And now for a little global health gossip--in between reading dispatches from the World Health Assembly, which is meeting in Geneva this week . . .
Barbara Hogan is out as South Africa's Health Minister--just a few days after being named one of Time Magazine's 100 Most Influential People in the World. Was she too outspoken about the need for greater transparency and accountability for South Africa's AIDS treatment programs? Too critical about the government's refusal to issue a visa to the Dalai Lama? Is the ANC government that petty? Or is this just normal shuffling of cabinet positions? South Africa watchers are taking a watch-and-see approach--especially since the new Health Minister, who comes from Limpopo, is not widely known.
Paul Farmer has told colleagues he is contemplating a possible position with the U.S. government.
And in other news,
Eric Goosby, who has been tapped by President Obama to replace Mark Dybul as U.S. Global AIDS Coordinator (head of PEPFAR), will be speaking at the Global Business Coalition on AIDS annual conference June 23-24 in Washington, DC. Dybul will be there as well in his new role as co-director, with Larry Gostin, of the Global Health Law Center at Georgetown University. (Dybul joined Georgetown in February).
Thomas Frieden, New York City's health commissioner, is Obama's pick to head up the Centers for Disease Control. Revere, in his unique way, highlights some of the challenges Frieden will face.
And if you're in Washington, D.C. for the Global Health Coalition annual conference, don't miss Katrin Verclas on Wednesday morning, May 27. She organized the excellent barcamp conference on Mobile Tech For Social Change that I attended in New York City back in February and is a crackerjack organizer and advocate for what mobile phones can do for health, finance, accessing the Internet, changing the world.
Oh, and this just in. . . the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, just won the $1 million Gates Award for Global Health, given out each year at the Global Health Coalition meeting.
Showing posts with label notes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label notes. Show all posts
Monday, 18 May 2009
Monday, 11 May 2009
Human Health Effects of DDT
Several folks, after reading my last post on DDT, have asked me about DDT's health effects on people. Their point: while DDT may prevent some people from dying of malaria isn't there a cost to their long-term health?
Once again, context is key. The major negative effects of DDT have been on animals--particularly birds and fish. This is very important and not something the environment can sustain, especially since DDT accumulates in any animal's fat tissue (including people's).
As far as we know, DDT's health effects on people are minimal compared to that on fish and birds--something that was straightforwardly acknowledged last year on the website of the World Resources Institute, where Al Gore serves on the board of directors.
More recently there has been some research to indicate that DDT may act as a hormone disrupter and affect fertility as well as promote premature delivery. Animal studies have also suggested a possible cancer risk--but once again that would presumably be at very high dose.
So, if you are just going to look at health effects in people, the scales tip toward using DDT in those parts of sub-Saharan Africa in particular where it would be most helpful.
This is the same kind of cost-benefit ratio that is seen with giving polio vaccines that also sometimes cause the disease itself.
The cost to the environment is the more worrying issue--and something that needs to be addressed whenever DDT is used as part of an anti-malaria program. Fortunately, the amount of DDT that is needed for residential spraying is small. South Africa has shown the spraying can be done with minimal impact on the environment--by training sprayers and making sure no DDT is diverted to agricultural use.
It's a fascinating topic--and hard to find experts who are truly impartial. In my experience of reporting on the topic, people from both the left and right use DDT to score political points without regard to what facts are like on the ground.
Makes me think I should look more closely at the latest report that the World Health Organization has decided to work towards the total elimination of DDT, perhaps even in malarial zones.
Related posts:
Back and Forth on DDT Again
Can Malaria Be Eradicated?
Once again, context is key. The major negative effects of DDT have been on animals--particularly birds and fish. This is very important and not something the environment can sustain, especially since DDT accumulates in any animal's fat tissue (including people's).
As far as we know, DDT's health effects on people are minimal compared to that on fish and birds--something that was straightforwardly acknowledged last year on the website of the World Resources Institute, where Al Gore serves on the board of directors.
More recently there has been some research to indicate that DDT may act as a hormone disrupter and affect fertility as well as promote premature delivery. Animal studies have also suggested a possible cancer risk--but once again that would presumably be at very high dose.
So, if you are just going to look at health effects in people, the scales tip toward using DDT in those parts of sub-Saharan Africa in particular where it would be most helpful.
This is the same kind of cost-benefit ratio that is seen with giving polio vaccines that also sometimes cause the disease itself.
The cost to the environment is the more worrying issue--and something that needs to be addressed whenever DDT is used as part of an anti-malaria program. Fortunately, the amount of DDT that is needed for residential spraying is small. South Africa has shown the spraying can be done with minimal impact on the environment--by training sprayers and making sure no DDT is diverted to agricultural use.
It's a fascinating topic--and hard to find experts who are truly impartial. In my experience of reporting on the topic, people from both the left and right use DDT to score political points without regard to what facts are like on the ground.
Makes me think I should look more closely at the latest report that the World Health Organization has decided to work towards the total elimination of DDT, perhaps even in malarial zones.
Related posts:
Back and Forth on DDT Again
Can Malaria Be Eradicated?
Friday, 24 April 2009
Killing River Blindness and Malaria With the Same Drug
Researchers ponder whether a common drug that kills parasitic worms (helminths) might also prevent mosquitoes from transmitting malaria. The work is more preliminary than most in the field of malaria research, so don’t expect it to save any lives any time soon—if ever. But it is an interesting application of the old adage about trying “to kill two birds with one stone.”
In anticipation of World Malaria Day (which is tomorrow), the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation held its first telephone briefing for bloggers who cover global health.
There were three researchers on the line—each of whom had won a $100,000 grant to explore an idea for fighting malaria that was a little unorthodox or “out of the box.” These are part of the Grand Challenges Exploration grants that the Gates Foundation has championed in recent years. Depending on the results, grantees are eligible for $1 million grants to further prove their concepts.
I focused most of my attention on Brian Foy, an assistant professor at Colorado State University.
Foy, who has previously done some work on malaria vaccines, started thinking about the life cycle of the malaria parasite inside the mosquito as an under-explored route of attack. It takes 10 to 14 days for the malaria parasite to mature in a mosquito’s body--from the time a mosquito bites an infected person (what entomologists call “taking a blood meal”) to the time that same mosquito can transmit the parasite to a different person. “If you could just make one of those blood meals toxic to the mosquito, you would basically kill it before it could transmit the parasite,” Foy says.
Enter ivermectin, a drug that targets parasitic worms, like heartworms in dogs or the worms that cause river blindness in people in West Africa. Ivermectin works by targeting certain neurotransmission channels in worms. It turns out those same channels exist in other invertebrates like mosquitoes.
So the idea is to give ivermectin to people, who then pass the drug along with their blood to the mosquito that bites them. To be most effective, the drug should kill only those mosquitoes infected with the parasite before it has a chance to fully mature. As an added bonus, you minimize the risk of resistance because you’re not killing all the mosquitoes, just the infected ones, so there is no selection pressure against the mosquitoes—at least in theory.
So far, the evidence from the field is encouraging. Foy reported data from Senegal that showed that mosquitoes died for up to a week after ivermectin was given in an anti-river blindness campaign. Now he is trying to determine if the effect is large enough so that if you expanded ivermectin treatment you could actually change the transmission of malaria.
You see, ivermectin is normally given only once or twice a year for the treatment of river blindness. To have any effect on mosquitoes, you would probably have to give ivermectin once a month.
But this is just a pilot test—a chance to see if the idea is worth pursuing further.
You’re talking about four very complicated organisms—humans, mosquitoes, malaria parasites and helminths. In 2007, there was a research paper that suggested that infection with helminths actually made malaria symptoms less severe and that treating the parasitic worms could actually make a co-infection with malaria worse. (TW Mwangi, et al. Annals of Tropical Medical Parasitology.)
So for now, the idea that ivermectin could make a dent in both river blindness and malaria at the same time is still just an intriguing idea that is being tested further.
The other two presenters on the Gates telebriefing were Szabolcs Marka, assistant professor at Columbia University and Pradipsinh Rathod, professor at University of Washington.
Marka is looking at the possibility of using laser light to interfere with a mosquito’s ability to find and bite people. Rathod is trying to see if genetic differences between Plasmodium falciparum parasites found in Asia and those in Africa might help develop more effective treatments.
You can hear a recording of the full teleconference until April 30th by calling (800) 475-6701 and entering access code # 997326.
Full disclosure: my 2008 Nieman Fellowship in Global Health Reporting was supported by a grant from the Gates Foundation. I believe I have no conflict of interest in this story because the Gates Foundation did not play an active role in my choice of study or of my field project on nurses in Malawi.
In anticipation of World Malaria Day (which is tomorrow), the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation held its first telephone briefing for bloggers who cover global health.
There were three researchers on the line—each of whom had won a $100,000 grant to explore an idea for fighting malaria that was a little unorthodox or “out of the box.” These are part of the Grand Challenges Exploration grants that the Gates Foundation has championed in recent years. Depending on the results, grantees are eligible for $1 million grants to further prove their concepts.
I focused most of my attention on Brian Foy, an assistant professor at Colorado State University.
Foy, who has previously done some work on malaria vaccines, started thinking about the life cycle of the malaria parasite inside the mosquito as an under-explored route of attack. It takes 10 to 14 days for the malaria parasite to mature in a mosquito’s body--from the time a mosquito bites an infected person (what entomologists call “taking a blood meal”) to the time that same mosquito can transmit the parasite to a different person. “If you could just make one of those blood meals toxic to the mosquito, you would basically kill it before it could transmit the parasite,” Foy says.
Enter ivermectin, a drug that targets parasitic worms, like heartworms in dogs or the worms that cause river blindness in people in West Africa. Ivermectin works by targeting certain neurotransmission channels in worms. It turns out those same channels exist in other invertebrates like mosquitoes.
So the idea is to give ivermectin to people, who then pass the drug along with their blood to the mosquito that bites them. To be most effective, the drug should kill only those mosquitoes infected with the parasite before it has a chance to fully mature. As an added bonus, you minimize the risk of resistance because you’re not killing all the mosquitoes, just the infected ones, so there is no selection pressure against the mosquitoes—at least in theory.
