Multimedia is not easy--takes much, much longer to create than pure text--and requires more thought, cooperation and collaboration.
At each stage of creating the Malawi video that is up on CNN's website--pre-production, production, post-production and distribution--I kept realizing how many different pieces there were. I'll admit there were times when I felt pretty low as each stage seemed to take longer than I anticipated. But I think the result is worth it.
Several multimedia journalists I respect keep emphasizing that you need to do a good job matching up various aspects of the story to the medium. Text--at whatever length (even captions) is particularly good for facts and analysis. Images for action or "slice of life." Audio for emotion.
So, even before I went to Malawi to report on its severe nurses shortage, I knew that I wanted the video to complement the text--not be the whole story. I wanted the video to give a sense of a couple of individual nurses and what they face in a real-world way that is much harder (although not impossible) do to with text.
And then the text could focus on context and analysis. For example, look at these three sentences from my CNN article:
"By the late 1990s, however, Malawi was reeling from the AIDS epidemic. As if that weren't bad enough, the government also had to cut spending on health care and education as a condition for getting help from the U.S. and other countries to liberalize its trade and economy. The publicly funded health system, on which more than 95 percent of Malawians still depend for treatment, quickly started to fall apart. "
Very quickly, I was able to provide the necessary context: the twin ravages of the AIDS epidemic and structural adjustment programs that crippled the Malawian health care system.
The photo essay was the least well-developed part of the CNN package--it really happened almost as an afterthought, when the CNN producer asked me if I had any still photos. But I was able to throw it together in a couple of hours (maybe 20 minutes to pick the photos and longer to export and email them to the producer) because I have organized all the photos Eileen Hohmuth-Lemonick took for the Malawi project as well as caption information in Lightroom, a terrific photo management/database program from Adobe. (And no, nobody paid me to mention Lightroom.)
Once again I wanted to touch on themes of showing nurses in a wide range of activities both inside and outside the hospital/clinic. Given how many negative images of poverty and despair we see from Africa, I specifically chose photos that show success--or at least active engagement. That's something I have thought about a lot over the years and so was able to act quickly.
FYI, I produced one other video based on the Malawi trip, called "Telling Stories, Saving Lives." You can see it in either Flash or Quicktime. I chose to upload it to blip.tv because of the Creative Commons license.
"Telling Stories" is more of a self-contained piece -- but could probably also be paired with a good text story (on women's rights or domestic violence or the arts and health). Why not all three articles connected to that same video. Ahh, my next project!
Related Post:
My Malawi Nurses Video Featured on CNN
Showing posts with label Malawi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Malawi. Show all posts
Monday, 3 August 2009
Thursday, 30 July 2009
My Malawi Nurses Video Featured on CNN
I'm happy to report that my story and video of the crippling shortage of nurses in Malawi has now been published in CNN's new health section "Vital Signs."
I actually shot two videos from my trip to Malawi. You can see the other one on blip.tv. It's called "Telling Stories, Saving Lives."
The videos, as many of you know, were months in the making. Who knew there were so many parts to putting moving images together?
And I have to question the idea that anyone truly is ever alone in producing video.
Many thanks to Nieman Fellow classmates (Ayelet, Joan, Walter, Simon and Stuart) who, along with Jeb Sharp and Joe Neel, gave me guerilla lessons in shooting video, Katherine Bates (who helped ferry all the equipment), Eileen Hohmuth-Lemonick (who took the still photos) Ed Robbins (who edited the videos and wrote the script), Stefanie Friedhoff (who believed in the project and provided the funding) and, of course, the great people at Embangweni Mission Hospital itself.
The two institutions to thank are, of course, the Nieman Foundation for Journalism, which awarded me the fellowship on global health reporting--and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which supported the Nieman Foundation.*
I haven't even won an award or anything and I'm just gushing with all the people to thank--but perhaps I'll stop there.
*I believe there is no conflict on interest posed by the Gates funding since I was free to chose my project and did my reporting without editorial input from the Gates Foundation.
Anyway, just wanted to share the joy.
Related Post:
Planning is Key to Good Multimedia
I actually shot two videos from my trip to Malawi. You can see the other one on blip.tv. It's called "Telling Stories, Saving Lives."
The videos, as many of you know, were months in the making. Who knew there were so many parts to putting moving images together?
And I have to question the idea that anyone truly is ever alone in producing video.
Many thanks to Nieman Fellow classmates (Ayelet, Joan, Walter, Simon and Stuart) who, along with Jeb Sharp and Joe Neel, gave me guerilla lessons in shooting video, Katherine Bates (who helped ferry all the equipment), Eileen Hohmuth-Lemonick (who took the still photos) Ed Robbins (who edited the videos and wrote the script), Stefanie Friedhoff (who believed in the project and provided the funding) and, of course, the great people at Embangweni Mission Hospital itself.
The two institutions to thank are, of course, the Nieman Foundation for Journalism, which awarded me the fellowship on global health reporting--and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which supported the Nieman Foundation.*
I haven't even won an award or anything and I'm just gushing with all the people to thank--but perhaps I'll stop there.
*I believe there is no conflict on interest posed by the Gates funding since I was free to chose my project and did my reporting without editorial input from the Gates Foundation.
Anyway, just wanted to share the joy.
Related Post:
Planning is Key to Good Multimedia
Friday, 5 June 2009
Malawi Project Featured in American Journal of Nursing

I am happy to report that a photo-essay about my Malawi project is the cover story for the June issue of the American Journal of Nursing. That great cover photo of Mphatso Nguluwe was taken by my friend Eileen Hohmuth-Lemonick who joined me on my three-month Malawi trip last year.
Mphatso is a great story-teller, who likes to tell her fellow Christians that she is the mother of nine children by eight different fathers. It's a great teachable moment that I wrote about last July.
My project focused on the nursing shortage in Malawi as a kind of a kind of window into how health systems function in poorer parts of the world. Malawi is in the midst of a six-year program to address its nursing shortage by paying nurses more and supporting more nursing education and training.
Part of what I learned in Malawi is how fragmented and overly narrow most efforts at improving health turn out to be. We think that having more drugs or more nurses and doctors will automatically improve conditions without considering the need for better roads, clean running water or functioning secondary schools to make sure those efforts succeed.
Because it's easier to raise money for a single issue--like AIDS or polio vaccines or girls' education, we continue to maintain (and tell stories about) siloed efforts that don't intentionally contribute to broader, more long-term needs like primary care. There was a study about that from the Institute of Tropical Medicine in Antwerp just yesterday in the Public Library of Science.
I don't understand why--if it took me only three months to figure this out--the professionals who do this for a living still can't seem to adjust their efforts accordingly. As the PLOS study suggests, they must already know this. But then, as the saying goes, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
I tried to get at some of these themes with the photos and captions that are part of the AJN essay as well as the supplemental material that is available online. When I suggested to Diana Mason, the outgoing editor-in-chief, that both be made available for free to non-subscribers as well since they reflect on health in the developing world, she readily agreed. Well, as another saying goes (two aphorisms in one post--that probably exceeds the limit), "it is better to strike even a tiny light than to curse the darkness."
Related posts:
Hiding Broken Practices Behind New Catchphrases
At Work with Malawi's Nurses
Update: Related 10-minute podcast with Christine Gorman on the AJN site
Thursday, 29 January 2009
Prevention vs. Treatment: A False Choice
The long-running debate over the relative importance of prevention or treatment is the theme that at least a dozen global health bloggers are exploring today. In many ways, the debate represents a false choice; a well-functioning health system requires both prevention and treatment. But how do you strike the right balance? Is the measuring stick simply the one provided by economics? Or do equity and fairness also play a role?
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” or so the old saying goes. But we don’t always practice what our folk wisdom preaches.
The U.S. medical system, as currently set up, rewards cardiac surgeons at a much greater rate than it does programs for avoiding weight gain or controlling high blood pressure.
About 5% or less of the U.S. budget on health care is spent on prevention, according to Don Wright of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Most of the rest is spent on treatment—and, I would venture to guess, paper work.
And yet, you can bet that if I ever experience a gripping pain in my chest or back, accompanied by nausea and perhaps an overwhelming sense of anxiety—classic signs of a heart attack in women—I am going to get myself to an emergency room right away to get treated and be mighty thankful if the specialists at the cardiac catheterization lab can open up any blocked arteries.
