company for the Global Health Council).
Both are necessary but not sufficient to what I would like to see, which is an independent editorial voice in global health news.
The news industry as we know it is undergoing radical transformation. It is too busy focusing on survival to care what happens to global health news. The Knight Foundation and others are focusing on local community news and investigative journalism. The foundations that fund global health are taking some baby steps—like the Gates Foundation funding NPR, PRI and the Jim Lehrer show—but they won’t do something bigger, I think, because they don’t want to give up control of the message.
So that leaves the people who are doing it for little or no money, out of passion or as an adjunct to other paying projects. (Heaven help us.)
Meanwhile, how do we get the values, the best of what we aspire to as journalists, as global citizens, baked into whatever the new systems are? I'm going to try buttonholing as many of my fellow participants at the meeting of the Association of Health Care Journalists in Seattle April 16-19 about this as I can. This is not something anyone can do on their own. But is there a critical mass willing to try? That's what I would like to know.
I welcome your thoughts.
Related posts:
Sharing and Global Health Blogging
Update on the Global Health Blogging Experiment
Community Organizing Meets Global Health Blogging
Looking for Context in Global Health Reporting
The promise: the Web allows anyone to have a voice.
The reality: the Web is actually narrowing the bounds of conversation. We’re recreating in the digital world the same categories and divisions that exist in the real world—only stronger. (See James Evans' recent analysis in Science for supporting evidence in scientific publishing online. On a related note, check out this study about "the winner's curse.")
Case in point: global health news coverage. This topic always falls between the cracks in the mainstream press—somewhere between “world news” and “health news.” Those offline categories are simply getting stronger in the online world. News categories are not yet miscellaneous enough, as David Weinberger describes.
In my experience, most global health news is actually promotional, not journalistic in nature.
A possible solution and the reason for this message: organizing the folks who are already writing about global health news online for free. Note: this is not going to pay anybody’s bills but since we are doing it anyway (as a way of keeping online notes for a book, learning, self-promotion, etc.), why not make it as powerful as it can be?
Some background: the fact that we were able to cover global health news at all was a happy result of the inefficiencies in the advertising model that financed most of the news business until very recently. Yes, most of the health advertising in TIME Magazine, for example, came from pharmaceutical companies but the firewall between edit and the publishing side, my own interests and those of several colleagues plus the fact that drug companies were okay with the fact that their ads reached both people who wanted their medications as well as those who did not, allowed us to write about global health and other less obviously remunerative articles. Keyword-based advertising has changed all that but that’s a topic for another post. (See Ethan Zuckerman for a really clear introduction to the value of advertising inefficiency, especially the part about how Bloomingdales underwrites the New York Time's Africa coverage)
After spending a lot of time thinking about this and talking to lots of people, I’m starting to accept that foundations are NOT going to pay for global health news coverage. And there probably is not a very good business model for it either. Oh yes, certain sections will get peeled off—anything having to do with mobile phones, pharmaceuticals or risk management. Plenty of opportunities for targeted advertising, subscriptions or commercial contracts there.
But the same market failures that have hobbled the development of new TB drugs over the past 50 years also affect the production and coverage of in-depth global health news.
Note, I am not talking about creating an educational service—like Kaiser’s globalhealthreporting.org. Nor am I envisioning a PR newswire for global health—like globalhealthtv.com (which was developed by a PR company for the Global Health Council).
Both are necessary but not sufficient to what I would like to see, which is an independent editorial voice in global health news.
The news industry as we know it is undergoing radical transformation. It is too busy focusing on survival to care what happens to global health news. The Knight Foundation and others are focusing on local community news and investigative journalism. The foundations that fund global health are taking some baby steps—like the Gates Foundation funding NPR, PRI and the Jim Lehrer show—but they won’t do something bigger, I think, because they don’t want to give up control of the message.
So that leaves the people who are doing it for little or no money, out of passion or as an adjunct to other paying projects. (Heaven help us.)
Meanwhile, how do we get the values, the best of what we aspire to as journalists, as global citizens, baked into whatever the new systems are? I'm going to try buttonholing as many of my fellow participants at the meeting of the Association of Health Care Journalists in Seattle April 16-19 about this as I can. This is not something anyone can do on their own. But is there a critical mass willing to try? That's what I would like to know.
I welcome your thoughts.