So far, the evidence from the field is encouraging. Foy reported data from Senegal that showed that mosquitoes died for up to a week after ivermectin was given in an anti-river blindness campaign. Now he is trying to determine if the effect is large enough so that if you expanded ivermectin treatment you could actually change the transmission of malaria.
You see, ivermectin is normally given only once or twice a year for the treatment of river blindness. To have any effect on mosquitoes, you would probably have to give ivermectin once a month.
But this is just a pilot test—a chance to see if the idea is worth pursuing further.
You’re talking about four very complicated organisms—humans, mosquitoes, malaria parasites and helminths. In 2007, there was a research paper that suggested that infection with helminths actually made malaria symptoms less severe and that treating the parasitic worms could actually make a co-infection with malaria worse. (TW Mwangi, et al. Annals of Tropical Medical Parasitology.)
So for now, the idea that ivermectin could make a dent in both river blindness and malaria at the same time is still just an intriguing idea that is being tested further.
The other two presenters on the Gates telebriefing were Szabolcs Marka, assistant professor at Columbia University and Pradipsinh Rathod, professor at University of Washington.
Marka is looking at the possibility of using laser light to interfere with a mosquito’s ability to find and bite people. Rathod is trying to see if genetic differences between Plasmodium falciparum parasites found in Asia and those in Africa might help develop more effective treatments.
You can hear a recording of the full teleconference until April 30th by calling (800) 475-6701 and entering access code # 997326.
Full disclosure: my 2008 Nieman Fellowship in Global Health Reporting was supported by a grant from the Gates Foundation. I believe I have no conflict of interest in this story because the Gates Foundation did not play an active role in my choice of study or of my field project on nurses in Malawi.
Tuesday, 21 April 2009
More Thoughts on Schools, Hospitals and Health
Yesterday's writeup of my notes about social determinants of health from the annual conference of the Association of Health Care Journalists focused a lot on the graphical sin of using circles (which tend to show equality) in an area where equality does not exist.
Just as important is the realization that when it comes to developing a recipe for promoting health, you cannot leave any of the important ingredients out--no matter if it is just a quarter of a teaspoon (a small amount) or a pound of something (a large amount).
So, while schools/general education may be more important than hospitals/health services in coming up with a recipe for promoting the overall health of a population, you cannot ignore the contribution of health services.
I was first introduced to this idea of how various factors relate to each other in David Bloom's class at the Harvard School of Public Health--although, being a health economist, he didn't talk about cooking and recipes. He talked about addition and multiplication.
More specifically, he told the class of future public health experts that they would eventually have to decide whether to think of health as a multiplicative process or an additive one. If additive, then the various factors that contribute to the health of a population (however you rank them) simply add up to whatever sum--and if one of those factors is zero, well, that's not fatal because the others will make up for it.
On the other hand, if achieving health is a multiplicative process, then any factor along the line whose value is zero ends up negating the whole effect.
As in 2 + 1 + 3 + 2 = 8
But 2 x 0 x 3 x 2 = 0
Changing a single one of the factors to zero negates the contribution of every other factor.
Just as important is the realization that when it comes to developing a recipe for promoting health, you cannot leave any of the important ingredients out--no matter if it is just a quarter of a teaspoon (a small amount) or a pound of something (a large amount).
So, while schools/general education may be more important than hospitals/health services in coming up with a recipe for promoting the overall health of a population, you cannot ignore the contribution of health services.
I was first introduced to this idea of how various factors relate to each other in David Bloom's class at the Harvard School of Public Health--although, being a health economist, he didn't talk about cooking and recipes. He talked about addition and multiplication.
More specifically, he told the class of future public health experts that they would eventually have to decide whether to think of health as a multiplicative process or an additive one. If additive, then the various factors that contribute to the health of a population (however you rank them) simply add up to whatever sum--and if one of those factors is zero, well, that's not fatal because the others will make up for it.
On the other hand, if achieving health is a multiplicative process, then any factor along the line whose value is zero ends up negating the whole effect.
As in 2 + 1 + 3 + 2 = 8
But 2 x 0 x 3 x 2 = 0
Changing a single one of the factors to zero negates the contribution of every other factor.
Monday, 20 April 2009
Schools Are Better than Hospitals for Improving Health
Education, social support and early childhood development play a more important role in determining the overall health of a country’s population than the condition of their hospitals and other health services, according to researchers who look at the social determinants of health.
Oh what a difference a choice of graphic makes!
If you think about it for just five minutes, you know that it’s not just doctors, nurses, hospitals and pills that determine how healthy we are. Those critical health services are part of an entire constellation that includes our genetic makeup, personal choices, the physical environment we live in (to overstate the obvious, it’s hard to stay healthy in a war zone), our social support, educational level and socioeconomic status.
Here is the way that Canadian public health officials visualize all these factors on an official government website—as spokes coming off a central hub.

The hub-and-spoke diagram makes it seem as if all these factors are playing equal roles in determining how healthy a given population is.
But what if you ranked those factors in order of importance?
That’s what Michael Hayes of Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada and Stephen Bezruchka of the University of Washington did in a panel discussion at the annual meeting of the Association of Health Care Journalists in Seattle on Saturday, April 18, 2009. (Search twitter for #ahcj09 to get some of the raw tweets published during the conference.)
Hayes and Bezruchka placed health services (the doctors-nurses-hospitals-clinics-medications part of the equation) at the absolute bottom of the list in importance. At the top of the list are social determinants, like education (particularly of mothers) and socioeconomic standing.
The whole list goes something like this, in order of importance:
Most Important
Social determinants of health (education, socioeconomic status, social support, etc)
Early childhood
Personal behavior
Physical Environment
Biology
Health Care Services
Least Important
This ordering of the list, which is based on 25 years worth of data, Hayes and Bezruchka said, leads to some startling conclusions. First off, we in the press focus far too much attention on health services (the docs, nurses, new treatments and medications) as opposed to education, crime rates, poverty when talking about health. Second, dollar for dollar, you would probably actually get a better health benefit investing disproportionately more in schools than in hospitals. And perhaps, third, Canadian public health officials need a new graphics team.
To develop that last point a little further. Don’t use circles when describing the factors that lead to health disparities. It makes everything seem equal. Use ranked lists that tell you what the most important factors are—provided, as always, you have the data to back it up.
What is still unclear to me is just how widespread the consensus is that social determinants of health are more important than health services in determining the overall health of any country’s citizens. (Chime in on comments below if you can enlighten us.)
I asked Hayes about consensus in a quick follow-up at the panel table prior to the start of the next session. He says there is consensus that there are social gradients to health and even what the major influences are but not on how they play out. One camp favors the psychosocial view: people who are optimists tend to be healthier and live longer than pessimists. The other camp is more materialist: poverty is key.
The point, Hayes said, is to link biology to social being. Then he gave a quick example. We tend to focus on the fact that smoking cigarettes is clearly a matter of personal choice, he said. But we ignore the role that advertising plays.
In my mind, I was thinking well, we haven’t really ignored advertising—I mean smoking was banned from television ads. But I guess there are still plenty of billboards, sports sponsorships, etc.
Earlier in the session, either Hayes or Bezruchka threw out the statement that the relative risk of dying from smoking in Japan is much lower than in the USA. And then strongly implied that social determinants of health (a better social safety net in Japan, more family support, etc) explained the difference.
It was a memorable line but begs to be checked out further. What are the absolute risks in both cases? (Even though I knew about the importance of absolute risk before I knew journalism professor Gary Schwitzer, I can hardly think of one without the other anymore.) What ways do smokers compare/differ in the US and Japan? (Seems like you would have to compare Japanese-American smokers to Japanese national smokers to be truly thorough.)
Later, I was reminded of a conversation I had had with a woman, who was a physician, who had developed tuberculosis. She would not have survived, she said, had it not been for her own mother and sisters, who kept her on track. They made sure she took her medications over the course of many months, even after the pills made her violently sick.
She knew intellectually that she had to continue her treatment but that was not enough to keep her alive. She needed the pills but that was not enough to keep her alive. Her knowledge, the pills and her family’s willingness to make sure she took them every day—even when she begged them not to—is what allowed her to survive.
For further reading on social determinants of health:
"Toward a Healthy Future"
The 1999 Canadian report that studied and quantified social determinants of behavior.
Bezruchka's webpage of resources on social factors in health inequalities (hat tip: @HoltzReport)
"Spreading the News: Social Determinants of Health Reportage in Canadian Daily Newspapers"
Hayes' own research into how much Canadian journalists are aware of the research on social determinants of health.
NB: This post is based on my writeup of my notes from AHCJ09.
Panel: "The healthy environment: it's not just medicine"
Panelist: Michael Hayes, Ph.D., associate dean, Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University
Panelist: Stephen A. Bezruchka, M.D., senior lecturer, Department of Global Health, University of Washington
Moderator: Andrew Holtz, M.P.H., independent journalist, Portland, Ore.
These notes are as accurate as I can make them but if you use any of this for a published piece, you should be sure to do your own reporting to double check it--as I will if I write it up for formal publication.
I'll post other notes from the AHCJ conference as I write them up.
Update (4/21/09): Here are a few more thoughts on how to think about the non-medical factors related to health and how they relate to health services and each other.
Oh what a difference a choice of graphic makes!
If you think about it for just five minutes, you know that it’s not just doctors, nurses, hospitals and pills that determine how healthy we are. Those critical health services are part of an entire constellation that includes our genetic makeup, personal choices, the physical environment we live in (to overstate the obvious, it’s hard to stay healthy in a war zone), our social support, educational level and socioeconomic status.
Here is the way that Canadian public health officials visualize all these factors on an official government website—as spokes coming off a central hub.

The hub-and-spoke diagram makes it seem as if all these factors are playing equal roles in determining how healthy a given population is.
But what if you ranked those factors in order of importance?