The year I spent at Harvard taught me a lot about how academics argue the prevention vs. treatment debate. Indeed, just a few years ago there was that rare thing in public health—a big public debate between some folks at the Gates Foundation on one side and some at Harvard on the other about whether prevention or treatment was the better—read more “cost-effective”—approach to tackling HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Eventually the Harvard side won the argument—especially once the cost of anti-retroviral therapy dropped dramatically. What made the difference was the fairness issue: How could you withhold treatment when so many were dying?
A few months in rural Malawi gave me a whole other perspective. There I learned that tremendous strides have been made in decreasing maternal death rates at the Embangweni Mission Hospital through a variety of efforts—not least of which was an emphasis on both prevention and treatment.
It did not happen by accident and it did not happen overnight. When the effort began, several years ago, there was only a single sink in the labor and delivery room. So improving the physical plant was a priority in terms of providing better treatment. Embangweni Hospital also worked really hard to get the right people in the ward—namely more nurses and clinical officers—and keep up their training. Alas, hard experience also taught them they had to make the ward off-limits to many of the grandmothers or “gogos,” who would slip their daughters and daughters-in-law a powerful herbal concoction to induce labor but that also increased the risk of potentially fatal uterine rupture.
On the prevention side, community health nurses have been working throughout the South Mzimbe region for the past ten years to provide prenatal care to pregnant women. To give just one example, the community health workers I met, like Joyce Ngoma and Tamala Chirwa, work hard to identify women who may have trouble delivering—because they are carrying twins or the fetus is not positioned properly. The nurses advise those women to go to the hospital early so that they can be watched more closely and scheduled for a caesarean operation, if need be.
Each side—prevention and treatment—benefits from the other. With fewer pregnant women showing up at the hospital in crisis, the clinical officers and nurses there are able to save more mothers' lives. The nurses in the field can see that their efforts have saved lives and are encouraged to do more prevention work.
Today's posts on Prevention vs. Treatment from other global health blogs (as I learn of them):
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” or so the old saying goes. But we don’t always practice what our folk wisdom preaches.
The U.S. medical system, as currently set up, rewards cardiac surgeons at a much greater rate than it does programs for avoiding weight gain or controlling high blood pressure.
About 5% or less of the U.S. budget on health care is spent on prevention, according to Don Wright of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Most of the rest is spent on treatment—and, I would venture to guess, paper work.
And yet, you can bet that if I ever experience a gripping pain in my chest or back, accompanied by nausea and perhaps an overwhelming sense of anxiety—classic signs of a heart attack in women—I am going to get myself to an emergency room right away to get treated and be mighty thankful if the specialists at the cardiac catheterization lab can open up any blocked arteries.
The year I spent at Harvard taught me a lot about how academics argue the prevention vs. treatment debate. Indeed, just a few years ago there was that rare thing in public health—a big public debate between some folks at the Gates Foundation on one side and some at Harvard on the other about whether prevention or treatment was the better—read more “cost-effective”—approach to tackling HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Eventually the Harvard side won the argument—especially once the cost of anti-retroviral therapy dropped dramatically. What made the difference was the fairness issue: How could you withhold treatment when so many were dying?
A few months in rural Malawi gave me a whole other perspective. There I learned that tremendous strides have been made in decreasing maternal death rates at the Embangweni Mission Hospital through a variety of efforts—not least of which was an emphasis on both prevention and treatment.
It did not happen by accident and it did not happen overnight. When the effort began, several years ago, there was only a single sink in the labor and delivery room. So improving the physical plant was a priority in terms of providing better treatment. Embangweni Hospital also worked really hard to get the right people in the ward—namely more nurses and clinical officers—and keep up their training. Alas, hard experience also taught them they had to make the ward off-limits to many of the grandmothers or “gogos,” who would slip their daughters and daughters-in-law a powerful herbal concoction to induce labor but that also increased the risk of potentially fatal uterine rupture.
On the prevention side, community health nurses have been working throughout the South Mzimbe region for the past ten years to provide prenatal care to pregnant women. To give just one example, the community health workers I met, like Joyce Ngoma and Tamala Chirwa, work hard to identify women who may have trouble delivering—because they are carrying twins or the fetus is not positioned properly. The nurses advise those women to go to the hospital early so that they can be watched more closely and scheduled for a caesarean operation, if need be.
Each side—prevention and treatment—benefits from the other. With fewer pregnant women showing up at the hospital in crisis, the clinical officers and nurses there are able to save more mothers' lives. The nurses in the field can see that their efforts have saved lives and are encouraged to do more prevention work.
Today's posts on Prevention vs. Treatment from other global health blogs (as I learn of them):
Healthtwine: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why "we tend to value current health more than future health."
Superbug: Prevention v. treatment (1st Global Health Blog Carnival!)
On the need for a vaccine against methicillin resistant staph aureus.
Perspectives: Prevention vs. Treatment
On why prevention vs. treatment is the wrong way to think about drug resistance to malaria.
Karen Grepin's Blog: Prevention vs. Treament in HIV: Have we given prevention a chance to shine?
Proving prevention works is a lot harder than you might think. Maybe that is another reason why there are so few studies on the effectiveness of prevention.
The Pump Handle: For Whom Prevention Pays
On one of the bigger, overlooked stories of public health in the U.S.--the faltering anti-tobacco struggle, another victim of the economic crisis.
HIV Information for Myanmar: Two Quotes from Bogyoke
A few words on the greater good from the late Bogyoke (General) Aung San, who led the fight for Burmese independence after World War II.
Health Reform Watch: Health Care, "Common Sense" and a Global Health Blogging Experiment
A bit off-topic and somewhat rambling (the French revolution?), but a look at whether concerns over health reform in the U.S. will crowd out discussion of global health.
Global Health at Change.org: Prevention vs. Treatment--an Eternal Debate?
On why good decisions in public health "are about balance, and looking for long-term systemic solutions instead of the quick fix."
And from a public relations perspective:
Ruder Finn's DotOrg (U.K.): The Lazarus Effect
Lucy asks "Are there are any differences between ’selling-in’ stories that have a prevention angle over those that emphasise treatment."
Thursday, 13 November 2008
Logging More Malawi Video
Oh thank goodness. This past weekend I discovered that just about everyone finds logging video tedious. I was at the Nieman Foundation’s 70th Anniversary convocation and telling my tale of woe about logging the video I had shot in Malawi to friends who are television producers and documentary makers.
Here I was afraid that I was doing something wrong—that something about my print journalism training had messed me up forever for dealing with video. What other explanation could there be if logging video was taking me so long and seemed so excruciating?
All the TV and video folks assured me that what I was feeling was absolutely normal. And that that sense of being overwhelmed by all the material I had gathered would eventually go away as I got better at planning my shots, producing and editing on the fly.
It is a situation that’s very akin to the kind of ruthless editing you have to do when you write. My friend Lorie Conway urged me to focus on just two stories out of the gigabytes and gigabytes of video, audio and digital stills I have—at least for now. Log to those stories (leaving out the bits that don’t support those pieces). I can always return to the original material later as time allows.
This may be easier said than done. Every time I go through the material I see more avenues to explore. Plus I feel such a sense of responsibility to the folks who shared so much of their lives with me. But you can’t do everything at once.
So I have been back at logging video with renewed vigor and once again combing through the photos Eileen took. Have also hired a journalism student for help with logging some of the audio. Will probably focus on a story about malaria and another about nurses’ daily challenges and successes at just one of the several hospitals I visited in Malawi.
One thing is for sure, the pregnant woman's lament has got to find a home in there somewhere.
Here I was afraid that I was doing something wrong—that something about my print journalism training had messed me up forever for dealing with video. What other explanation could there be if logging video was taking me so long and seemed so excruciating?
All the TV and video folks assured me that what I was feeling was absolutely normal. And that that sense of being overwhelmed by all the material I had gathered would eventually go away as I got better at planning my shots, producing and editing on the fly.
It is a situation that’s very akin to the kind of ruthless editing you have to do when you write. My friend Lorie Conway urged me to focus on just two stories out of the gigabytes and gigabytes of video, audio and digital stills I have—at least for now. Log to those stories (leaving out the bits that don’t support those pieces). I can always return to the original material later as time allows.
This may be easier said than done. Every time I go through the material I see more avenues to explore. Plus I feel such a sense of responsibility to the folks who shared so much of their lives with me. But you can’t do everything at once.
So I have been back at logging video with renewed vigor and once again combing through the photos Eileen took. Have also hired a journalism student for help with logging some of the audio. Will probably focus on a story about malaria and another about nurses’ daily challenges and successes at just one of the several hospitals I visited in Malawi.