Related posts:
Sharing and Global Health Blogging
Update on the Global Health Blogging Experiment
Community Organizing Meets Global Health Blogging
Looking for Context in Global Health Reporting
Friday, 6 March 2009
Can You Improve Wikipedia's Entry on Global Health?
After 27 months, Wikipedia's entry on "global health" is finally starting to take shape. I look at this as yet another lesson on the need to wait for (or build) a critical mass.
Not all conversations on the Web happen so fast and include so many partners that it makes your head spin. Some are so long and laborious that you might think the participants were Treebeard and the rest of Tolkien's Ents. Case in point: the 27-month long conversation behind Wikipedia's entry on "global health."
Back in June of 2005, a volunteer Wikipedia editor who went by the name "Drgregmartin" wrote a short entry on Wikipedia about "global health." A few months later, I came along and did a little copy-editing, added some historical context and a few external links.
By the fall of 2006, this short, not-great entry had morphed into something completely overgrown and unreadable. A number of anonymous users from several universities clearly decided to do a little self-promotion while others added several giant tangents or pet peeves. Eventually, the entry got flagged as "needing clean up."
So far, I have described the natural history of countless Wikipedia entries. An earnest soul writes a short piece, others discover it and soon so many editors have a hand in it that it morphs into something that is far worse than whatever it started off as. In the best circumstances, this chaotic phase settles down and editing becomes much more stable--and the writing and the rigor improve.
Trying to be a good Wikipedian, I started a conversation on the global_health talk page about how to fix the entry and get to the next, more stable phase of Wiki writing. My proposal was met with deafening silence.
Meanwhile, the entry was getting longer and less readable. I contemplated fixing things myself but figured I would be out-revised by the self-promoters. Every once in a while I would come back to check on things. The entry kept getting woolier and woolier. I chalked it up as a reality-check on how Wikipedia works: popular articles are more likely to be better.
But, every now and then, someone would add a comment on the talk page. In more than two years, there have in fact been seven responses--all fairly substantial. And here's the most intriguing thing: they actually can be read as a conversation with genuine give and take.
Gradually, a Wikipedian by the name of Useknowledge came along and edited the entry back to a form that is more manageable.
It is still not perfect, but it is an improvement over the original post. The next step, as someone who may be Evelyne de Leeuw from Australia wrote, is to try to make the focus more health-oriented and less disease-oriented.
So, what do you think? Will a community arise organically to do this or is going to take concerted effort by a few people to create that community?
Some of the more utopian aspects of the web have enchanted many of us into giving credence to an "if you build it, they will come" mindset.
For me, the history of the "global health" entry on Wikipedia so far shows the limitations of that ideal (especially since already there is a new, more sophisticated round of self-promotion happening with external links to a number of academic centers). But I was heartened by the improvements that did happen. I suspect, however, that I may need the lifespan of an Ent to see the full flowering of the global health entry.
Or you could prove me wrong by taking a crack at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_health.
Not all conversations on the Web happen so fast and include so many partners that it makes your head spin. Some are so long and laborious that you might think the participants were Treebeard and the rest of Tolkien's Ents. Case in point: the 27-month long conversation behind Wikipedia's entry on "global health."
Back in June of 2005, a volunteer Wikipedia editor who went by the name "Drgregmartin" wrote a short entry on Wikipedia about "global health." A few months later, I came along and did a little copy-editing, added some historical context and a few external links.
By the fall of 2006, this short, not-great entry had morphed into something completely overgrown and unreadable. A number of anonymous users from several universities clearly decided to do a little self-promotion while others added several giant tangents or pet peeves. Eventually, the entry got flagged as "needing clean up."
So far, I have described the natural history of countless Wikipedia entries. An earnest soul writes a short piece, others discover it and soon so many editors have a hand in it that it morphs into something that is far worse than whatever it started off as. In the best circumstances, this chaotic phase settles down and editing becomes much more stable--and the writing and the rigor improve.
Trying to be a good Wikipedian, I started a conversation on the global_health talk page about how to fix the entry and get to the next, more stable phase of Wiki writing. My proposal was met with deafening silence.
Meanwhile, the entry was getting longer and less readable. I contemplated fixing things myself but figured I would be out-revised by the self-promoters. Every once in a while I would come back to check on things. The entry kept getting woolier and woolier. I chalked it up as a reality-check on how Wikipedia works: popular articles are more likely to be better.
But, every now and then, someone would add a comment on the talk page. In more than two years, there have in fact been seven responses--all fairly substantial. And here's the most intriguing thing: they actually can be read as a conversation with genuine give and take.