That’s what Michael Hayes of Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada and Stephen Bezruchka of the University of Washington did in a panel discussion at the annual meeting of the Association of Health Care Journalists in Seattle on Saturday, April 18, 2009. (Search twitter for #ahcj09 to get some of the raw tweets published during the conference.)
Hayes and Bezruchka placed health services (the doctors-nurses-hospitals-clinics-medications part of the equation) at the absolute bottom of the list in importance. At the top of the list are social determinants, like education (particularly of mothers) and socioeconomic standing.
The whole list goes something like this, in order of importance:
Most Important
Social determinants of health (education, socioeconomic status, social support, etc)
Early childhood
Personal behavior
Physical Environment
Biology
Health Care Services
Least Important
This ordering of the list, which is based on 25 years worth of data, Hayes and Bezruchka said, leads to some startling conclusions. First off, we in the press focus far too much attention on health services (the docs, nurses, new treatments and medications) as opposed to education, crime rates, poverty when talking about health. Second, dollar for dollar, you would probably actually get a better health benefit investing disproportionately more in schools than in hospitals. And perhaps, third, Canadian public health officials need a new graphics team.
To develop that last point a little further. Don’t use circles when describing the factors that lead to health disparities. It makes everything seem equal. Use ranked lists that tell you what the most important factors are—provided, as always, you have the data to back it up.
What is still unclear to me is just how widespread the consensus is that social determinants of health are more important than health services in determining the overall health of any country’s citizens. (Chime in on comments below if you can enlighten us.)
I asked Hayes about consensus in a quick follow-up at the panel table prior to the start of the next session. He says there is consensus that there are social gradients to health and even what the major influences are but not on how they play out. One camp favors the psychosocial view: people who are optimists tend to be healthier and live longer than pessimists. The other camp is more materialist: poverty is key.
The point, Hayes said, is to link biology to social being. Then he gave a quick example. We tend to focus on the fact that smoking cigarettes is clearly a matter of personal choice, he said. But we ignore the role that advertising plays.
In my mind, I was thinking well, we haven’t really ignored advertising—I mean smoking was banned from television ads. But I guess there are still plenty of billboards, sports sponsorships, etc.
Earlier in the session, either Hayes or Bezruchka threw out the statement that the relative risk of dying from smoking in Japan is much lower than in the USA. And then strongly implied that social determinants of health (a better social safety net in Japan, more family support, etc) explained the difference.
It was a memorable line but begs to be checked out further. What are the absolute risks in both cases? (Even though I knew about the importance of absolute risk before I knew journalism professor Gary Schwitzer, I can hardly think of one without the other anymore.) What ways do smokers compare/differ in the US and Japan? (Seems like you would have to compare Japanese-American smokers to Japanese national smokers to be truly thorough.)
Later, I was reminded of a conversation I had had with a woman, who was a physician, who had developed tuberculosis. She would not have survived, she said, had it not been for her own mother and sisters, who kept her on track. They made sure she took her medications over the course of many months, even after the pills made her violently sick.
She knew intellectually that she had to continue her treatment but that was not enough to keep her alive. She needed the pills but that was not enough to keep her alive. Her knowledge, the pills and her family’s willingness to make sure she took them every day—even when she begged them not to—is what allowed her to survive.
For further reading on social determinants of health:
"Toward a Healthy Future"
The 1999 Canadian report that studied and quantified social determinants of behavior.
Bezruchka's webpage of resources on social factors in health inequalities (hat tip: @HoltzReport)
"Spreading the News: Social Determinants of Health Reportage in Canadian Daily Newspapers"
Hayes' own research into how much Canadian journalists are aware of the research on social determinants of health.
NB: This post is based on my writeup of my notes from AHCJ09.
Panel: "The healthy environment: it's not just medicine"
Panelist: Michael Hayes, Ph.D., associate dean, Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University
Panelist: Stephen A. Bezruchka, M.D., senior lecturer, Department of Global Health, University of Washington
Moderator: Andrew Holtz, M.P.H., independent journalist, Portland, Ore.
These notes are as accurate as I can make them but if you use any of this for a published piece, you should be sure to do your own reporting to double check it--as I will if I write it up for formal publication.
I'll post other notes from the AHCJ conference as I write them up.
Update (4/21/09): Here are a few more thoughts on how to think about the non-medical factors related to health and how they relate to health services and each other.
Monday, 23 February 2009
Don’t Bury Failures. Share Them
Computer science students from the U.S. and Senegal designed a mobile phone application especially for fisherwomen in Senegal and yet, the Senegalese women could not use it because of a single flawed assumption.
I promised myself I would share at least one story from the MobileTech for Social Change Barcamp I attended at Hunter College in New York City on Saturday (Feb. 21, 2008). Barcamp, for those who may not know, is an approach to organizing and running conferences that tries to capture the hidden value of most meetings—the conversations that happen between sessions in the hallways—and bring it front and center. Barcamps are also supposed to be free, or nearly so, for participants to attend.
A computer science group from the State University of New York at Stonybrook presented three applications or “apps,” that is to say mini-computer programs, that they had designed for use on no-frills mobile phones owned by women working in the informal Senegalese economy. The pilot tests for two of the apps—a dictionary and a book-keeping calculator—were deemed successes. The third app—for measuring profit and loss—was judged a failure.
Since most people—myself included—don’t like to publish their failures, I was impressed by the Stonybrook group’s willingness to do so. Indeed, they were almost as enthusiastic about the failure as the two successes. “You often learn more from failure than success,” says Jennifer Wong, one of the two Stonybrook professors who, along with two students, came to present their findings. Sure, we all say it. But who really embraces the idea? Brava!
The National Collegiate Inventors and Innovators Alliance is giving the Stonybrook group and its co-investigators at Pace University and Thies Univeristy nearly $50,000 over two years to design mobile phone apps for use in the informal Senegalese economy.
What the mobile app group did right: they built local capacity. They recruited 20 Senegalese computer science students and taught a one-week crash course in Senegal on how to write and load mobile phone applications. These students in turn interviewed the local fisherwomen in Wolof (one of Senegal’s most common local languages) to customize the profit-and-loss application for their phones.
The fisherwomen are actually fish sellers. They buy fresh fish and then dry it to sell on the market. The women often sell the dried fish at a loss, which is why a simple profit-and-loss calculator on their mobile phones might help them decide when and at what price to buy the fresh fish so they could come out ahead.
The pilot was a failure because the fish sellers found the mobile phone profit-and-loss calculator useless. The computer science group did not learn why the app was useless, however, until a second round of testing in which one of the Senegalese computer science students happened to have a grandmother who was a fish seller. After talking with the fish sellers, he discovered that all the prices for both fresh fish and dried fish are fixed. Since everyone charges the same price for fish (one for dried, the other for fresh) on any given day, there is no way for the women to wait until the price is right.
One wonders why anyone would sell dried fish at all under these conditions? There is bound to be more to this story. Please enlighten us if you can, using the comments section.
Lesson learned: you have to be very specific when seeking local expertise.
Another way of looking at it: just because something looks to you like irrational economic behavior doesn't necessarily mean that it is, or that you know why it is irrational.
To find out more about applications for mobile phones in the informal economy, contact Anita Wasilewska or Jennifer Wong at SUNY Stonybrook or Christelle Scharff at Pace University in New York City or Prof. Ibrahima Ndiaye, Director of the Economic and Social Sciences Education and Research Unit, Thiès University, Senegal. See also their wiki about mobile apps in Senegal.
To learn more about what else went on at MobileTech For Social Change (New York):
• Search for #m4change on Twitter from 2/21/09 to about 2/23/09
• Read the Morningside Post stories once they come online
• Read Patrick Meier’s summary post on iRevolution
• Check out some #m4change photos on Flickr (cool search for events after 20090201)
• Read Persephone Miel at Media Re:public on why mobiles are not the future; they are right now.
(updated on 2/24/2009 to add Christelle Scharf and Ibrahima Ndiaye and Pace and Thies Universities.)
I promised myself I would share at least one story from the MobileTech for Social Change Barcamp I attended at Hunter College in New York City on Saturday (Feb. 21, 2008). Barcamp, for those who may not know, is an approach to organizing and running conferences that tries to capture the hidden value of most meetings—the conversations that happen between sessions in the hallways—and bring it front and center. Barcamps are also supposed to be free, or nearly so, for participants to attend.
A computer science group from the State University of New York at Stonybrook presented three applications or “apps,” that is to say mini-computer programs, that they had designed for use on no-frills mobile phones owned by women working in the informal Senegalese economy. The pilot tests for two of the apps—a dictionary and a book-keeping calculator—were deemed successes. The third app—for measuring profit and loss—was judged a failure.
Since most people—myself included—don’t like to publish their failures, I was impressed by the Stonybrook group’s willingness to do so. Indeed, they were almost as enthusiastic about the failure as the two successes. “You often learn more from failure than success,” says Jennifer Wong, one of the two Stonybrook professors who, along with two students, came to present their findings. Sure, we all say it. But who really embraces the idea? Brava!
The National Collegiate Inventors and Innovators Alliance is giving the Stonybrook group and its co-investigators at Pace University and Thies Univeristy nearly $50,000 over two years to design mobile phone apps for use in the informal Senegalese economy.
What the mobile app group did right: they built local capacity. They recruited 20 Senegalese computer science students and taught a one-week crash course in Senegal on how to write and load mobile phone applications. These students in turn interviewed the local fisherwomen in Wolof (one of Senegal’s most common local languages) to customize the profit-and-loss application for their phones.
The fisherwomen are actually fish sellers. They buy fresh fish and then dry it to sell on the market. The women often sell the dried fish at a loss, which is why a simple profit-and-loss calculator on their mobile phones might help them decide when and at what price to buy the fresh fish so they could come out ahead.
The pilot was a failure because the fish sellers found the mobile phone profit-and-loss calculator useless. The computer science group did not learn why the app was useless, however, until a second round of testing in which one of the Senegalese computer science students happened to have a grandmother who was a fish seller. After talking with the fish sellers, he discovered that all the prices for both fresh fish and dried fish are fixed. Since everyone charges the same price for fish (one for dried, the other for fresh) on any given day, there is no way for the women to wait until the price is right.