One thing is for sure, the pregnant woman's lament has got to find a home in there somewhere.
Wednesday, 17 September 2008
Incident at Malawi Road Block
Every trip has its rough spots. Mine occurred on August 27 when we were detained by police for three hours after stopping at a road block in southern Malawi. It certainly felt like a shakedown—although the sergeant who flagged us down never directly asked for a bribe. And by the time it was all over, I was silently cursing both the police officer and our car rental agency—more on their involvement in a moment. I may never know what really happened, but I definitely learned a lesson about how difficult it can be to prove corruption or assign blame for it.
First some background. We were driving in a rental car from the city of Zomba, where I had interviewed several folks at the College of Health Sciences, back to Lilongwe. I was with my sister Michele and my friend Lisa, who accompanied me the last 10 days of the trip, and our driver Godfrey.
My original plan had been to do all the driving myself but after seeing how crowded the roads were with pedestrians, bikes, children, goats and chickens, I swallowed my pride and hired a driver. Although I had been told I could rent someone’s private car for much less than a rental car agency would charge, I was suspicious of breakdowns and so, after getting a recommendation, contacted Richard Phiri at the Sputnik Car Rental Agency in Lilongwe.
The car was a reconditioned Toyota Corolla. The driver a very nice guy named Godfrey. I wondered why there was no sign on the side of the automobile advertising Sputnik, but Richard assured me that was a security measure so that no one would target the car.
Ended up traveling all over Malawi in the two weeks I used the rental car. We must have passed through dozens of roadblocks—from the really permanent ones with metal barriers and guard posts to the more makeshift ones with just a pole across some barrels. Never had a problem anywhere. Mostly the officers waved us through. Occasionally they checked the insurance stickers on the windshield.
And in fact, my most sustained previous contact with a police officer had been quite pleasant, if the source of some amusement.
But half an hour or so out of Zomba, in the small town of Machinga, we came across a roadblock that had a different feel from the others. For one thing, there was only a single police officer manning it. For another, there were no vendors selling anything nearby.
After we stopped, the police officer glanced at the camera sitting in my lap and the large blue duffel we had stowed on the back seat (it didn’t fit with the other bags in the trunk). Then he asked for Godfrey’s driver’s license and asked who the car belonged to. Godfrey said “Putnik,” leaving off the “S” which I attributed to his being nervous.
Still holding Godfrey’s driver’s license, the officer—whose name I later learned was Sergeant Mbakkie—then walked over to the left side of the car to look at the insurance stickers and announced that one was missing. Then he walked back the road a bit to flag down several other vehicles.
While we waited, I called Richard Phiri at Sputnik and he immediately concluded that Mbakkie wanted a bribe. This seemed more than plausible since the newspapers had been full of stories about a charcoal seller in a Lilongwe neighborhood who was had just been shot dead by several policemen when he refused to pay them a bribe.
Richard told me not to worry, Sputnik would refund the cost of the bribe. I asked if I need to get a receipt (okay, so I was rattled) and he assured me he would trust me on the amount, which he figured would amount to a couple thousand kwacha or $13.50.
Except Sergeant Mbakkie never explicitly asked for money. He just kept talking about how we had to go to court because the car had been hired illegally, that we would need to wait our turn like everyone else, that it would probably take all day, etc. I figured he was building everything up so that we would be grateful that he would take a bribe. But I was much too chicken to offer money because, of course, bribery is against the law and I didn’t want to be caught doing something that was definitely illegal because of something that might or might not be taking place.
I will admit that I was scared enough in the first half hour that if Mbakkie had directly asked for money at that point, I would have forked it over and been happy to go on our way. But as more time passed, I calmed down and kept telling myself not to get pressured into anything.
At critical moments the conversation between Mbakkie and Godfrey turned from English into Chichewe, which of course I couldn’t follow. We had now been stopped on the side of the road for half an hour and no one came by the car to sell tomatoes or curios or practice their English—that seemed pretty telling.
After one long discussion, Godfrey said the police wanted us to pull off the road and into the police station. I refused, reasoning that the more visible we were—even if no one was coming near us—the better off we were. That also seemed odd—that we could just say no, weren’t going to move the car, without any apparent consequences.
And in fact, later, when Sergeant Mbakkie tried to hold on to my copy of the rental car contract, which I had showed him, I simply took it out of his hands and said, “That’s my property.” And he let me keep it.
Two older women walked by at one point and made some sympathetic remarks when my sister explained the situation to them but then they headed on their way.
By this point I had called my friend Kondwani Munthali, who is a journalist for The Nation, one of three big newspapers in Malawi. (Really glad I had kept my cell phone fully charged and had plenty of airtime for it.) Kondwani ended up speaking to both Sergeant Mbakkie and Richard Phiri at Sputnik. Then I spoke with them in English and then Godfrey spoke with everyone in Chichewa.
It started to feel at some point like all these conversations were taking place at cross-purposes. Sergeant Mbakkie would walk away from us with no explanation into the police station and then come back out again—all the while holding on to Godfrey’s driver’s license. But I kept thinking that it was important to make sure as many people knew about our situation as possible. And so I focused on that. I also knew it wouldn’t do any good to get angry or raise my voice.
Then Godfrey decided to go into the police station—forbidding me from coming with him and promising that things would work out—and when he came out, he announced that Sergeant Mbakkie had agreed that since I didn’t want to take care of this in Machinga, we could go to the next biggest town—Liwonde—about 30 minutes away to deal with it.
After waiting at the Liwonde road block (which turned out to be the wrong place) and then meeting up with Sergaent Mbakkie again at the Liwonde Police Station a couple of kilometers away, we were introduced to a new character in this drama—the prosecutor.
By this point both the prosecutor and Sergeant Mbakkie told me that neither I nor my fellow passengers had done anything wrong. It was Godfrey, our driver, who was being charged. That gave me the opening to ask to see the charges, which is how I learned the police officer’s name.
The prosecutor took me to his office where Godfrey and I sat on a low wooden bench. The official statement was handwritten in English and stated that Godfrey had confessed voluntarily to driving a car for hire that was not properly registered as a rental car. (So that’s what Godfrey was doing in the police station in Machinga.) In essence, the prosecutor told us, it was the equivalent of driving a stolen car and the punishment could be five years in prison.
The most tangible proof, the prosecutor said, was that our car—like most private cars—had yellow license plates with black lettering. Rental cars were supposed to have white plates with red lettering.
I asked Godfrey if he had indeed admitted to the charge and he said he had because he thought it would move things along. (So he didn’t want me there because I might have kept him from signing?)
At this point, the only thing I could hold on to was the fact that both the prosecutor and Sergeant Mbakkie had said that I and my fellow passengers had done nothing wrong. So I pushed that point with the prosecutor, asked repeatedly why we were being held—we were now coming up on three hours—if we had done nothing wrong and then called Richard Phiri at Sputnik for the umpteenth time and told him that if he had rented us an improperly registered car it was his problem and he needed to work things out with the prosecutor.
So Phiri and the prosecutor had a long talk on my cell phone and I’m not sure what they said or even if this was the conversation that turned things around but at some point I realized that we were going to get out of all this, it was just going to take a little time and there would have to be some kind of face-saving mechanism. But there would be no bribe.
In retrospect, I realize the prosecutor might have been asking for money when he said “isn’t there someone you can call to cancel all this?” but I was not swift enough to pick up on that.
I guess I had been in the prosecutor’s office long enough that Michele started to worry and came in asking if I was okay. I said yes and tried to communicate with my eyes that I thought things had turned.
At any rate, after pointing out to the prosecutor yet again by his own admission that three of us hadn’t done anything wrong, that we had been detained for the entire morning, that we wanted to be back in Lilongwe before dark due to the dangers of driving at night, the face-saving mechanism appeared.
Sergeant Mbakkie would hold on to Godfrey’s driver’s license but give him a sheet of paper allowing him to drive without a driver’s license, pending a court appearance. Godfrey would drive us the remaining four hours to Lilongwe but agree to return the next day for his court appearance.
And so we were off. We had lost three hours, our appetites and a few previously warm feelings about Malawi. We checked out all the license plates on every vehicle we passed on the way back to Lilongwe and sure enough the private vehicles all had yellow plates with black lettering, the taxis and mini-buses had white plates with red lettering and the vehicles driven by non-government organizations had white plates with blue lettering.