Gradually, a Wikipedian by the name of Useknowledge came along and edited the entry back to a form that is more manageable.
It is still not perfect, but it is an improvement over the original post. The next step, as someone who may be Evelyne de Leeuw from Australia wrote, is to try to make the focus more health-oriented and less disease-oriented.
So, what do you think? Will a community arise organically to do this or is going to take concerted effort by a few people to create that community?
Some of the more utopian aspects of the web have enchanted many of us into giving credence to an "if you build it, they will come" mindset.
For me, the history of the "global health" entry on Wikipedia so far shows the limitations of that ideal (especially since already there is a new, more sophisticated round of self-promotion happening with external links to a number of academic centers). But I was heartened by the improvements that did happen. I suspect, however, that I may need the lifespan of an Ent to see the full flowering of the global health entry.
Or you could prove me wrong by taking a crack at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_health.
Wednesday, 18 February 2009
Looking for Context in Global Health Reporting
To me, the most satisfying news stories are the ones that provide a context that continues to inform long after the news has turned old. That kind of deeper context is often what I look for in global health stories but do not usually find. Something to think about if you are hoping to improve the routine coverage of global health news.
I am thinking about this now for several reasons. Sharon Schmickle’s amazing article today in the Washington Post on the growing global threat of wheat rust—she provides plenty of context—finally got me to write these thoughts down.
When Josh Benton of the Nieman Foundation was in New York a couple weeks ago, we had a long chat about what constitutes context in news stories. (That's the kind of stuff we enjoy talking about.) He told me about Matt Johnson’s project at the University of Missouri’s Reynolds Journalism Institute.
As I understand it, Matt’s key insight came when he read decades worth of stories about commercial development in and around Columbia, Missouri. He realized he didn’t feel any better informed about the major factors, developers and politicians involved after reading one or 100 stories. Each story had to be taken on its own—separate from the others. The long-term context did not emerge from reading all those stories. It was all information overload with no meaning.
Johnson’s project is to see if there is a way to make that context more explicit, so that each news item about development either contributes to the context or benefits from it. What Matt Johnson says about the search for more context in the news makes a lot of sense to me.
In January, Jeb Sharp of PRI’s The World launched a new history podcast called “How We Got Here.” It looks at the history that continues to shape current events. Her inaugural piece was about Iran—because of all the talk about the incoming Obama Administration’s possible diplomatic outreach to that country.
But Sharp’s reporting on the three weeks in 1953 in which CIA agent Kermit Roosevelt nearly single-handedly engineered a coup in Iran provided some of the missing context that I was looking for in an entirely different story. Namely, it helped me understand a little better why the Iranian government recently tried and convicted a pair of Iranian AIDS doctors for conspiring to foment a “velvet revolution” by attending international medical conferences.
Earlier this month, Ethan Zuckerman, co-founder of Global Voices, wrote a very good piece that provides the missing context around the recent unrest in Madagascar. I have actually been following this in the news—in the New York Times and on the web. But nothing explained WHY this was happening NOW in the way that Ethan’s blog post did.
It makes me think of David Pogue’s Missing Manuals enterprise. You know, computer software doesn’t ship with printed instructional material any more. You have to either go online or screen through an electronic manual. But a lot of us still find a book a useful way to organize information—to get the broader view. So when software companies stopped supplying physical manuals, Pogue stepped into the gap with his Missing Manual series.
Supplying the missing context turned out to be a good business model for Pogue. Makes me wonder if that case is transferable to reporting about global health?
I am thinking about this now for several reasons. Sharon Schmickle’s amazing article today in the Washington Post on the growing global threat of wheat rust—she provides plenty of context—finally got me to write these thoughts down.
When Josh Benton of the Nieman Foundation was in New York a couple weeks ago, we had a long chat about what constitutes context in news stories. (That's the kind of stuff we enjoy talking about.) He told me about Matt Johnson’s project at the University of Missouri’s Reynolds Journalism Institute.
As I understand it, Matt’s key insight came when he read decades worth of stories about commercial development in and around Columbia, Missouri. He realized he didn’t feel any better informed about the major factors, developers and politicians involved after reading one or 100 stories. Each story had to be taken on its own—separate from the others. The long-term context did not emerge from reading all those stories. It was all information overload with no meaning.
Johnson’s project is to see if there is a way to make that context more explicit, so that each news item about development either contributes to the context or benefits from it. What Matt Johnson says about the search for more context in the news makes a lot of sense to me.