One wonders why anyone would sell dried fish at all under these conditions? There is bound to be more to this story. Please enlighten us if you can, using the comments section.
Lesson learned: you have to be very specific when seeking local expertise.
Another way of looking at it: just because something looks to you like irrational economic behavior doesn't necessarily mean that it is, or that you know why it is irrational.
To find out more about applications for mobile phones in the informal economy, contact Anita Wasilewska or Jennifer Wong at SUNY Stonybrook or Christelle Scharff at Pace University in New York City or Prof. Ibrahima Ndiaye, Director of the Economic and Social Sciences Education and Research Unit, Thiès University, Senegal. See also their wiki about mobile apps in Senegal.
To learn more about what else went on at MobileTech For Social Change (New York):
• Search for #m4change on Twitter from 2/21/09 to about 2/23/09
• Read the Morningside Post stories once they come online
• Read Patrick Meier’s summary post on iRevolution
• Check out some #m4change photos on Flickr (cool search for events after 20090201)
• Read Persephone Miel at Media Re:public on why mobiles are not the future; they are right now.
(updated on 2/24/2009 to add Christelle Scharf and Ibrahima Ndiaye and Pace and Thies Universities.)
Thursday, 22 January 2009
Broken Links at DotGov Sites
Are broken web links at U.S. government sites going to be a feature of all future changes in Administration? I'm having trouble finding some of the links I had saved on a couple of global health issues from official U.S. government sites. Shouldn't we have some web continuity between Bush and Obama Administrations?
I can no longer get at a press release about human rights from Dec. 10, 2008 that was on the whitehouse.gov site. I get redirected to the Obama briefing room, not even a "page has been moved" message. Very Ministry of Truth.
Yesterday, Maryn McKenna found a broken link to whitehouse.gov that used to tell about the President's Malaria Initiative. No refer pages to where the pages are archived (although the Malaria Initiative itself is still available at fightingmalaria.gov).
I thought, okay, that is the White House--a very political place. But then in writing up my post about the Iranian AIDS doctors who were just sentenced to prison terms for trying to foment a velvet revolution via international HIV meetings (you can't make this stuff up, unfortunately), I realized that a link to an official statement from U.S. State department about the Alaei case was broken. The error message read "We're sorry. That page can't be found and may have been moved."
Since the statement was made by the Bush Administration, the contents had been moved to an archive site. Okay, fine, but at least give me the refer. I had to go and search by eyeball (keyword search Alaei brought up nothing) to find the archived statement.
That's when I started to worry. What about all the press releases at the Centers for Disease Control? Are all those links broken, too? Fortunately, as of Jan. 22, 2008, the CDC's RSS feed for press releases about vaccinations, mortality data, etc. is intact.
I used to think saving links to U.S. government web sites was a safe thing to do because, well, it's the government, they have to preserve those web pages--right? It is a matter of public record. And press releases are part of the public record. But what if the government webmasters preserve the pages and destroy the links? Makes keeping track of things mighty difficult.
It's a different kind of way of politicizing the record--every bit as Orwellian as deleting the word "abortion" as a search term from the Popline database last spring. Fortunately, that was fixed.
Is there a technological fix for broken links, too? Can the new Administration put up their stuff without losing the links to the old information? It is the same government of the same country, after all--just different temporary leaders.
Do you have any other examples of broken government links about global health post-Obama transition?
I can no longer get at a press release about human rights from Dec. 10, 2008 that was on the whitehouse.gov site. I get redirected to the Obama briefing room, not even a "page has been moved" message. Very Ministry of Truth.
Yesterday, Maryn McKenna found a broken link to whitehouse.gov that used to tell about the President's Malaria Initiative. No refer pages to where the pages are archived (although the Malaria Initiative itself is still available at fightingmalaria.gov).
I thought, okay, that is the White House--a very political place. But then in writing up my post about the Iranian AIDS doctors who were just sentenced to prison terms for trying to foment a velvet revolution via international HIV meetings (you can't make this stuff up, unfortunately), I realized that a link to an official statement from U.S. State department about the Alaei case was broken. The error message read "We're sorry. That page can't be found and may have been moved."
Since the statement was made by the Bush Administration, the contents had been moved to an archive site. Okay, fine, but at least give me the refer. I had to go and search by eyeball (keyword search Alaei brought up nothing) to find the archived statement.
That's when I started to worry. What about all the press releases at the Centers for Disease Control? Are all those links broken, too? Fortunately, as of Jan. 22, 2008, the CDC's RSS feed for press releases about vaccinations, mortality data, etc. is intact.
I used to think saving links to U.S. government web sites was a safe thing to do because, well, it's the government, they have to preserve those web pages--right? It is a matter of public record. And press releases are part of the public record. But what if the government webmasters preserve the pages and destroy the links? Makes keeping track of things mighty difficult.
It's a different kind of way of politicizing the record--every bit as Orwellian as deleting the word "abortion" as a search term from the Popline database last spring. Fortunately, that was fixed.
Is there a technological fix for broken links, too? Can the new Administration put up their stuff without losing the links to the old information? It is the same government of the same country, after all--just different temporary leaders.
Do you have any other examples of broken government links about global health post-Obama transition?
Thursday, 15 January 2009
Who Reads the Global Health Report?
Based on your comments, I would have to say you are all intelligent and thoughtful, if still a little bit shy. (To keep things civil, I delete the comments from trolls and hucksters.) Thanks to some basic web analytics software, here is what else I know about the people who visit The Global Health Report.
Just over 1500 unique visitors come to the site in December 2008, a monthly rate that has quadrupled in the past year. (Is that good or bad? You tell me.)
If I'm reading the charts right,
97% used a fast connection
2% used dialup
fewer than 1% accessed the blog from a mobile phone.
In the past year, visitors have come from 140 countries, with the following breakdown for the top five:
United States 71%
United Kingdom 6%
Canada 4%
South Africa 2%
If you have simple ideas on how to increase the international readership of the blog, please let me know.
11% of visitors accessed the site using computers on university or college networks, with the top five being:
Harvard University
Northwestern University
George Washington University
Bowdoin College
University of Washington
1% of visitors accessed the site using computers at U.S. government agencies, with the top five being:
The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
The U.S. Department of State
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
The U.S. Agency for International Development
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
Employees who use computer networks at the following press organizations (top 5):
BBC
Seattle Times
New York Times
Time Inc.
National Public Radio
Plus, a smattering of non-U.S. national and international agencies, several public relations agencies, some foundations and lots and lots of folks who I assume must be logging in from home on RoadRunner, Comcast, BellSouth, etc.
Related post:
Top 5 Blog Posts for 2008
Just over 1500 unique visitors come to the site in December 2008, a monthly rate that has quadrupled in the past year. (Is that good or bad? You tell me.)
If I'm reading the charts right,
97% used a fast connection
2% used dialup
fewer than 1% accessed the blog from a mobile phone.
In the past year, visitors have come from 140 countries, with the following breakdown for the top five:
United States 71%
United Kingdom 6%
Canada 4%
South Africa 2%
If you have simple ideas on how to increase the international readership of the blog, please let me know.
11% of visitors accessed the site using computers on university or college networks, with the top five being:
Harvard University
Northwestern University
George Washington University
Bowdoin College
University of Washington
1% of visitors accessed the site using computers at U.S. government agencies, with the top five being:
The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
The U.S. Department of State
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
The U.S. Agency for International Development
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
Employees who use computer networks at the following press organizations (top 5):
BBC
Seattle Times
New York Times
Time Inc.
National Public Radio
Plus, a smattering of non-U.S. national and international agencies, several public relations agencies, some foundations and lots and lots of folks who I assume must be logging in from home on RoadRunner, Comcast, BellSouth, etc.
Related post:
Top 5 Blog Posts for 2008
Thursday, 8 January 2009
AIDS Docs, Sanjay Gupta, Measles
Iranian AIDS Docs. Revere at Effect Measure and Declan Butler at Nature both have items up about the 6-month detention, trial and expected sentencing of Arash and Kamiar Alaei, who were accused of trying to overthrow the government by going to international AIDS meetings.
Sanjay Gupta for U.S. Surgeon General. Several public health types seem disappointed but hopeful while many of the journalists I follow on Twitter and in list-servs are far more skeptical. Interestingly, the public health types emphasize Gupta's demonstrable communication skills while the journalists focus on his lack of public health experience (which, of course, is not the same as medical experience). I'll have more to say on this later when I have time to write a more thoughtful piece.
Other interesting posts on the Surgeon General at Paul Krugman's blog (see especially the early comments) and a much more positive analysis at Technology Health and Development.
Measles cases up in Europe. A Lancet study found measles cases were on track to double, from 3,909 in in 2007 to 6,269 cases in the first nine months of 2008. (Click here for full text of Lancet study on measles.)
Sanjay Gupta for U.S. Surgeon General. Several public health types seem disappointed but hopeful while many of the journalists I follow on Twitter and in list-servs are far more skeptical. Interestingly, the public health types emphasize Gupta's demonstrable communication skills while the journalists focus on his lack of public health experience (which, of course, is not the same as medical experience). I'll have more to say on this later when I have time to write a more thoughtful piece.
Other interesting posts on the Surgeon General at Paul Krugman's blog (see especially the early comments) and a much more positive analysis at Technology Health and Development.
Measles cases up in Europe. A Lancet study found measles cases were on track to double, from 3,909 in in 2007 to 6,269 cases in the first nine months of 2008. (Click here for full text of Lancet study on measles.)
Tuesday, 6 January 2009
Questions About Gupta for Surgeon General
Years ago, when I was a cub health reporter, I remember the political reporters assuring me that the U.S. Surgeon General's position was a largely ceremonial one that political Washington didn't take too seriously.
This surprised me at the time--shows you what I know about politics. It seemed to me the Surgeon General's report of 1964 about smoking was an incredibly important public health policy. And I think Surgeon General Koop opened the door somewhat in a very closed Reagan Administration on AIDS policy.