The hardest part for me was trying to figure out who was at fault.
There seemed no question that Sergeant Mbakkie considered three women traveling on their own to be easy marks. But it also seemed pretty likely that our rental car was in fact improperly registered. (And in fact, Michele pointed out that the insurance stickers, once we had cause to look at them, showed the car was registered to Richard Phiri and not to Sputnik.)
This suspicion seemed even more justified when Richard immediately agreed to my demand for a 10% discount on the balance of our rental car payment (guess I should have asked for more) all the while denying that there was anything wrong with the car’s registration.
Why the rental car agency would provide us with a car (and driver) without the right papers or plates is a whole other issue. The most charitable explanation is that they didn’t have enough cars in their fleet and were trying to be accommodating.
On the other hand, if they were trying to cut corners, they sure weren’t very good at it. They should have come up with a better cover story for Godfrey to tell the police officer—something like Mr. Phiri has loaned his personal car to these ladies to drive through Malawi or this is a company car—but then, of course, we would have known something was off-kilter.
I realize I am placing more responsibility on Richard than on Godfrey in this whole affair. But Richard had more authority in the matter and Godfrey seemed more caught in the middle.
At any rate, Godfrey drove back to Liwonde the next day for his court appearance and told us the charge was dropped and showed us his recovered driver’s license to prove it. Later, Richard tried to smooth things over by saying that Mbakkie had been reassigned after being reprimanded for giving trouble to tourists—but whether or not that was true, it actually made us feel worse.
In the end, Michele, Lisa and I came away thinking that neither the police officer nor the car agency was on the up and up. I also learned that blatant corruption is not the only kind you have to watch out for. And that just because you try to do the right thing—like hire a car from a legitimate car rental agency—doesn’t mean you will succeed.
But I’d be interested in learning, by your comments below, what you think, what you might have done in the same circumstances or if you’ve had a similar experience.
First some background. We were driving in a rental car from the city of Zomba, where I had interviewed several folks at the College of Health Sciences, back to Lilongwe. I was with my sister Michele and my friend Lisa, who accompanied me the last 10 days of the trip, and our driver Godfrey.
My original plan had been to do all the driving myself but after seeing how crowded the roads were with pedestrians, bikes, children, goats and chickens, I swallowed my pride and hired a driver. Although I had been told I could rent someone’s private car for much less than a rental car agency would charge, I was suspicious of breakdowns and so, after getting a recommendation, contacted Richard Phiri at the Sputnik Car Rental Agency in Lilongwe.
The car was a reconditioned Toyota Corolla. The driver a very nice guy named Godfrey. I wondered why there was no sign on the side of the automobile advertising Sputnik, but Richard assured me that was a security measure so that no one would target the car.
Ended up traveling all over Malawi in the two weeks I used the rental car. We must have passed through dozens of roadblocks—from the really permanent ones with metal barriers and guard posts to the more makeshift ones with just a pole across some barrels. Never had a problem anywhere. Mostly the officers waved us through. Occasionally they checked the insurance stickers on the windshield.
And in fact, my most sustained previous contact with a police officer had been quite pleasant, if the source of some amusement.
But half an hour or so out of Zomba, in the small town of Machinga, we came across a roadblock that had a different feel from the others. For one thing, there was only a single police officer manning it. For another, there were no vendors selling anything nearby.
After we stopped, the police officer glanced at the camera sitting in my lap and the large blue duffel we had stowed on the back seat (it didn’t fit with the other bags in the trunk). Then he asked for Godfrey’s driver’s license and asked who the car belonged to. Godfrey said “Putnik,” leaving off the “S” which I attributed to his being nervous.
Still holding Godfrey’s driver’s license, the officer—whose name I later learned was Sergeant Mbakkie—then walked over to the left side of the car to look at the insurance stickers and announced that one was missing. Then he walked back the road a bit to flag down several other vehicles.
While we waited, I called Richard Phiri at Sputnik and he immediately concluded that Mbakkie wanted a bribe. This seemed more than plausible since the newspapers had been full of stories about a charcoal seller in a Lilongwe neighborhood who was had just been shot dead by several policemen when he refused to pay them a bribe.
Richard told me not to worry, Sputnik would refund the cost of the bribe. I asked if I need to get a receipt (okay, so I was rattled) and he assured me he would trust me on the amount, which he figured would amount to a couple thousand kwacha or $13.50.
Except Sergeant Mbakkie never explicitly asked for money. He just kept talking about how we had to go to court because the car had been hired illegally, that we would need to wait our turn like everyone else, that it would probably take all day, etc. I figured he was building everything up so that we would be grateful that he would take a bribe. But I was much too chicken to offer money because, of course, bribery is against the law and I didn’t want to be caught doing something that was definitely illegal because of something that might or might not be taking place.
I will admit that I was scared enough in the first half hour that if Mbakkie had directly asked for money at that point, I would have forked it over and been happy to go on our way. But as more time passed, I calmed down and kept telling myself not to get pressured into anything.
At critical moments the conversation between Mbakkie and Godfrey turned from English into Chichewe, which of course I couldn’t follow. We had now been stopped on the side of the road for half an hour and no one came by the car to sell tomatoes or curios or practice their English—that seemed pretty telling.
After one long discussion, Godfrey said the police wanted us to pull off the road and into the police station. I refused, reasoning that the more visible we were—even if no one was coming near us—the better off we were. That also seemed odd—that we could just say no, weren’t going to move the car, without any apparent consequences.
And in fact, later, when Sergeant Mbakkie tried to hold on to my copy of the rental car contract, which I had showed him, I simply took it out of his hands and said, “That’s my property.” And he let me keep it.
Two older women walked by at one point and made some sympathetic remarks when my sister explained the situation to them but then they headed on their way.
By this point I had called my friend Kondwani Munthali, who is a journalist for The Nation, one of three big newspapers in Malawi. (Really glad I had kept my cell phone fully charged and had plenty of airtime for it.) Kondwani ended up speaking to both Sergeant Mbakkie and Richard Phiri at Sputnik. Then I spoke with them in English and then Godfrey spoke with everyone in Chichewa.
It started to feel at some point like all these conversations were taking place at cross-purposes. Sergeant Mbakkie would walk away from us with no explanation into the police station and then come back out again—all the while holding on to Godfrey’s driver’s license. But I kept thinking that it was important to make sure as many people knew about our situation as possible. And so I focused on that. I also knew it wouldn’t do any good to get angry or raise my voice.
Then Godfrey decided to go into the police station—forbidding me from coming with him and promising that things would work out—and when he came out, he announced that Sergeant Mbakkie had agreed that since I didn’t want to take care of this in Machinga, we could go to the next biggest town—Liwonde—about 30 minutes away to deal with it.
After waiting at the Liwonde road block (which turned out to be the wrong place) and then meeting up with Sergaent Mbakkie again at the Liwonde Police Station a couple of kilometers away, we were introduced to a new character in this drama—the prosecutor.
By this point both the prosecutor and Sergeant Mbakkie told me that neither I nor my fellow passengers had done anything wrong. It was Godfrey, our driver, who was being charged. That gave me the opening to ask to see the charges, which is how I learned the police officer’s name.
The prosecutor took me to his office where Godfrey and I sat on a low wooden bench. The official statement was handwritten in English and stated that Godfrey had confessed voluntarily to driving a car for hire that was not properly registered as a rental car. (So that’s what Godfrey was doing in the police station in Machinga.) In essence, the prosecutor told us, it was the equivalent of driving a stolen car and the punishment could be five years in prison.
The most tangible proof, the prosecutor said, was that our car—like most private cars—had yellow license plates with black lettering. Rental cars were supposed to have white plates with red lettering.
I asked Godfrey if he had indeed admitted to the charge and he said he had because he thought it would move things along. (So he didn’t want me there because I might have kept him from signing?)
At this point, the only thing I could hold on to was the fact that both the prosecutor and Sergeant Mbakkie had said that I and my fellow passengers had done nothing wrong. So I pushed that point with the prosecutor, asked repeatedly why we were being held—we were now coming up on three hours—if we had done nothing wrong and then called Richard Phiri at Sputnik for the umpteenth time and told him that if he had rented us an improperly registered car it was his problem and he needed to work things out with the prosecutor.
So Phiri and the prosecutor had a long talk on my cell phone and I’m not sure what they said or even if this was the conversation that turned things around but at some point I realized that we were going to get out of all this, it was just going to take a little time and there would have to be some kind of face-saving mechanism. But there would be no bribe.