In January, Jeb Sharp of PRI’s The World launched a new history podcast called “How We Got Here.” It looks at the history that continues to shape current events. Her inaugural piece was about Iran—because of all the talk about the incoming Obama Administration’s possible diplomatic outreach to that country.
But Sharp’s reporting on the three weeks in 1953 in which CIA agent Kermit Roosevelt nearly single-handedly engineered a coup in Iran provided some of the missing context that I was looking for in an entirely different story. Namely, it helped me understand a little better why the Iranian government recently tried and convicted a pair of Iranian AIDS doctors for conspiring to foment a “velvet revolution” by attending international medical conferences.
Earlier this month, Ethan Zuckerman, co-founder of Global Voices, wrote a very good piece that provides the missing context around the recent unrest in Madagascar. I have actually been following this in the news—in the New York Times and on the web. But nothing explained WHY this was happening NOW in the way that Ethan’s blog post did.
It makes me think of David Pogue’s Missing Manuals enterprise. You know, computer software doesn’t ship with printed instructional material any more. You have to either go online or screen through an electronic manual. But a lot of us still find a book a useful way to organize information—to get the broader view. So when software companies stopped supplying physical manuals, Pogue stepped into the gap with his Missing Manual series.
Supplying the missing context turned out to be a good business model for Pogue. Makes me wonder if that case is transferable to reporting about global health?
Friday, 30 January 2009
Update on the Global Health Blogging Experiment
Thank you to all who participated in our little "global health blogging experiment." Nine posts on "prevention vs. treatment" were published--out of an expected 12. Respectable numbers for an all-volunteer effort.
I do not have much time to write today, alas, but wanted to leave you with at least one thought. I was particularly intrigued that Liz Borkowski pointed us to a larger story--the gradual abandonment of anti-tobacco/anti-smoking programs in the U.S. That's the kind of piece--big and slow-moving--that can be very hard to get a grip on in the traditional media. And precisely the sort of thing that can thrive on the web.
An example comes to mind from well outside the global health sphere--how the folks at Talking Points Memo aggregated their own reporting with that of disparate professional journalists to tell the story of the number of US attorneys who had been fired under the Bush Administration for not toeing the line politically. (The TPM, incidentally, also won a George Polk Award for Journalism for its work.)
Anyway, I hope folks look at the other entries and post their own responses/analyses/constructive critiques. So, without further ado, here are the other global health posts on "prevention vs. treatment."
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
I do not have much time to write today, alas, but wanted to leave you with at least one thought. I was particularly intrigued that Liz Borkowski pointed us to a larger story--the gradual abandonment of anti-tobacco/anti-smoking programs in the U.S. That's the kind of piece--big and slow-moving--that can be very hard to get a grip on in the traditional media. And precisely the sort of thing that can thrive on the web.
An example comes to mind from well outside the global health sphere--how the folks at Talking Points Memo aggregated their own reporting with that of disparate professional journalists to tell the story of the number of US attorneys who had been fired under the Bush Administration for not toeing the line politically. (The TPM, incidentally, also won a George Polk Award for Journalism for its work.)
Anyway, I hope folks look at the other entries and post their own responses/analyses/constructive critiques. So, without further ado, here are the other global health posts on "prevention vs. treatment."
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
Thursday, 29 January 2009
Prevention vs. Treatment: A False Choice
The long-running debate over the relative importance of prevention or treatment is the theme that at least a dozen global health bloggers are exploring today. In many ways, the debate represents a false choice; a well-functioning health system requires both prevention and treatment. But how do you strike the right balance? Is the measuring stick simply the one provided by economics? Or do equity and fairness also play a role?
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” or so the old saying goes. But we don’t always practice what our folk wisdom preaches.
The U.S. medical system, as currently set up, rewards cardiac surgeons at a much greater rate than it does programs for avoiding weight gain or controlling high blood pressure.
About 5% or less of the U.S. budget on health care is spent on prevention, according to Don Wright of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Most of the rest is spent on treatment—and, I would venture to guess, paper work.
And yet, you can bet that if I ever experience a gripping pain in my chest or back, accompanied by nausea and perhaps an overwhelming sense of anxiety—classic signs of a heart attack in women—I am going to get myself to an emergency room right away to get treated and be mighty thankful if the specialists at the cardiac catheterization lab can open up any blocked arteries.