Obviously, the reason I'm reminded of this is the floating of Sanjay Gupta's name as possible surgeon general nominee. Full disclosure: I worked with Sanjay at TIME and think he's very nice, an excellent neurosurgeon and obviously very telegenic.
But that's the question: is the SG position all about being a good communicator--in which case, Sanjay is a surprising but logical choice. Or is there more to the Surgeon General's position--like actually setting public health policy? If the latter, then--much as I like Sanjay--I remain unconvinced that there aren't people with better public health credentials to take the job.
I am asking about this on Twitter and in private emails and conversations I have been having with fellow journalists and public health types.
Will let you know if I learn anything good, including any interesting posts--as opposed to the many, many me-too posts that merely repeat what has already been said in the mainstream media.
Also, please point me in the direction of good information about whether the Surgeon General's position is largely ceremonial or not.
Update: See Opposition to Gupta as Surgeon General
This surprised me at the time--shows you what I know about politics. It seemed to me the Surgeon General's report of 1964 about smoking was an incredibly important public health policy. And I think Surgeon General Koop opened the door somewhat in a very closed Reagan Administration on AIDS policy.
Obviously, the reason I'm reminded of this is the floating of Sanjay Gupta's name as possible surgeon general nominee. Full disclosure: I worked with Sanjay at TIME and think he's very nice, an excellent neurosurgeon and obviously very telegenic.
But that's the question: is the SG position all about being a good communicator--in which case, Sanjay is a surprising but logical choice. Or is there more to the Surgeon General's position--like actually setting public health policy? If the latter, then--much as I like Sanjay--I remain unconvinced that there aren't people with better public health credentials to take the job.
I am asking about this on Twitter and in private emails and conversations I have been having with fellow journalists and public health types.
Will let you know if I learn anything good, including any interesting posts--as opposed to the many, many me-too posts that merely repeat what has already been said in the mainstream media.
Also, please point me in the direction of good information about whether the Surgeon General's position is largely ceremonial or not.
Update: See Opposition to Gupta as Surgeon General
Wednesday, 31 December 2008
Top 5 Blog Posts for 2008
My top five 2008 blog posts, based on unique page views:
1. Demand for Plumpy'Nut Outstrips Supply
2. At Work with Malawi's Nurses
3. Who Are the Health Eight (or H8)?
4. Al Gore: Clean Coal is a Lie
5. Agnes Binagwaho on Brain Drain
When I look at the analytics graphs for these posts, I am struck once again by the ways in which the Web captures ephemeral posts and makes them permanent.
The Plumpy'Nut post received the greatest number of unique page views. In fact, even my posts from 2007 on the controversy surrounding the patent for this nutritional supplement, which helps to save the lives of starving kids, still get a lot of hits. Intriguingly, views of the the post on the demand for Plumpy'nut peaked in July, two months after the post first appeared.
I'm glad to see "At Work with Malawi's Nurses" continues to be popular since it describes the focus of my Nieman Fellowship field project and has occupied a lot of my psychic energy over the past year. It's still chugging along at 58% of its peak back in March.
"Who are the Health Eight (or H8)?" about eight big players in the global health field continues to amaze me. It has had two peaks since it first appeared in April (the second, taller than the first, coincided with the July meeting of the G8 on health in Tokyo) and is currently on its third big upward slope, which seems likely to beat the other two.
My very simple reporting of Al Gore's speech at the Clinton Global Initiative in September, in which he called the concept of "clean coal" a lie, got attention from both the left and right zones of the blogosphere. It is on a second surge, possibly related to the coal ash spill in Tennessee earlier this month.
And the Agnes Binagwaho post, in which she speaks movingly of her own temptation to quit practicing medicine in Rwanda, has the most intriguing web analytics profile--a couple of peaks and valleys that also grow in popularity and that I think mirror the different speeches she has given on university campuses in the U.S.
1. Demand for Plumpy'Nut Outstrips Supply
2. At Work with Malawi's Nurses
3. Who Are the Health Eight (or H8)?
4. Al Gore: Clean Coal is a Lie
5. Agnes Binagwaho on Brain Drain
When I look at the analytics graphs for these posts, I am struck once again by the ways in which the Web captures ephemeral posts and makes them permanent.
The Plumpy'Nut post received the greatest number of unique page views. In fact, even my posts from 2007 on the controversy surrounding the patent for this nutritional supplement, which helps to save the lives of starving kids, still get a lot of hits. Intriguingly, views of the the post on the demand for Plumpy'nut peaked in July, two months after the post first appeared.
I'm glad to see "At Work with Malawi's Nurses" continues to be popular since it describes the focus of my Nieman Fellowship field project and has occupied a lot of my psychic energy over the past year. It's still chugging along at 58% of its peak back in March.
"Who are the Health Eight (or H8)?" about eight big players in the global health field continues to amaze me. It has had two peaks since it first appeared in April (the second, taller than the first, coincided with the July meeting of the G8 on health in Tokyo) and is currently on its third big upward slope, which seems likely to beat the other two.
My very simple reporting of Al Gore's speech at the Clinton Global Initiative in September, in which he called the concept of "clean coal" a lie, got attention from both the left and right zones of the blogosphere. It is on a second surge, possibly related to the coal ash spill in Tennessee earlier this month.
And the Agnes Binagwaho post, in which she speaks movingly of her own temptation to quit practicing medicine in Rwanda, has the most intriguing web analytics profile--a couple of peaks and valleys that also grow in popularity and that I think mirror the different speeches she has given on university campuses in the U.S.
Friday, 19 December 2008
Jailed Iranian AIDS Docs
Looking ahead to Monday.
The folks at Physicians for Human Rights expect the U.S. State Department to release a statement on the 6-month anniversary of the detention of two AIDS doctors in Iran.
Kamiar and Arash Alaei are internationally known for their work with AIDS and with heroin addicts. Iranian authorities accuse the brothers of trying to promote a "velvet revolution" under the guise of fighting AIDS. (Sounds a lot like the Haleh Esfandiari case to me.)
A quick Google News search shows the Alaeis' detention has so far garnered more mainstream press interest in Europe than the U.S., especially in French-language press.
I learned about the story in an e-mail from Physicians for Human Rights. Read more about their campaign to free the brothers here. (Note to PHR, you need to update the background page on the website. Kamiar Alaei has obviously not returned to his doctoral program at the SUNY Albany School of Public Health.)
The BBC profiled Kamiar and Arash Alaei for their AIDS work back in 2004 as did the Washington Post in 2006.
If you know about this story, please add to the comments below. I will give the comments that provide the most context a full-on post of their own.
Update: the State Department released its statement on the Alaei brothers on Tuesday, Dec. 23, 2008. It reads, in part:
The folks at Physicians for Human Rights expect the U.S. State Department to release a statement on the 6-month anniversary of the detention of two AIDS doctors in Iran.
Kamiar and Arash Alaei are internationally known for their work with AIDS and with heroin addicts. Iranian authorities accuse the brothers of trying to promote a "velvet revolution" under the guise of fighting AIDS. (Sounds a lot like the Haleh Esfandiari case to me.)
A quick Google News search shows the Alaeis' detention has so far garnered more mainstream press interest in Europe than the U.S., especially in French-language press.
I learned about the story in an e-mail from Physicians for Human Rights. Read more about their campaign to free the brothers here. (Note to PHR, you need to update the background page on the website. Kamiar Alaei has obviously not returned to his doctoral program at the SUNY Albany School of Public Health.)
The BBC profiled Kamiar and Arash Alaei for their AIDS work back in 2004 as did the Washington Post in 2006.
If you know about this story, please add to the comments below. I will give the comments that provide the most context a full-on post of their own.
Update: the State Department released its statement on the Alaei brothers on Tuesday, Dec. 23, 2008. It reads, in part:
The United States is also deeply concerned by the continued detention of internationally known Iranian HIV/AIDS physicians Dr. Arash Alaei and Dr. Kamiar Alaei. December 22 marked six months since the physicians were arbitrarily arrested by Iranian authorities and detained in Tehran’s Evin Prison. As a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Iran has the obligation to afford due process rights to anyone detained. The two have been active in various international exchange programs and academic research, helping to involve Iranians in the international academic and scientific community.
In November 2006, because of their work on HIV/AIDS, the Alaei brothers were participants in the first professional exchange program for Iranians in almost three decades, sponsored by the U.S. Department of State’s Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs. The program, which focused on public health, led to collaboration between American and Iranian medical professionals that could benefit the global fight against HIV-AIDS. Similar programs have brought citizens from over 165 countries to the United States.
The Iranian people have consistently expressed their desire to be connected to the global community. The actions of the Iranian Government against the Alaei brothers, Ms. Ebadi, and other human rights activists only serve to isolate further the Iranian people. With our friends and allies in the region, we stand by the brave people of Iran, who are trying peacefully to exercise their universal human rights, and call upon the Government of Iran to abide by its international obligations.
Wednesday, 17 December 2008
Twitter and Global Health
I finally gave in and created a Twitter account back on November 4 so I could participate in the #votereport project. It reminded me somewhat of the way mobile phone or SMS texting has shaped elections in Africa, starting with the 2000 election in Ghana and continuing on to the more recent 2008 election in Zimbabwe. It also got me thinking about how such democracy-movement techniques could be adapted to global health. Perhaps to introduce some much-needed transparency in pharmaceutical supply chains?
Votereport was a volunteer-led project that called on U.S. voters to characterize their election experience by providing three major pieces of information: where they voted, how long they waited to vote and whether the experience was a good one or a bad one. If yours was a bad experience, then you were supposed to give a brief description why, e.g. mismatch of your name compared to driver’s license records caused an official to doubt your right to vote.
From a technical point of view, we’re talking about structured-data.
I messed up my first attempt at tweeting my own vote but fortunately someone named ZekeSaysSo showed me how to do it: “#votereport. #10019 #good #wait:40 at 6 AM. longest lines I have ever seen at this polling place at this hour.”
Each specific piece of information was preceded by a # sign or hashtag, also known as a pound sign, to make the information more easily sortable by computer.