In retrospect, I realize the prosecutor might have been asking for money when he said “isn’t there someone you can call to cancel all this?” but I was not swift enough to pick up on that.
I guess I had been in the prosecutor’s office long enough that Michele started to worry and came in asking if I was okay. I said yes and tried to communicate with my eyes that I thought things had turned.
At any rate, after pointing out to the prosecutor yet again by his own admission that three of us hadn’t done anything wrong, that we had been detained for the entire morning, that we wanted to be back in Lilongwe before dark due to the dangers of driving at night, the face-saving mechanism appeared.
Sergeant Mbakkie would hold on to Godfrey’s driver’s license but give him a sheet of paper allowing him to drive without a driver’s license, pending a court appearance. Godfrey would drive us the remaining four hours to Lilongwe but agree to return the next day for his court appearance.
And so we were off. We had lost three hours, our appetites and a few previously warm feelings about Malawi. We checked out all the license plates on every vehicle we passed on the way back to Lilongwe and sure enough the private vehicles all had yellow plates with black lettering, the taxis and mini-buses had white plates with red lettering and the vehicles driven by non-government organizations had white plates with blue lettering.
The hardest part for me was trying to figure out who was at fault.
There seemed no question that Sergeant Mbakkie considered three women traveling on their own to be easy marks. But it also seemed pretty likely that our rental car was in fact improperly registered. (And in fact, Michele pointed out that the insurance stickers, once we had cause to look at them, showed the car was registered to Richard Phiri and not to Sputnik.)
This suspicion seemed even more justified when Richard immediately agreed to my demand for a 10% discount on the balance of our rental car payment (guess I should have asked for more) all the while denying that there was anything wrong with the car’s registration.
Why the rental car agency would provide us with a car (and driver) without the right papers or plates is a whole other issue. The most charitable explanation is that they didn’t have enough cars in their fleet and were trying to be accommodating.
On the other hand, if they were trying to cut corners, they sure weren’t very good at it. They should have come up with a better cover story for Godfrey to tell the police officer—something like Mr. Phiri has loaned his personal car to these ladies to drive through Malawi or this is a company car—but then, of course, we would have known something was off-kilter.
I realize I am placing more responsibility on Richard than on Godfrey in this whole affair. But Richard had more authority in the matter and Godfrey seemed more caught in the middle.
At any rate, Godfrey drove back to Liwonde the next day for his court appearance and told us the charge was dropped and showed us his recovered driver’s license to prove it. Later, Richard tried to smooth things over by saying that Mbakkie had been reassigned after being reprimanded for giving trouble to tourists—but whether or not that was true, it actually made us feel worse.
In the end, Michele, Lisa and I came away thinking that neither the police officer nor the car agency was on the up and up. I also learned that blatant corruption is not the only kind you have to watch out for. And that just because you try to do the right thing—like hire a car from a legitimate car rental agency—doesn’t mean you will succeed.
But I’d be interested in learning, by your comments below, what you think, what you might have done in the same circumstances or if you’ve had a similar experience.
Friday, 15 August 2008
Back in Lilongwe
Starting to think of this as my second home. The five-hour trip from Neno was uneventful--best kind. Now to find some lunch.
Thursday, 14 August 2008
Heading to Lilongwe
Will spend the weekend in the capital, greet some new visitors from the U.S. and bid farewell to Eileen, who is heading home with literally thousands of photos on her hard drives. (Eileen wants me to put in that not all of the pictures are good but I've seen many that I liked very much.)
Then it's a little R-and-R at the Lake, where I'll have time to reflect a lot more on my 12-week sojourn in Malawi, followed by game-viewing in Liwonde plus a trip to Zomba to meet more nursing instructors.
As usual, will post more items and photos as time and internet access allow.
Then it's a little R-and-R at the Lake, where I'll have time to reflect a lot more on my 12-week sojourn in Malawi, followed by game-viewing in Liwonde plus a trip to Zomba to meet more nursing instructors.
As usual, will post more items and photos as time and internet access allow.
Running Low on Food in August
Have learned in two places now that at least some rural areas of Malawi are already starting to run out of food. Heard predictions in the north last month that people would start running out of food in mid-August. Spoke with a group of folks from villages surrounding Neno this morning and they said the rains had been poor in this area as well and they also were starting to run out of what they had grown.
Because Malawi depends on subsistence farming, with little to no irrigation, it has a single growing season so there is always a hungry period when crops are first planted in November. August is a bit early for people to start running out of food but there are no predictions of a widespread famine like the one that hit about five years ago.
As for buying maize, the price of 50 kilos, which might feed a family of eight for a week, is now 3500 kwachas (US $23) , compared to 1500 kwachas (US $10) at the same time last year.
Because Malawi depends on subsistence farming, with little to no irrigation, it has a single growing season so there is always a hungry period when crops are first planted in November. August is a bit early for people to start running out of food but there are no predictions of a widespread famine like the one that hit about five years ago.
As for buying maize, the price of 50 kilos, which might feed a family of eight for a week, is now 3500 kwachas (US $23) , compared to 1500 kwachas (US $10) at the same time last year.
Fish Outlet and Fashion Centre
That was the sign above a store we passed last week in the car on the way from Mulanje. Wasn’t quick enough to get a picture but just the idea of combining a “fish outlet” and “fashion centre” made me smile. Of course, one of the nurses we met in northern Malawi had a thriving business selling dried fish as well as used clothing from a couple of tables outside her home so perhaps it’s not such a bad idea after all.
In fact, have noticed that many of the nurses who appear to be making a go of things in rural Malawi have some kind of business income beyond their nursing salary or even their locum payments (more on locums in a future post). They often grow maize (both for themselves and for sale) or keep chickens as well.
Not every nurse is necessarily a good farmer or businessperson, of course. But if you’re trying to figure out how to make nursing in rural areas more attractive, it seems you might pay attention to opportunities for creating outside income—and not just pocket change but real income for school fees and the like.
Professional groups like nurses might be a good target audience for micro-credit enterprises—provided, as always, things are done correctly with plenty of education about what it means to borrow money. One idea: loans for fertilizer that make higher crop yields possible.
Which brings up another point: lack of access to affordable credit. I’ve been astonished at the high interest rates in Malawi. If you can get a loan from the bank, the rate is around 25%. Micro-credit and private money-lenders charge a lot more.
I’ve seen a couple of billboards for Blue, the South African financial company, and met a man in Lilongwe who works for them. Their effective interest rate is 50%, he told me. I have been told of a local micro-credit group here in Neno that charges 60% (and apparently doesn’t have many customers.) The loans may be unsecured but at those interest rates, I can’t see how anyone can get ahead.
In fact, have noticed that many of the nurses who appear to be making a go of things in rural Malawi have some kind of business income beyond their nursing salary or even their locum payments (more on locums in a future post). They often grow maize (both for themselves and for sale) or keep chickens as well.
Not every nurse is necessarily a good farmer or businessperson, of course. But if you’re trying to figure out how to make nursing in rural areas more attractive, it seems you might pay attention to opportunities for creating outside income—and not just pocket change but real income for school fees and the like.
Professional groups like nurses might be a good target audience for micro-credit enterprises—provided, as always, things are done correctly with plenty of education about what it means to borrow money. One idea: loans for fertilizer that make higher crop yields possible.
Which brings up another point: lack of access to affordable credit. I’ve been astonished at the high interest rates in Malawi. If you can get a loan from the bank, the rate is around 25%. Micro-credit and private money-lenders charge a lot more.
I’ve seen a couple of billboards for Blue, the South African financial company, and met a man in Lilongwe who works for them. Their effective interest rate is 50%, he told me. I have been told of a local micro-credit group here in Neno that charges 60% (and apparently doesn’t have many customers.) The loans may be unsecured but at those interest rates, I can’t see how anyone can get ahead.
Wednesday, 13 August 2008
More Thoughts From the Road
Want to write more about the trip to Chilimbondo in the Dambe Traditional Authority. We drove for about an hour and a half from Neno on a rocky road ever higher. Went through several areas where there were no villages, but everywhere there were signs of human cultivation: furrowed fields on the hillsides, crops planted in the flood plains of tiny streams, even a few stands of wheat glistening a tender pale green in the sun.