The year I spent at Harvard taught me a lot about how academics argue the prevention vs. treatment debate. Indeed, just a few years ago there was that rare thing in public health—a big public debate between some folks at the Gates Foundation on one side and some at Harvard on the other about whether prevention or treatment was the better—read more “cost-effective”—approach to tackling HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Eventually the Harvard side won the argument—especially once the cost of anti-retroviral therapy dropped dramatically. What made the difference was the fairness issue: How could you withhold treatment when so many were dying?
A few months in rural Malawi gave me a whole other perspective. There I learned that tremendous strides have been made in decreasing maternal death rates at the Embangweni Mission Hospital through a variety of efforts—not least of which was an emphasis on both prevention and treatment.
It did not happen by accident and it did not happen overnight. When the effort began, several years ago, there was only a single sink in the labor and delivery room. So improving the physical plant was a priority in terms of providing better treatment. Embangweni Hospital also worked really hard to get the right people in the ward—namely more nurses and clinical officers—and keep up their training. Alas, hard experience also taught them they had to make the ward off-limits to many of the grandmothers or “gogos,” who would slip their daughters and daughters-in-law a powerful herbal concoction to induce labor but that also increased the risk of potentially fatal uterine rupture.
On the prevention side, community health nurses have been working throughout the South Mzimbe region for the past ten years to provide prenatal care to pregnant women. To give just one example, the community health workers I met, like Joyce Ngoma and Tamala Chirwa, work hard to identify women who may have trouble delivering—because they are carrying twins or the fetus is not positioned properly. The nurses advise those women to go to the hospital early so that they can be watched more closely and scheduled for a caesarean operation, if need be.
Each side—prevention and treatment—benefits from the other. With fewer pregnant women showing up at the hospital in crisis, the clinical officers and nurses there are able to save more mothers' lives. The nurses in the field can see that their efforts have saved lives and are encouraged to do more prevention work.
Today's posts on Prevention vs. Treatment from other global health blogs (as I learn of them):
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” or so the old saying goes. But we don’t always practice what our folk wisdom preaches.
The U.S. medical system, as currently set up, rewards cardiac surgeons at a much greater rate than it does programs for avoiding weight gain or controlling high blood pressure.
About 5% or less of the U.S. budget on health care is spent on prevention, according to Don Wright of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Most of the rest is spent on treatment—and, I would venture to guess, paper work.
And yet, you can bet that if I ever experience a gripping pain in my chest or back, accompanied by nausea and perhaps an overwhelming sense of anxiety—classic signs of a heart attack in women—I am going to get myself to an emergency room right away to get treated and be mighty thankful if the specialists at the cardiac catheterization lab can open up any blocked arteries.
The year I spent at Harvard taught me a lot about how academics argue the prevention vs. treatment debate. Indeed, just a few years ago there was that rare thing in public health—a big public debate between some folks at the Gates Foundation on one side and some at Harvard on the other about whether prevention or treatment was the better—read more “cost-effective”—approach to tackling HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Eventually the Harvard side won the argument—especially once the cost of anti-retroviral therapy dropped dramatically. What made the difference was the fairness issue: How could you withhold treatment when so many were dying?
A few months in rural Malawi gave me a whole other perspective. There I learned that tremendous strides have been made in decreasing maternal death rates at the Embangweni Mission Hospital through a variety of efforts—not least of which was an emphasis on both prevention and treatment.
It did not happen by accident and it did not happen overnight. When the effort began, several years ago, there was only a single sink in the labor and delivery room. So improving the physical plant was a priority in terms of providing better treatment. Embangweni Hospital also worked really hard to get the right people in the ward—namely more nurses and clinical officers—and keep up their training. Alas, hard experience also taught them they had to make the ward off-limits to many of the grandmothers or “gogos,” who would slip their daughters and daughters-in-law a powerful herbal concoction to induce labor but that also increased the risk of potentially fatal uterine rupture.
On the prevention side, community health nurses have been working throughout the South Mzimbe region for the past ten years to provide prenatal care to pregnant women. To give just one example, the community health workers I met, like Joyce Ngoma and Tamala Chirwa, work hard to identify women who may have trouble delivering—because they are carrying twins or the fetus is not positioned properly. The nurses advise those women to go to the hospital early so that they can be watched more closely and scheduled for a caesarean operation, if need be.
Each side—prevention and treatment—benefits from the other. With fewer pregnant women showing up at the hospital in crisis, the clinical officers and nurses there are able to save more mothers' lives. The nurses in the field can see that their efforts have saved lives and are encouraged to do more prevention work.