People like Adrian Holovaty have convinced a lot of us reporters that one major path to a future for journalism lies through structured data. As Holovaty defined it in 2006, structured data is “the type of information that can be sliced-and-diced, in an automated fashion, by computers.”
Holovaty’s breakthrough example in 2005: using the structured data from Chicago crime statistics mashed up with Google maps to automatically generate geographical pictures of a neighborhood’s character. You can see the latest iteration of his efforts at Everyblock.com
The new wrinkle about Votereport, the Ghanian and Zimabwean elections is that “we the people” provided the structured data—in real time with tangible results. Mobile texting plus radio coverage stopped voting irregularities in Ghana in 2000 and prevented Robert Mugabe from being able to fudge electoral results in Zimbabwe earlier this year—although it didn’t stop him from hanging on to power.
Nothing quite so impressive in the U.S. but Votereport did help a number of individuals cast regular ballots instead of provisional ballots after minor misspellings of their name threatened their franchise rights. Because anyone who tweeted #bad and provided information as to why they couldn’t vote was automatically put into contact with an election protection lawyer. In many cases, simple misunderstandings were resolved before the voting booths closed.
See also Ethan Zuckerman’s thoughtful look at the pros and cons of twittering vs. texting elections.
Seems like you could adapt this type of technology to other uses. I’m thinking specifically about the government’s drug-supply chain in Malawi.
Many, many people I talked to complained about how they can’t get the drugs they need for hospitals and clinics from the Malawi government’s Central Medical Stores. Even the taxi drivers in Lilongwe know that a lot of the pharmaceuticals get diverted from the public sector to the private sector—despite periodic purges of the employees involved.
What if every hospital administrator, clinical officer and nurse used their mobile phone to text every encounter they had with Malawi’s CMS, giving information about the number and kind of drugs that were missing? And you compared that to the number and kind of drugs they started off with—many made available through international agreements?
How long would it take before CMS employees retaliated? Could you get enough people to participate so that no one individual would be targeted for retribution?
Just wondering. What do you think?
See also this Slideshare presentation on Twitter for Health by PF Anderson at the University of Michigan.
Votereport was a volunteer-led project that called on U.S. voters to characterize their election experience by providing three major pieces of information: where they voted, how long they waited to vote and whether the experience was a good one or a bad one. If yours was a bad experience, then you were supposed to give a brief description why, e.g. mismatch of your name compared to driver’s license records caused an official to doubt your right to vote.
From a technical point of view, we’re talking about structured-data.
I messed up my first attempt at tweeting my own vote but fortunately someone named ZekeSaysSo showed me how to do it: “#votereport. #10019 #good #wait:40 at 6 AM. longest lines I have ever seen at this polling place at this hour.”
Each specific piece of information was preceded by a # sign or hashtag, also known as a pound sign, to make the information more easily sortable by computer.
People like Adrian Holovaty have convinced a lot of us reporters that one major path to a future for journalism lies through structured data. As Holovaty defined it in 2006, structured data is “the type of information that can be sliced-and-diced, in an automated fashion, by computers.”
Holovaty’s breakthrough example in 2005: using the structured data from Chicago crime statistics mashed up with Google maps to automatically generate geographical pictures of a neighborhood’s character. You can see the latest iteration of his efforts at Everyblock.com
The new wrinkle about Votereport, the Ghanian and Zimabwean elections is that “we the people” provided the structured data—in real time with tangible results. Mobile texting plus radio coverage stopped voting irregularities in Ghana in 2000 and prevented Robert Mugabe from being able to fudge electoral results in Zimbabwe earlier this year—although it didn’t stop him from hanging on to power.
Nothing quite so impressive in the U.S. but Votereport did help a number of individuals cast regular ballots instead of provisional ballots after minor misspellings of their name threatened their franchise rights. Because anyone who tweeted #bad and provided information as to why they couldn’t vote was automatically put into contact with an election protection lawyer. In many cases, simple misunderstandings were resolved before the voting booths closed.
See also Ethan Zuckerman’s thoughtful look at the pros and cons of twittering vs. texting elections.
Seems like you could adapt this type of technology to other uses. I’m thinking specifically about the government’s drug-supply chain in Malawi.
Many, many people I talked to complained about how they can’t get the drugs they need for hospitals and clinics from the Malawi government’s Central Medical Stores. Even the taxi drivers in Lilongwe know that a lot of the pharmaceuticals get diverted from the public sector to the private sector—despite periodic purges of the employees involved.
What if every hospital administrator, clinical officer and nurse used their mobile phone to text every encounter they had with Malawi’s CMS, giving information about the number and kind of drugs that were missing? And you compared that to the number and kind of drugs they started off with—many made available through international agreements?
How long would it take before CMS employees retaliated? Could you get enough people to participate so that no one individual would be targeted for retribution?
Just wondering. What do you think?
See also this Slideshare presentation on Twitter for Health by PF Anderson at the University of Michigan.
Monday, 15 December 2008
Can There Be Too Much Training?
There are many moments from my three-month Malawi trip that I just had to store away for later reflection. I recognized a ring of truth even if I did not quite understand what it meant or how it fit into the larger picture. What a number of people said to me about the role of training—which theoretically seems like a good thing—was just one of these moments that set my head spinning.
A number of managers I interviewed griped that excessive training sessions were distorting the health care system in Malawi. Too many nurses in a country with precious few nurses in the first place were out of their clinic or hospital for various two-week training sessions, often every other month. Several health care workers—particularly in government hospitals—said they depended on the extra pay they got from those training sessions. A couple of Malawians I met who did trainings admitted they could not get anyone to come unless they offered financial incentives.
Now I learn these were not just a few isolated cases. Training and sustainability have turned into perverse incentives in numerous HIV programs in Malawi, according to a new study by Ann Swidler (UC Berkeley) and Susan Cotts Watkins (UPenn and UCLA). I am trying to get a hold of the full paper but this excerpt, provided by Bill Savedoff at the Center for Global Development, is electrifying:
Hat-tips to Alanna Shaikh and Bill Savedoff for the study.
A number of managers I interviewed griped that excessive training sessions were distorting the health care system in Malawi. Too many nurses in a country with precious few nurses in the first place were out of their clinic or hospital for various two-week training sessions, often every other month. Several health care workers—particularly in government hospitals—said they depended on the extra pay they got from those training sessions. A couple of Malawians I met who did trainings admitted they could not get anyone to come unless they offered financial incentives.
Now I learn these were not just a few isolated cases. Training and sustainability have turned into perverse incentives in numerous HIV programs in Malawi, according to a new study by Ann Swidler (UC Berkeley) and Susan Cotts Watkins (UPenn and UCLA). I am trying to get a hold of the full paper but this excerpt, provided by Bill Savedoff at the Center for Global Development, is electrifying:
Swidler and Watkins follow the logic of the “sustainability” mantra [Savedoff writes] to show how incentives at every level – from the international donors to the national elites, interstitial elites and local population – make funding for training (and training of trainers) the dysfunctional outcome of an otherwise well-meaning effort. The donors can claim they are “teaching the population to fish,” the national elites get income and status from managing and negotiating the programs, the interstitial elites (usually young high-school-educated volunteers) get contacts and opportunities to rise socially and economically, and the local population gets .. well, relatively little.
[snip]
Swidler and Watkins make the case for what is really needed quite clearly in their final remarks:
"It is hard to say precisely what constructive recommendations follow from the perspective we have offered here, but we do have several suggestions. First, the ideal of sustainability is a convenient self-delusion for funders and they would do much better if they could systematically and rigorously determine what projects are effective and then sustain them by paying local workers to actually do good—provide health care, sell discounted seeds and fertilizers, treat STIs, provide ARVs, supply children with books and school uniforms, or care for the ill and elderly (Kremer & Miguel, 2007).
Second, since few of the approaches to AIDS prevention currently in vogue have shown any measurable effect (Potts et al, 2008), we encourage funding that responds to Malawians’ desire to take care of the vulnerable in their communities, provide for their children’s futures, and build economic security, independent of the issue of HIV and AIDS. Indeed, reading the proposals that Malawian villagers submitted in their usually vain attempts to gain access to AIDS funding convinces us that villagers do know what they want, but little of it is training in how to prevent, mitigate, or treat AIDS. The first two they already know how to do as well as the experts who try to advise them (Watkins, 2004), and treating AIDS has to be done through the health-care system.
"Finally, we suggest that donors consider the “hidden curriculum” their procedures teach. Requirements for elaborate proposals, bank accounts, and monitoring and evaluation might better be replaced by simple procedures that would funnel more resources to villagers and less to monitors. Such resources would create continuing projects that both villagers and employees (perhaps the brighter, more successful of the villagers’ children) might rely upon. Rather than projecting a social imaginary that they find morally gratifying, donors and NGOs might provide opportunities that could sustain the realistic aspirations of those they claim to help."
Hat-tips to Alanna Shaikh and Bill Savedoff for the study.
Wednesday, 10 December 2008
Daulaire and Gayle for Obama Administration?
Catching up to the news. Helene Gayle, currently leading CARE, is being rumored as a possible pick to head up USAID, according to Al Kamen at the Washington Post. Nils Daulaire may be tapped for HIV/AIDS coordinator, displacing Mark Dybul. If true, I wonder where Dybul will go?
Repeating rumors is precarious business. The way the game is played in Washington, you can't help but feel you're being used by someone--you just never know by whom. (See Valerie Plame.) Maybe it's a trial balloon. Maybe it's wishful thinking. We'll know soon enough.
Related Post: US Food Policy Needs to Change (Editorial)
Update (Jan. 13, 2009) Looks like Dybul is staying on at Pepfar for now. Wonder how he gets along with Hillary Clinton, who as Secretary of State, would presumably be his boss?
Repeating rumors is precarious business. The way the game is played in Washington, you can't help but feel you're being used by someone--you just never know by whom. (See Valerie Plame.) Maybe it's a trial balloon. Maybe it's wishful thinking. We'll know soon enough.