And of course, hillsides dotted with just a few saplings plus the odd mature tree standing as a lonely sentinel on the ridge. I remarked on this to one of my benchmates in the back of the ambulance. Fifteen minutes later he pointed out a thick grove of magnificent tall trees on the side of the hill and told me that it surrounded a cemetery. No one had cut the trees for firewood or burned them to make charcoal out of respect for the dead.
Several times the driver had to slow down almost to a stop to work the ambulance around a boulder or a dip in the road. Before every blind curve, he tapped on the horn a couple times to announce our imminent arrival. And often, in fact, there was a group of children playing or women carrying water, parcels or stacks of firewood. We passed a few bicycles being pushed up the hills or coasted down the other side.
As I was admiring the driver’s skill and the ambulance's brakes, I suddenly remembered the report from a couple weeks ago that a heavily laden truck with 50 people had overturned on a dirt road near Mzimbe, killing at least half the passengers. Then I thought about about the accident we passed on the road to Lilongwe. No point dwelling on the risk—it was out of my hands—and I pushed those thoughts away.
Came to the top of one ridge and suddenly there was a large community of at least 150 or more huts spread out on the slopes below us. We passed through the village and saw oxen—our first in quite a while—along with the usual goats, chickens and, of course, people. Most of the buildings were round mud huts topped with thatch—although every now and then you would see a square one or even a brick structure. Very few homes this far out had roofs made of iron sheets.
Caught myself thinking, as we passed through the village again on the way back, how authentic it all looked. The rondavels capped by thatch, the simple designs painted on a few of the homes. But then, as always with me, that second thought. Did that mean I had been disappointed by the sturdier brick structures I had seen in Embangweni, some with satellite dishes sprouting from their iron sheeted roofs? Would I deny anyone the chance for electricity, running water, better communications, health care and education out of a misplaced loyalty to some artificial ideal of the authentic—whatever that is?
Realize I am projecting my own struggle with what is authentic in my life and my chosen profession onto these sturdy huts. Reminds me of all the bright young people I met in Massachusetts this past year who have become so enthusiastic about global health. One of the biggest attractions—no matter what they may say about justice—seems to be that desire for meaning, to see that you are making a difference every day and not just to take it on faith. Our motivations are always mixed.
Must be coming to the end of the trip. All these ruminations. Well, that’s normal, I guess. This is the time to reflect before I start collating the interviews, the impressions, the memories I have gathered and buckling down to write. Or in the immortal more direct words of Andrew Quinn, one my compatriots in Nieman fellowship, “I am learning a great deal. But is it going to translate into copy? Sheeeeez.”
And of course, hillsides dotted with just a few saplings plus the odd mature tree standing as a lonely sentinel on the ridge. I remarked on this to one of my benchmates in the back of the ambulance. Fifteen minutes later he pointed out a thick grove of magnificent tall trees on the side of the hill and told me that it surrounded a cemetery. No one had cut the trees for firewood or burned them to make charcoal out of respect for the dead.
Several times the driver had to slow down almost to a stop to work the ambulance around a boulder or a dip in the road. Before every blind curve, he tapped on the horn a couple times to announce our imminent arrival. And often, in fact, there was a group of children playing or women carrying water, parcels or stacks of firewood. We passed a few bicycles being pushed up the hills or coasted down the other side.
As I was admiring the driver’s skill and the ambulance's brakes, I suddenly remembered the report from a couple weeks ago that a heavily laden truck with 50 people had overturned on a dirt road near Mzimbe, killing at least half the passengers. Then I thought about about the accident we passed on the road to Lilongwe. No point dwelling on the risk—it was out of my hands—and I pushed those thoughts away.
Came to the top of one ridge and suddenly there was a large community of at least 150 or more huts spread out on the slopes below us. We passed through the village and saw oxen—our first in quite a while—along with the usual goats, chickens and, of course, people. Most of the buildings were round mud huts topped with thatch—although every now and then you would see a square one or even a brick structure. Very few homes this far out had roofs made of iron sheets.
Caught myself thinking, as we passed through the village again on the way back, how authentic it all looked. The rondavels capped by thatch, the simple designs painted on a few of the homes. But then, as always with me, that second thought. Did that mean I had been disappointed by the sturdier brick structures I had seen in Embangweni, some with satellite dishes sprouting from their iron sheeted roofs? Would I deny anyone the chance for electricity, running water, better communications, health care and education out of a misplaced loyalty to some artificial ideal of the authentic—whatever that is?
Realize I am projecting my own struggle with what is authentic in my life and my chosen profession onto these sturdy huts. Reminds me of all the bright young people I met in Massachusetts this past year who have become so enthusiastic about global health. One of the biggest attractions—no matter what they may say about justice—seems to be that desire for meaning, to see that you are making a difference every day and not just to take it on faith. Our motivations are always mixed.
Must be coming to the end of the trip. All these ruminations. Well, that’s normal, I guess. This is the time to reflect before I start collating the interviews, the impressions, the memories I have gathered and buckling down to write. Or in the immortal more direct words of Andrew Quinn, one my compatriots in Nieman fellowship, “I am learning a great deal. But is it going to translate into copy? Sheeeeez.”
Tuesday, 12 August 2008
Rocky Road to Dambe

Just back from three hours on bumpy, dusty roads into the hills right on the border with Mozambique. What a blast and am I ever glad I don’t have to do that every day! We packed into the back of an ambulance with Matilda Nyambo and her team from Neno District Hospital and climbed up a rocky, dusty road to the hillside village of Chilimbonde in the Dambe Traditional Authority. (More on Neno and the Ministry of Health's partnership with two international organizations in a future post.)
We followed the ridge most of the way and so had a good view of Mozambique to one side of the vehicle and Malawi to the other. In fact, because the road forms the border for part of the way, I was riding in Malawi on the way out and came back through Mozambique!
Seems every nurse who goes on a mobile clinic is part actress—and Matilda is no exception. I enjoyed watching her engage the group of 100-plus women and children and listen to them laugh at some of her pantomines.
Of course every good act needs an opener; there was singing and a lecture on the use of bed nets to prevent the transmission of malaria. Because the bednets are donated they can only be given to mothers with children under the age of a year. And yet, everyone seems to want them.
And so another odd complication. When the bednets were for sale, anyone could buy them but no one could afford them. Now that they’re free, they are limited to pregnant women and mothers with children under the age of one.
(For a while they were given to pregnant women and those with children under the age of five—the highest risk groups—but everywhere I’ve been in Malawi, I’m told the target now is pregnant women and kids under the age of one.)
But a number of people on the ground are trying to get bed nets for everyone--including adults with HIV, who seem particularly vulnerable to malaria.
NB: In the original version of this post, I said we had traveled to the village of Dambe. I learned afterwards that we traveled to Chilimbondo, which is in the Dambe Traditional Authority. We did not go to the village of Dambe, which is the chief's headquarters.
Sunday, 10 August 2008
Arrival in Neno
Have arrived safely at the PIH facility in Neno after about 45 minutes on a tarmac road and about an hour on a dirt road. I'm becoming quite the connoisseur of dirt roads. This one is more rocky as we climb the side of several hills whereas most of the others we have been on are more sandy.
The caps lock key on my laptop seems to have inverted itself somehow on the ride. So when the green light is depressed, I get normal upper and lower case but when it's out, THE LETTERS ARE ALL UPPER CASE. (Seems to have something to do with the "num lock" key. ) But other than that, we and our equipment seem to have survived the journey.
The other big news is that there is wifi in the guest house--the fastest connection we've yet had in Malawi--so I'll be able to post items throughout the week. Alas, no Celtel mobile service but Malawi Telekom is supposed to work.
Heading to Neno
The driver from Partners in Health is going to pick us up at noon. Once again, I think we will be beyond the reach of the Internet for a while and possibly even of text messaging. But by the end of the week, we should be back in Lilongwe and have internet access.
Linking the Local and the International Perspective

8 August
Arrived in Blantyre this morning. Spent this afternoon talking with Tulipoka Soko, the chief nursing officer at Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, and some of her colleagues.
I had tried to make arrangements from the U.S. to talk with nursing staff at QECH but hadn’t gotten anywhere. But when I showed up on Tuesday to set up the interview for today, Mrs. Soko was quite open and willing to talk. Some things you just can’t plan ahead.
This brings up another point. I have tried not to rely too much on expatriates in doing my reporting in Malawi. It’s not that I have anything against expatriates and indeed you have to talk to some international folks to get a good picture. But you can’t leave out the people who are working locally, in government, in hospitals, in local civic organizations. And even within Malawi, you certainly don’t want to talk only to people at the highest levels.