Today's posts on Prevention vs. Treatment from other global health blogs (as I learn of them):
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
Tuesday, 27 January 2009
Community Organizing Meets Global Health Blogging
Towards building a social network around global health news.
At least a dozen global health bloggers have publicly said they will be posting on the broad theme of "prevention vs. treatment" this Thursday, January 29, 2009. (Feel free to join in!) This is part of an experiment that grew out of a Twitter conversation to see if we can coordinate posts in a kind of "global health blog carnival" to increase awareness of global health issues. I'll be posting about my experience in Malawi and reflecting on whether the prevention vs. treatment debate is really a false choice.
But there are some larger questions here that I would like to explore: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web? What can we do to nurture it? Do economic realities dictate that this will have to be a volunteer led endeavor, at least for a while?
Or, another way of putting that last question: Is news about global health subject to the same market failures that afflict products for global health (e.g. free-market forces alone will not lead to new tuberculosis medications and other drugs that affect mostly the poorest people in the world)?
Some preliminary thoughts on the first question: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web?
Although blogging has been around for a while, we haven't really had the critical mass of bloggers interested in global health issues until recently.
International news coverage has suffered terribly in the retrenchment affecting the journalism industry. There are efforts to do something about that. The Gates Foundation is funding more coverage of global health issues at National Public Radio, Public Radio International and on television's The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer. The new kid on the block is Global Post, which I am happy to say, has a global health correspondent in South Africa. And let's not forget Global Voices Online, whose international health reporting is growing.
The British newspaper The Guardian is partnering with AMREF, an NGO dedicated to medical relief in Africa, to report development news from the Ugandan village of Katine. (See Laura Oliver's post on a UK journalism blog for news on the project's growing pains. Larry Hollon also has thoughts at Perspectives.)
I suspect we have only scratched the surface. In my view, a true social network for global health news would go far beyond encouraging comments, cross-linking, blog carnivals and re-tweeting. But those are the first steps.
Note to self and others: the news innovation barcamp for entrepreneurial journalists at the University of Missouri last week may give us some ideas for how to share ideas, organize efforts. They have created an online site for collaboration among groups of like-minded people (journalists and non-journalists) who want to explore new ideas for news coverage but have low or no budgets for experimentation.
At least a dozen global health bloggers have publicly said they will be posting on the broad theme of "prevention vs. treatment" this Thursday, January 29, 2009. (Feel free to join in!) This is part of an experiment that grew out of a Twitter conversation to see if we can coordinate posts in a kind of "global health blog carnival" to increase awareness of global health issues. I'll be posting about my experience in Malawi and reflecting on whether the prevention vs. treatment debate is really a false choice.
But there are some larger questions here that I would like to explore: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web? What can we do to nurture it? Do economic realities dictate that this will have to be a volunteer led endeavor, at least for a while?
Or, another way of putting that last question: Is news about global health subject to the same market failures that afflict products for global health (e.g. free-market forces alone will not lead to new tuberculosis medications and other drugs that affect mostly the poorest people in the world)?
Some preliminary thoughts on the first question: Is a social network around global health news starting to emerge organically on the web?
Although blogging has been around for a while, we haven't really had the critical mass of bloggers interested in global health issues until recently.
International news coverage has suffered terribly in the retrenchment affecting the journalism industry. There are efforts to do something about that. The Gates Foundation is funding more coverage of global health issues at National Public Radio, Public Radio International and on television's The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer. The new kid on the block is Global Post, which I am happy to say, has a global health correspondent in South Africa. And let's not forget Global Voices Online, whose international health reporting is growing.
The British newspaper The Guardian is partnering with AMREF, an NGO dedicated to medical relief in Africa, to report development news from the Ugandan village of Katine. (See Laura Oliver's post on a UK journalism blog for news on the project's growing pains. Larry Hollon also has thoughts at Perspectives.)
I suspect we have only scratched the surface. In my view, a true social network for global health news would go far beyond encouraging comments, cross-linking, blog carnivals and re-tweeting. But those are the first steps.
Note to self and others: the news innovation barcamp for entrepreneurial journalists at the University of Missouri last week may give us some ideas for how to share ideas, organize efforts. They have created an online site for collaboration among groups of like-minded people (journalists and non-journalists) who want to explore new ideas for news coverage but have low or no budgets for experimentation.