Related Post: US Food Policy Needs to Change (Editorial)
Update (Jan. 13, 2009) Looks like Dybul is staying on at Pepfar for now. Wonder how he gets along with Hillary Clinton, who as Secretary of State, would presumably be his boss?
Monday, 8 December 2008
Sharing and Global Health Blogging
How can we get more coverage of global health news when old media doesn’t seem to want to do it without outside support and new media (blogs, texting, sharedmedia) still seems a scattershot affair?
This is the fourth post in a series that began with “Rethinking Why I Blog.” The others are “What Plumpy’Nut Taught Me” and “Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing.”
One of my goals for my Nieman fellowship year was to develop a business plan for a web-based global health news service. I know, I know, “news service” is such a quaint phrase, reminiscent of teletype, telegraphs and Morse code. But it is descriptive. If it’s too old-fashioned for you, think “content platform.”
The idea was to aggregate posts from around the globe as well as to provide funding for original reporting. I further focused the goal by targeting transparency issues in global health funding by eight major organizations. I developed the plan as part of a class on non-profits that I took at the Kennedy School and pitched it to the Open Society and Ashoka folks. Both decided to pass.
Nowadays, though, I’m wondering if maybe I was just trying too hard or too soon? After all, I keep seeing efforts by individuals to write about what they find interesting or newsworthy in global health. The ones I find most interesting are not promotional or advocacy-oriented but rather add context and highlight overlooked news.
In addition to established blogs from academics in the field, e.g. Effect Measure, The Pump Handle, Aetiology, there are a few more student blogs, like these efforts from Karen Grepin at Harvard, GlobeMed at Northwestern University and Unacceptable from Brigham Young University. See others on my blogroll at right.
(Mostly US-generated, I know. Send me your recommendations for global health blogs from other countries using the comment section below!! I haven't been bowled over by what I have read in the health section of Global Voices Online. )
The development community is farther along in self-publishing. See especially blogs from organizations like DFID and the Center for Global Development as well as DFID-funded Scidev.net. While trolling Twitter, I found “Blood and Milk,” a clear-eyed view by Alanna Shaikh of just how ethically challenged anti-poverty work can be despite good intentions.
Now that the Gates Foundation is investing in mainstream news organizations so they can cover global health news, you might say we don’t need individual efforts at reporting and commenting any more. Who needs amateurs, who post between bouts of norovirus or grant applications, when you can hire professionals [irony alert]?
And yet they write.
Update: PharmD+'s list of 100 global health blogs--three of mine are included, one of which is no longer active. But others on the list haven't been updated for quite a while either, e.g. BrownforGlobalHealth (last post Sept. 2007) and Don Burke's Global Health Blog (last post Jan. 2008).
This is the fourth post in a series that began with “Rethinking Why I Blog.” The others are “What Plumpy’Nut Taught Me” and “Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing.”
One of my goals for my Nieman fellowship year was to develop a business plan for a web-based global health news service. I know, I know, “news service” is such a quaint phrase, reminiscent of teletype, telegraphs and Morse code. But it is descriptive. If it’s too old-fashioned for you, think “content platform.”
The idea was to aggregate posts from around the globe as well as to provide funding for original reporting. I further focused the goal by targeting transparency issues in global health funding by eight major organizations. I developed the plan as part of a class on non-profits that I took at the Kennedy School and pitched it to the Open Society and Ashoka folks. Both decided to pass.
Nowadays, though, I’m wondering if maybe I was just trying too hard or too soon? After all, I keep seeing efforts by individuals to write about what they find interesting or newsworthy in global health. The ones I find most interesting are not promotional or advocacy-oriented but rather add context and highlight overlooked news.
In addition to established blogs from academics in the field, e.g. Effect Measure, The Pump Handle, Aetiology, there are a few more student blogs, like these efforts from Karen Grepin at Harvard, GlobeMed at Northwestern University and Unacceptable from Brigham Young University. See others on my blogroll at right.
(Mostly US-generated, I know. Send me your recommendations for global health blogs from other countries using the comment section below!! I haven't been bowled over by what I have read in the health section of Global Voices Online. )
The development community is farther along in self-publishing. See especially blogs from organizations like DFID and the Center for Global Development as well as DFID-funded Scidev.net. While trolling Twitter, I found “Blood and Milk,” a clear-eyed view by Alanna Shaikh of just how ethically challenged anti-poverty work can be despite good intentions.
Now that the Gates Foundation is investing in mainstream news organizations so they can cover global health news, you might say we don’t need individual efforts at reporting and commenting any more. Who needs amateurs, who post between bouts of norovirus or grant applications, when you can hire professionals [irony alert]?
And yet they write.
Update: PharmD+'s list of 100 global health blogs--three of mine are included, one of which is no longer active. But others on the list haven't been updated for quite a while either, e.g. BrownforGlobalHealth (last post Sept. 2007) and Don Burke's Global Health Blog (last post Jan. 2008).
Thursday, 4 December 2008
Story-Telling Makes Sense
Making the obvious difficult. We tell stories to deal with information overload (http://is.gd/af7f) and understand complexity (http://is.gd/af7j).
Thursday, 20 November 2008
Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing
By all means, share what you are doing on the web. Just make it authentic.
Previous posts in the series: "Rethinking why I blog" and "What Plumpy'Nut taught me."
When Richard Lalleman of the Netherlands asked me to share my delicious feeds about development with his Focuss.info initiative, I came back at him with some questions to make sure I knew just what kind of sharing he was talking about. I wanted to make sure that he wasn’t going to use my freely available feeds for a commercial project and that it would NOT require any extra effort on my part.
That got me thinking about the nature of sharing on the web. And whether it’s any different from sharing in the real world.
My church, like many community organizations whether faith-based or not, collects cash and canned goods for our local food pantry. Every year, we need to explain to the youngest crop of Sunday Schoolers what sorts of items are worth sharing. Usually, one or two discover the brilliant strategy of sharing something they don’t like—like canned peas. It’s a two-fer. They get rid of something they don’t want and they get points—in case anyone is keeping score—for sharing.
And so every year we explain again that the point of sharing is not to share what you don’t like but to share your love, in this case something that you find tasty or that you would want to receive yourself.
That first impulse—to selfish sharing—is totally human and not something that we necessarily grow out of. Think about how many folks donate clothes that they would never wear. There’s the satisfaction of sharing, not to mention a tax deduction. We won’t even go into the harm that free clothing has done to struggling textile industries around the globe.
A lot of the potential of the web comes from what’s called the “gift economy” or the benefits of collaboration.
The more you look, the more you realize there are different levels of sharing, with differing levels of authenticity.
Here’s a list, with examples, that I am playing around with. Some of the layers overlap, of course. Feel free to play along, whether here or on your preferred social media.
Selfish-sharing: (see above)
Reciprocal sharing: You watch the kids on Tuesday and I’ll watch them on Wednesday.
Self-interested sharing (or enlightened self-interest): I’ll tweet my voting experience as a way of improving democracy.
Convenient sharing: I’ll share the idle time on my computer to help model new ways to control malaria parasites.
Sharing from abundance: I can’t eat all these tomatoes from my garden; would you like some?
Coincidental sharing: I had to do this anyway, but I don’t mind sharing what I learned about getting a cell phone in Malawi.
Catalytic sharing: let’s all get together and write the code for [insert favorite open-source program here] and watch it change the world when we’re done. Or let's share what we know about treating drug-resistant tuberculosis.
Sacrificial sharing: the stranger who dives into icy waters to rescue a child trapped in a sinking car. A soldier’s ultimate sacrifice.
Next: Sharing and Global Health Blogging
Previous posts in the series: "Rethinking why I blog" and "What Plumpy'Nut taught me."
When Richard Lalleman of the Netherlands asked me to share my delicious feeds about development with his Focuss.info initiative, I came back at him with some questions to make sure I knew just what kind of sharing he was talking about. I wanted to make sure that he wasn’t going to use my freely available feeds for a commercial project and that it would NOT require any extra effort on my part.
That got me thinking about the nature of sharing on the web. And whether it’s any different from sharing in the real world.
My church, like many community organizations whether faith-based or not, collects cash and canned goods for our local food pantry. Every year, we need to explain to the youngest crop of Sunday Schoolers what sorts of items are worth sharing. Usually, one or two discover the brilliant strategy of sharing something they don’t like—like canned peas. It’s a two-fer. They get rid of something they don’t want and they get points—in case anyone is keeping score—for sharing.
And so every year we explain again that the point of sharing is not to share what you don’t like but to share your love, in this case something that you find tasty or that you would want to receive yourself.
That first impulse—to selfish sharing—is totally human and not something that we necessarily grow out of. Think about how many folks donate clothes that they would never wear. There’s the satisfaction of sharing, not to mention a tax deduction. We won’t even go into the harm that free clothing has done to struggling textile industries around the globe.
A lot of the potential of the web comes from what’s called the “gift economy” or the benefits of collaboration.
The more you look, the more you realize there are different levels of sharing, with differing levels of authenticity.
Here’s a list, with examples, that I am playing around with. Some of the layers overlap, of course. Feel free to play along, whether here or on your preferred social media.
Selfish-sharing: (see above)
Reciprocal sharing: You watch the kids on Tuesday and I’ll watch them on Wednesday.
Self-interested sharing (or enlightened self-interest): I’ll tweet my voting experience as a way of improving democracy.
Convenient sharing: I’ll share the idle time on my computer to help model new ways to control malaria parasites.
Sharing from abundance: I can’t eat all these tomatoes from my garden; would you like some?
Coincidental sharing: I had to do this anyway, but I don’t mind sharing what I learned about getting a cell phone in Malawi.
Catalytic sharing: let’s all get together and write the code for [insert favorite open-source program here] and watch it change the world when we’re done. Or let's share what we know about treating drug-resistant tuberculosis.
Sacrificial sharing: the stranger who dives into icy waters to rescue a child trapped in a sinking car. A soldier’s ultimate sacrifice.