This is often harder than you might think. For one thing, expatriates often come at things from familiar perspectives, so it’s usually easier to get a good grasp on what they are saying. And expatriates are often easier to contact from the U.S. So there’s a built-in bias towards folks who have more access to international communications.
But by being here in Malawi, and spending nearly three months here, I have been able to meet lots of people—like Mrs. Soko—who are quite open about their experience, the joys and challenges of where they work.
That doesn’t mean you have a magic crystal ball and everything suddenly becomes clear. (Would love to spend more time at QECH to delve deeper into the daily experience of patients and ward nurses, for example.) But it certainly gives a better picture than if you limit yourself entirely to those with an international perspective and status.
Charcoal and Deforestation
Although my primary focus in Malawi is nurses and the health system, I can’t help but notice other issues—like deforestation. Many of the hills that I have seen in southern Malawi have been stripped bare of trees to feed the need for charcoal.
Even the forest preserves around Mulanje Massif are starting to show the effects. A new road from Blantyre to Mulanje has opened up—which cut the trip to less than an hour by car. But that has also meant charcoal sellers can easily bike their way up to Blantyre from Mulanje. The photo above is of a charcoal seller who has wrapped his wares in plastic so as not to get in trouble with the forest rangers.
The economics of the issue are compelling. Charcoal is less expensive for cooking than electricity. Charcoal in the rural areas may cost 300 to 400 MK for one of these huge bags but 800 MK in town and that could last you a month. So what happens when all the trees are gone? When you’re trying to make it to the end of the day alive, tomorrow is a luxury.
Saturday, 9 August 2008
Filling out the Picture
7 August 2008
When I first came to Malawi, one of the questions that was uppermost in my mind was why nurses leave the country to work in the U.K. or other English-speaking countries or why so many leave the public sector to work for non-government organizations or private hospitals and clinics. But in truth, that's pretty easy to understand. Much of it boils down to better pay, better working conditions (fewer hours, fewer patients, more resources), better housing and more opportunities for their children.
What has been a lot harder to get at is why nurses stay in Malawi, particularly why they stay in the public sector. Catherine Ndolo in Embangweni taught me to look at relationships, at how much the workplace demonstrates that it cares about both its patients and its staff. Others have talked about the opportunity to advance—that they stay with government positions because, after a few years, the Ministry of Health will pay to upgrade their education.
Then in just the past two days I spoke with two nurses—Grant Ngugluwe and Maureen Juma—who had almost diametrically opposed views. Both of them work in Mulanje. Maureen is a nurse tutor at the Mulanje Mission College of Nursing. Grant works in the male ward at the Mulanje Mission Hospital. I talked with each of them separately so it's a little unfair to compare their responses. But they stated their positions so eloquently like that I couldn't help but play one against the other.
Both of them are from the younger generation of Malawians, who have graduated from nursing school in just the past five years. Neither has the sense of caution that I witnessed so often in older nurses—many of whom learned from bitter experience during the Banda era not to rock any boats.
Grant took the more cynical view. When I told him that many nurses told me they stayed because they loved their country—and who would look after their remaining family if everyone left—he told me he wasn't so sure patriotism played such a big role. "Maybe they don't know how to go overseas?" he said. "Much as everyone talks of professional dedication, everyone is looking for better jobs."
He confirmed my suspicion that one way many nurses make the contacts needed to emigrate is by first working for an international NGO. "If you work for an NGO, then you have access to the internet," Grant said. "You also have more access to information in general. You make contact with people in the field."
Then of course there are also friends and classmates who have already made the move abroad.
Grant thought family ties played a stronger role than patriotism in determining whether registered nurses stayed or left. (Nurse midwife technicians—who provide the bulk of Malawi's nursing care—do not have an internationally marketable degree. But it's impressive to see how many upgrade to a bachelor's in registered nursing.)
Maureen Juma, on the other hand, was passionate about the need to serve—and she sounded very sincere to me.
(I've also talked with several nursing students who clearly thought that the patriotic line was a good one and had probably used it for their nursing school interviews. I had to make sure not to smile during some of those interviews—especially when I heard the almost identical phrases coming out of different students' mouths.)
What's particularly interesting to me is to compare the transcript of what Maureen said to the actual recording of her words. Her passion really grabs you through the headphones in a way that the simple transcript doesn't. Comes back to that issue of what each medium does best. Audio is ideal for conveying emotion. Print is an excellent vehicle for giving detailed information—facts, figures and analyses.
One thing Maureen was especially passionate about was how often Europeans and Americans focus on what's missing in Malawi. She says she was particularly struck by this during a recent trip to Norway for advanced training in nursing education. One person very patronizingly started to explain to her what a computer was. "As if we didn't have computers in Malawi," she exclaimed. Another went so far as to ask "if they have cars in your country?"
Her words were coming out so fast by this point in the interview that some of them got a little jumbled up. But the point was clear. A lot of people come to Malawi prepared only to see the worst.
"These people take only bad pictures and they don't know that there's the good side of things," Maureen said. "They think that when you go to Malawi you are going to find people that are dying of hunger, people that are all HIV positive. That's not the news and that's not the situation. Malawi is also a country that has got its own potentials. And it's got things that are good—a lot of them. Apart from having the Lake [Lake Malawi], apart from having the Mountain [Mulanje Massif], we've got people like us who are willing to work in Malawi and stay here for good."
It was a message to the world but also a message to me and to Eileen about what we are doing in Malawi—about making sure we show both the positive and the negative.
I told Maureen I agree that photos and stories from Malawi often emphasize the negative at the expense of the positives that do exist. I've tried on this trip to get a much broader picture—no whitewashing but no unnecessary gloom either. Realize this could be a tough one to pull off. But I'm going to give it my best shot.
When I first came to Malawi, one of the questions that was uppermost in my mind was why nurses leave the country to work in the U.K. or other English-speaking countries or why so many leave the public sector to work for non-government organizations or private hospitals and clinics. But in truth, that's pretty easy to understand. Much of it boils down to better pay, better working conditions (fewer hours, fewer patients, more resources), better housing and more opportunities for their children.
What has been a lot harder to get at is why nurses stay in Malawi, particularly why they stay in the public sector. Catherine Ndolo in Embangweni taught me to look at relationships, at how much the workplace demonstrates that it cares about both its patients and its staff. Others have talked about the opportunity to advance—that they stay with government positions because, after a few years, the Ministry of Health will pay to upgrade their education.
Then in just the past two days I spoke with two nurses—Grant Ngugluwe and Maureen Juma—who had almost diametrically opposed views. Both of them work in Mulanje. Maureen is a nurse tutor at the Mulanje Mission College of Nursing. Grant works in the male ward at the Mulanje Mission Hospital. I talked with each of them separately so it's a little unfair to compare their responses. But they stated their positions so eloquently like that I couldn't help but play one against the other.
Both of them are from the younger generation of Malawians, who have graduated from nursing school in just the past five years. Neither has the sense of caution that I witnessed so often in older nurses—many of whom learned from bitter experience during the Banda era not to rock any boats.
Grant took the more cynical view. When I told him that many nurses told me they stayed because they loved their country—and who would look after their remaining family if everyone left—he told me he wasn't so sure patriotism played such a big role. "Maybe they don't know how to go overseas?" he said. "Much as everyone talks of professional dedication, everyone is looking for better jobs."
He confirmed my suspicion that one way many nurses make the contacts needed to emigrate is by first working for an international NGO. "If you work for an NGO, then you have access to the internet," Grant said. "You also have more access to information in general. You make contact with people in the field."
Then of course there are also friends and classmates who have already made the move abroad.
Grant thought family ties played a stronger role than patriotism in determining whether registered nurses stayed or left. (Nurse midwife technicians—who provide the bulk of Malawi's nursing care—do not have an internationally marketable degree. But it's impressive to see how many upgrade to a bachelor's in registered nursing.)
Maureen Juma, on the other hand, was passionate about the need to serve—and she sounded very sincere to me.
(I've also talked with several nursing students who clearly thought that the patriotic line was a good one and had probably used it for their nursing school interviews. I had to make sure not to smile during some of those interviews—especially when I heard the almost identical phrases coming out of different students' mouths.)
What's particularly interesting to me is to compare the transcript of what Maureen said to the actual recording of her words. Her passion really grabs you through the headphones in a way that the simple transcript doesn't. Comes back to that issue of what each medium does best. Audio is ideal for conveying emotion. Print is an excellent vehicle for giving detailed information—facts, figures and analyses.