Thursday, 15 January 2009
Proposed: Global Health Blogging Experiment
Reading Jon Shaffer's post on three top debates in global health gave me an idea. What if we organized a bunch of global health bloggers to coordinate their posts around a single topic and then picked a day where we agreed to post them all? It might increase the visibility of some of the deeper issues in global health.
Each blogger would take the part of the debate that had the most resonance to them. Say, for example, the topic were "prevention vs. treatment." Maryn McKenna might write about it in the case of antibiotic resistance. I might write about it in the community health vs hospital context. Alanna Shaikh might write about it based on her experiences in Central Asia. Then we would update our individual posts with links to what the others had to say.
You might think of it as a blog carnival (defined as "a rotating showcase of interesting writing from around the blogosphere within a particular discipline"), although that may be too organized for our first effort. The most exciting part is that we're starting to get enough of a critical mass of global health bloggers that this is even possible. What do you think?
Each blogger would take the part of the debate that had the most resonance to them. Say, for example, the topic were "prevention vs. treatment." Maryn McKenna might write about it in the case of antibiotic resistance. I might write about it in the community health vs hospital context. Alanna Shaikh might write about it based on her experiences in Central Asia. Then we would update our individual posts with links to what the others had to say.
You might think of it as a blog carnival (defined as "a rotating showcase of interesting writing from around the blogosphere within a particular discipline"), although that may be too organized for our first effort. The most exciting part is that we're starting to get enough of a critical mass of global health bloggers that this is even possible. What do you think?
Monday, 8 December 2008
Sharing and Global Health Blogging
How can we get more coverage of global health news when old media doesn’t seem to want to do it without outside support and new media (blogs, texting, sharedmedia) still seems a scattershot affair?
This is the fourth post in a series that began with “Rethinking Why I Blog.” The others are “What Plumpy’Nut Taught Me” and “Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing.”
One of my goals for my Nieman fellowship year was to develop a business plan for a web-based global health news service. I know, I know, “news service” is such a quaint phrase, reminiscent of teletype, telegraphs and Morse code. But it is descriptive. If it’s too old-fashioned for you, think “content platform.”
The idea was to aggregate posts from around the globe as well as to provide funding for original reporting. I further focused the goal by targeting transparency issues in global health funding by eight major organizations. I developed the plan as part of a class on non-profits that I took at the Kennedy School and pitched it to the Open Society and Ashoka folks. Both decided to pass.
Nowadays, though, I’m wondering if maybe I was just trying too hard or too soon? After all, I keep seeing efforts by individuals to write about what they find interesting or newsworthy in global health. The ones I find most interesting are not promotional or advocacy-oriented but rather add context and highlight overlooked news.
In addition to established blogs from academics in the field, e.g. Effect Measure, The Pump Handle, Aetiology, there are a few more student blogs, like these efforts from Karen Grepin at Harvard, GlobeMed at Northwestern University and Unacceptable from Brigham Young University. See others on my blogroll at right.
(Mostly US-generated, I know. Send me your recommendations for global health blogs from other countries using the comment section below!! I haven't been bowled over by what I have read in the health section of Global Voices Online. )
The development community is farther along in self-publishing. See especially blogs from organizations like DFID and the Center for Global Development as well as DFID-funded Scidev.net. While trolling Twitter, I found “Blood and Milk,” a clear-eyed view by Alanna Shaikh of just how ethically challenged anti-poverty work can be despite good intentions.
Now that the Gates Foundation is investing in mainstream news organizations so they can cover global health news, you might say we don’t need individual efforts at reporting and commenting any more. Who needs amateurs, who post between bouts of norovirus or grant applications, when you can hire professionals [irony alert]?
And yet they write.
Update: PharmD+'s list of 100 global health blogs--three of mine are included, one of which is no longer active. But others on the list haven't been updated for quite a while either, e.g. BrownforGlobalHealth (last post Sept. 2007) and Don Burke's Global Health Blog (last post Jan. 2008).
This is the fourth post in a series that began with “Rethinking Why I Blog.” The others are “What Plumpy’Nut Taught Me” and “Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing.”
One of my goals for my Nieman fellowship year was to develop a business plan for a web-based global health news service. I know, I know, “news service” is such a quaint phrase, reminiscent of teletype, telegraphs and Morse code. But it is descriptive. If it’s too old-fashioned for you, think “content platform.”