Next: Sharing and Global Health Blogging
Wednesday, 19 November 2008
What Plumpy’Nut Taught Me
Online collaboration may be the wave of the future but it’s not so easy to convince people to do it. As I learned last year, lots of public health folks were willing to talk to me about the Plumpy’ Nut patent but most were reluctant to act as journalists themselves, to help dig for the story, pull the various threads together.
Many were intrigued by the patent issue but didn’t want to join in publicly because they didn’t think they were expert enough. A few, no doubt, also felt the need to play it safe. After all, who knows what future employers (or donors) might think? As always, the people who knew the most were often the least interested in going on the record—in whatever format.
This is the second post in a series that started with “Rethinking Why I Blog.”
I learned about the Plumpy’Nut patent in October of 2007. I was attending a nutrition conference in which I picked up some hallway grousing from a humanitarian group that had been told it could not whip up its own version of Plumpy’nut, a carefully fortified peanut butter that has done wonders in the fight against severe malnutrition.
There was a patent on Plumpy’Nut, taken out by its manufacturer Nutriset (and the French government, I later learned.) Even though the recipe is widely available and easy to follow, making a batch on your own in many countries would land you in plenty of legal hot water.
Fascinating case. Before then the only reports I had heard or seen about Plumpy’Nut were glowing accounts about its proven qualities to save young children’s lives.
My first impulse was to dig deeper and write a freelance piece. But here I hit a snag. The rule was no freelance while on a Nieman fellowship.
So then I thought about it a bit and rather than ask for an exception, I decided to use this as an experiment in online collaboration. Normally I would hoard the information until I could come out with a fully-fledged piece. Otherwise, I would risk being scooped.
Instead, I decided to share it all, from the beginning, starting with the first disgruntled vibes I picked up at that conference. I envisioned a group blog where a bunch of interested folks could pursue the story—each contributing a different piece. And so launched what I hoped would be a group blog at Patents and Peanut Butter.
Talked to a number of students at Harvard’s School for Public Health. All were unfailingly polite, many offered suggestions, a number were intimidated by the blogging software. Most found it easier just to talk to me and let me write whatever I wanted on the blog.
Talked to several faculty members, including Richard Cash, who helped develop oral rehydration therapy back in the 1960s. Like Plumpy’Nut, ORT is a dead-simple recipe that saves lives. Unlike Plumpy’Nut, ORT is not patented. Anyone can make it. Many manufacturers do, but so do folks at home.
Several legal types thought the Plumpy’Nut patent wouldn’t stand up to legal challenge. I learned about “prior art” and “non-obvious” innovations.
Once again, the old habit—of journalist interviewing source as opposed to source commenting directly on a web site—was hard to break. I was perfectly willing to break it. But most people I talked to were not.
And so the blog sputtered along. I continued adding notes as time and opportunity allowed. But the hoped-for group blog did not materialize.
And yet, after a few months on the Internet, I did start getting inquiries and a few people from around the world added their two cents—some of them anonymously (which brings up all sorts of other issues.). Most of the interaction was still via e-mail. Most people didn’t feel comfortable posting comments on the Internet—despite repeated encouragement on my part. A few got into the spirit.
This was not the instantaneous burst of community magic that I had hoped for. But a kind of long-amplitude wave eventually did materialize. My old Plumpy’Nut posts kept getting traffic. Maybe I had brought a fast-food mentality to a slow-cooking world.
And indeed, a year after the blog went up (and many months after I stopped posting anything new), I received an e-mail from Martin Enserink at Science, who was working on a story about Plumpy’Nut and wanted to include a sidebar on the patent controversy.
We exchanged some information—though I couldn’t tell him much more than what I had already posted on the Internet. And Enserink's article—a piece of real journalism—has advanced the story. That’s where I learned, for example, that the real sticking point in the patent controversy may be the French government—and not Nutriset.
On balance, I learned more by sharing the Plumpy’Nut information when I did than if I had hoarded the information. And other people—whom I would never have known about otherwise—learned a few things through our exchanges or just by lurking on the blog.
As for news gathering, this felt kind of like a disorganized (or is it self-organized) relay race. Sometimes I was the leader passing the baton, sometimes I was receiving the baton. And sometimes, much to my surprise, I was just one of the bystanders (formerly known as the audience) cheering the race on.
Next: Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing
Many were intrigued by the patent issue but didn’t want to join in publicly because they didn’t think they were expert enough. A few, no doubt, also felt the need to play it safe. After all, who knows what future employers (or donors) might think? As always, the people who knew the most were often the least interested in going on the record—in whatever format.
This is the second post in a series that started with “Rethinking Why I Blog.”
I learned about the Plumpy’Nut patent in October of 2007. I was attending a nutrition conference in which I picked up some hallway grousing from a humanitarian group that had been told it could not whip up its own version of Plumpy’nut, a carefully fortified peanut butter that has done wonders in the fight against severe malnutrition.
There was a patent on Plumpy’Nut, taken out by its manufacturer Nutriset (and the French government, I later learned.) Even though the recipe is widely available and easy to follow, making a batch on your own in many countries would land you in plenty of legal hot water.
Fascinating case. Before then the only reports I had heard or seen about Plumpy’Nut were glowing accounts about its proven qualities to save young children’s lives.
My first impulse was to dig deeper and write a freelance piece. But here I hit a snag. The rule was no freelance while on a Nieman fellowship.
So then I thought about it a bit and rather than ask for an exception, I decided to use this as an experiment in online collaboration. Normally I would hoard the information until I could come out with a fully-fledged piece. Otherwise, I would risk being scooped.
Instead, I decided to share it all, from the beginning, starting with the first disgruntled vibes I picked up at that conference. I envisioned a group blog where a bunch of interested folks could pursue the story—each contributing a different piece. And so launched what I hoped would be a group blog at Patents and Peanut Butter.
Talked to a number of students at Harvard’s School for Public Health. All were unfailingly polite, many offered suggestions, a number were intimidated by the blogging software. Most found it easier just to talk to me and let me write whatever I wanted on the blog.
Talked to several faculty members, including Richard Cash, who helped develop oral rehydration therapy back in the 1960s. Like Plumpy’Nut, ORT is a dead-simple recipe that saves lives. Unlike Plumpy’Nut, ORT is not patented. Anyone can make it. Many manufacturers do, but so do folks at home.
Several legal types thought the Plumpy’Nut patent wouldn’t stand up to legal challenge. I learned about “prior art” and “non-obvious” innovations.
Once again, the old habit—of journalist interviewing source as opposed to source commenting directly on a web site—was hard to break. I was perfectly willing to break it. But most people I talked to were not.
And so the blog sputtered along. I continued adding notes as time and opportunity allowed. But the hoped-for group blog did not materialize.
And yet, after a few months on the Internet, I did start getting inquiries and a few people from around the world added their two cents—some of them anonymously (which brings up all sorts of other issues.). Most of the interaction was still via e-mail. Most people didn’t feel comfortable posting comments on the Internet—despite repeated encouragement on my part. A few got into the spirit.
This was not the instantaneous burst of community magic that I had hoped for. But a kind of long-amplitude wave eventually did materialize. My old Plumpy’Nut posts kept getting traffic. Maybe I had brought a fast-food mentality to a slow-cooking world.
And indeed, a year after the blog went up (and many months after I stopped posting anything new), I received an e-mail from Martin Enserink at Science, who was working on a story about Plumpy’Nut and wanted to include a sidebar on the patent controversy.
We exchanged some information—though I couldn’t tell him much more than what I had already posted on the Internet. And Enserink's article—a piece of real journalism—has advanced the story. That’s where I learned, for example, that the real sticking point in the patent controversy may be the French government—and not Nutriset.
On balance, I learned more by sharing the Plumpy’Nut information when I did than if I had hoarded the information. And other people—whom I would never have known about otherwise—learned a few things through our exchanges or just by lurking on the blog.
As for news gathering, this felt kind of like a disorganized (or is it self-organized) relay race. Sometimes I was the leader passing the baton, sometimes I was receiving the baton. And sometimes, much to my surprise, I was just one of the bystanders (formerly known as the audience) cheering the race on.
Next: Authentic Sharing vs. Selfish Sharing
Tuesday, 18 November 2008
What to Tell the Global Health Fellows?
Going to Cambridge, Mass. this weekend to impart whatever wisdom I can to the current global health fellows about the academic year at Harvard, the field project and life after the Nieman year. Looking forward to hearing what they’re doing and to catching up with David Kohn and Andrew Quinn, who will also be there.
But what to say that they don’t already know? All three of the current global health fellows have extensive experience in developing countries—Vietnam, Nigeria and India.
And how to prioritize? I still have trouble talking about the Malawi trip in anything less than treatise form. And so when friends ask, I often just say it was great and leave it at that.
If I had to focus on just three things what would they be?
1. Importance of sharing what you’re doing. e.g. Plumpy’Nut patent, putting Malawi proposal on the web. Solicit feedback but don’t be discouraged if you don’t get it or it doesn’t come as fast as you’d like it to.
2. Plan, plan, plan. Thinking of the field project as three distinct phases: pre-production, production and post-production. My own struggles with post-production. Don’t forget to bring the Malawi planning book I created. Also the laminated contact cards.
3. Bite off more than you can chew. But not too much more. Then let it happen.
Check with David and Andrew to see what they're thinking.
But what to say that they don’t already know? All three of the current global health fellows have extensive experience in developing countries—Vietnam, Nigeria and India.
And how to prioritize? I still have trouble talking about the Malawi trip in anything less than treatise form. And so when friends ask, I often just say it was great and leave it at that.
If I had to focus on just three things what would they be?
1. Importance of sharing what you’re doing. e.g. Plumpy’Nut patent, putting Malawi proposal on the web. Solicit feedback but don’t be discouraged if you don’t get it or it doesn’t come as fast as you’d like it to.
2. Plan, plan, plan. Thinking of the field project as three distinct phases: pre-production, production and post-production. My own struggles with post-production. Don’t forget to bring the Malawi planning book I created. Also the laminated contact cards.
3. Bite off more than you can chew. But not too much more. Then let it happen.
Check with David and Andrew to see what they're thinking.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)