The idea was to aggregate posts from around the globe as well as to provide funding for original reporting. I further focused the goal by targeting transparency issues in global health funding by eight major organizations. I developed the plan as part of a class on non-profits that I took at the Kennedy School and pitched it to the Open Society and Ashoka folks. Both decided to pass.
Nowadays, though, I’m wondering if maybe I was just trying too hard or too soon? After all, I keep seeing efforts by individuals to write about what they find interesting or newsworthy in global health. The ones I find most interesting are not promotional or advocacy-oriented but rather add context and highlight overlooked news.
In addition to established blogs from academics in the field, e.g. Effect Measure, The Pump Handle, Aetiology, there are a few more student blogs, like these efforts from Karen Grepin at Harvard, GlobeMed at Northwestern University and Unacceptable from Brigham Young University. See others on my blogroll at right.
(Mostly US-generated, I know. Send me your recommendations for global health blogs from other countries using the comment section below!! I haven't been bowled over by what I have read in the health section of Global Voices Online. )
The development community is farther along in self-publishing. See especially blogs from organizations like DFID and the Center for Global Development as well as DFID-funded Scidev.net. While trolling Twitter, I found “Blood and Milk,” a clear-eyed view by Alanna Shaikh of just how ethically challenged anti-poverty work can be despite good intentions.
Now that the Gates Foundation is investing in mainstream news organizations so they can cover global health news, you might say we don’t need individual efforts at reporting and commenting any more. Who needs amateurs, who post between bouts of norovirus or grant applications, when you can hire professionals [irony alert]?
And yet they write.
Update: PharmD+'s list of 100 global health blogs--three of mine are included, one of which is no longer active. But others on the list haven't been updated for quite a while either, e.g. BrownforGlobalHealth (last post Sept. 2007) and Don Burke's Global Health Blog (last post Jan. 2008).
Monday, 1 December 2008
New Gates Grant for Global Health News
An announcement is due later today from The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer that the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is giving WETA, co-producer of The NewsHour, a $3.5 million grant over the next three years to cover global health issues. Foundation-funding of publicly funded news programs like The NewsHour is becoming more and more important as other sources of money, like corporate-funding, dry up.
Other recent investments in global health news coverage by the Gates Foundation include:
1. A nearly $1 million, three-year grant for National Public Radio in 2006.
2. A $5 million, three-year grant for Public Radio International in 2007.
This latest move suggests the Gates Foundation has made a strategic decision to fund news-coverage directly, as opposed to, say, training for journalists in global health issues. In 2007, the Gates Foundation gave the Knight Foundation $1.7 million over three years for health fellowships for journalists in sub-Saharan Africa. Earlier this year, however, the Gates Foundation chose not to renew its three-year grant to the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard.
The Nieman Foundation is continuing its global health program—although it will award two fellowships next year instead of three.
I’m very interested to see how the Gates-funded NewsHour navigates the challenge of reporting on global health programs that are funded by the Gates Foundation and of interviewing experts who are also receiving funding from the Gates Foundation.
Full disclosure: I received a 2008 Nieman Fellowship for Global Health Reporting. The Gates Foundation had no say in the choice of my field project. And I dealt with even the potential appearance of a conflict-of-interest issue by focusing on the nursing brain drain in Malawi—an issue that, as far as I can tell, has received no Gates funding.
Updated to add Knight Foundation information.
Other recent investments in global health news coverage by the Gates Foundation include:
1. A nearly $1 million, three-year grant for National Public Radio in 2006.
2. A $5 million, three-year grant for Public Radio International in 2007.
This latest move suggests the Gates Foundation has made a strategic decision to fund news-coverage directly, as opposed to, say, training for journalists in global health issues. In 2007, the Gates Foundation gave the Knight Foundation $1.7 million over three years for health fellowships for journalists in sub-Saharan Africa. Earlier this year, however, the Gates Foundation chose not to renew its three-year grant to the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard.
The Nieman Foundation is continuing its global health program—although it will award two fellowships next year instead of three.
I’m very interested to see how the Gates-funded NewsHour navigates the challenge of reporting on global health programs that are funded by the Gates Foundation and of interviewing experts who are also receiving funding from the Gates Foundation.
Full disclosure: I received a 2008 Nieman Fellowship for Global Health Reporting. The Gates Foundation had no say in the choice of my field project. And I dealt with even the potential appearance of a conflict-of-interest issue by focusing on the nursing brain drain in Malawi—an issue that, as far as I can tell, has received no Gates funding.
Updated to add Knight Foundation information.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)