One thing Maureen was especially passionate about was how often Europeans and Americans focus on what's missing in Malawi. She says she was particularly struck by this during a recent trip to Norway for advanced training in nursing education. One person very patronizingly started to explain to her what a computer was. "As if we didn't have computers in Malawi," she exclaimed. Another went so far as to ask "if they have cars in your country?"
Her words were coming out so fast by this point in the interview that some of them got a little jumbled up. But the point was clear. A lot of people come to Malawi prepared only to see the worst.
"These people take only bad pictures and they don't know that there's the good side of things," Maureen said. "They think that when you go to Malawi you are going to find people that are dying of hunger, people that are all HIV positive. That's not the news and that's not the situation. Malawi is also a country that has got its own potentials. And it's got things that are good—a lot of them. Apart from having the Lake [Lake Malawi], apart from having the Mountain [Mulanje Massif], we've got people like us who are willing to work in Malawi and stay here for good."
It was a message to the world but also a message to me and to Eileen about what we are doing in Malawi—about making sure we show both the positive and the negative.
I told Maureen I agree that photos and stories from Malawi often emphasize the negative at the expense of the positives that do exist. I've tried on this trip to get a much broader picture—no whitewashing but no unnecessary gloom either. Realize this could be a tough one to pull off. But I'm going to give it my best shot.
Drive to Mulanje

1 August 2008
Eileen and I left Lilongwe at 8 AM with a driver named Godfrey in the vehicle we rented from Sputnik Car Rentals. (Not, I hasten to add, the same Godfrey as the nurse in Embangweni who used to be a driver.)
Almost as soon as we left Lilongwe, you could see the vegetation changing. More water, more fertile. We stopped in Dedza to see the pottery factory there. Nothing earth-shattering but good quality nonetheless and a nice-looking guesthouse. Actually liked the tiles in the women's restroom the best.
Then we worked our way south on the M1. There are people along the highway practically the whole way—bicycles, pedestrians, the occasional ox cart—although the ox carts became fewer and fewer the farther south we went.
Asked Godfrey about the lack of oxen compared to the north and he said that after the arrival of multi-party elections in 1994, there was kind of a free-for-all in which many people thought democracy was the freedom to do or to take whatever you wanted. As a result lots of cattle were stolen in the south and they've never really recovered. That would be a good story to check into further but alas I don't have the time and it really doesn't have much to do with my project on nurses.
Anyway, there were plenty of trucks, minibuses and pickups packed with folks sitting in the bed on the road. Just so much humanity. Plus chickens, goats, cattle and the like.
We stopped in Blantyre to pick up a few snacks for lunch. Still don't quite have the hang of making lunch ahead of time for the trip. Sandwiches or the like. Haven't really found cold cuts or lunch meats. Godfrey stopped at a supermarket in an area crawling with street kids and others who started begging before we were even able to get out of the car. Lost my appetite right then and there.
We drove through Blantyre. Saw the Queen Elizabeth Hospital and the College of Medicine from a distance. Could see new construction at the College. Billboards from various donors announcing their participation in funding this building or that.
At Limbe, we took the slightly longer route in order to go through the tea plantations. Beautiful light green, rolling hills. Godfrey pulled off in one area so we could stroll a bit between the tea bushes and get some photos. Later we saw some of the shacks that the workers lived in. Although they were stucco, it reminded me of sharecropper-cabins I had seen in Mississippi when I was a kid in the 1970s. Long blocks divided into living quarters for different families.
At any rate, we made it to Mulanje about 4:30 PM. A good day's travel. Glad I wasn't driving.
Practical Notes on Photo Releases
1 August, 2008
Web publishers need to pay more attention to getting formal permission to publish someone's likeness on the Internet. It may cut down a bit on spontaneity and it can be a hassle to manage the information but it's the right thing to do.
The Berkman Center for Internet and Society has just put out a legal guide especially geared to citizen journalists or participatory media. Although the guide is clear and well-written, you can tell it was put together by lawyers in academia and not by practicing journalists. No one would be able to follow all those rules and still meet a tight deadline.
That's too bad because there are a number of legal issues that you should be aware of when publishing on the Web or for a traditional media outlet. Still, the Berkman guide is a good starting place and you shouldn't be put off by its comprehensiveness.
One issue that I have focused a lot on in the past seven weeks in Malawi is getting written permission to publish a person's photograph—whether in print, broadcast or electronic format.
The principle is pretty simple to understand. It's one thing to take someone's photo for your own personal use. It's quite another to publish it.
You should have that person's permission to publish their likeness. How you prove that you received such an okay varies a lot from implied consent (the subject didn't try to block what was obviously a camera taking their photo) to spoken agreement to written consent.
There are also different standards based on the level of privacy one might expect in any given context. Then there's the issue of whether you are photographing a public personality or a private citizen.
In public places like the streets of Manhattan, there is not a reasonable expectation of privacy and so permission is implied. That's why you don't have to get even spoken agreement from all the folks featured in a crowd scene at a football game, for example, or at a demonstration.
In places like hospitals, where I have spent a lot of my career, there is an obvious expectation of privacy. And so, ideally, the highest standard—written permission for the publication of photographs—should apply.
But that's not always the practice. One thing I learned while on my Nieman fellowship is how often the implied consent rule is used—such as when a patient is transferred to an ambulance after a car accident. (The video or still camera was obvious and no one tried to stop the shot.)
For my Malawi project, however, I resolved to get written permission for the use of people's likenesses in most cases and only occasionally rely on verbal or even implied consent. I see no reason to use one standard in the U.S. and a different one in Malawi.
Plus, since the consent form includes the use that will be made of the photograph, it provides reassurance to the subjects that their image won't be used to illustrate an entirely different theme. One story I heard from more than one person was about unnamed journalists taking pictures under one guise—such as work in a hospital—and then using them to illustrate a story on HIV, accompanied by a caption that said declared that everyone in the photo was infected with the AIDS virus. Whether that's a true story or not I don't know, but it sounds plausible.
Another benefit of getting written consent is that you get people to write their own names, making sure to get the correct spelling. Plus you can write good caption information for the photos right on the consent form.
In retrospect, I should have realized that a lot of the patients would be illiterate. Ended up using X's and thumbprints in most of those cases. Fortunately, the idea of giving written consent for operations is becoming more widespread in Malawi and so people understood the concept—even in translation.
Anyway, you don't have to go crazy with these consent forms. In my opinion, long consent forms tend to obfuscate rather than to clarify what you're trying to do. Here's the central wording for my form:
"I hereby consent to the use of my photograph, video footage and name to illustrate any articles by Christine Gorman—whether in print or electronic format—concerning the subject of ________________________________________________."
That's followed by spaces for the printed name, signature, the date, address and contact information (telephone or email).
I use a separate consent for children, which requires a guardian's signature.
NB: Check out Andrew Quinn's experience with consent forms in Kenya.
Web publishers need to pay more attention to getting formal permission to publish someone's likeness on the Internet. It may cut down a bit on spontaneity and it can be a hassle to manage the information but it's the right thing to do.
The Berkman Center for Internet and Society has just put out a legal guide especially geared to citizen journalists or participatory media. Although the guide is clear and well-written, you can tell it was put together by lawyers in academia and not by practicing journalists. No one would be able to follow all those rules and still meet a tight deadline.
That's too bad because there are a number of legal issues that you should be aware of when publishing on the Web or for a traditional media outlet. Still, the Berkman guide is a good starting place and you shouldn't be put off by its comprehensiveness.
One issue that I have focused a lot on in the past seven weeks in Malawi is getting written permission to publish a person's photograph—whether in print, broadcast or electronic format.
The principle is pretty simple to understand. It's one thing to take someone's photo for your own personal use. It's quite another to publish it.
You should have that person's permission to publish their likeness. How you prove that you received such an okay varies a lot from implied consent (the subject didn't try to block what was obviously a camera taking their photo) to spoken agreement to written consent.
There are also different standards based on the level of privacy one might expect in any given context. Then there's the issue of whether you are photographing a public personality or a private citizen.
In public places like the streets of Manhattan, there is not a reasonable expectation of privacy and so permission is implied. That's why you don't have to get even spoken agreement from all the folks featured in a crowd scene at a football game, for example, or at a demonstration.
In places like hospitals, where I have spent a lot of my career, there is an obvious expectation of privacy. And so, ideally, the highest standard—written permission for the publication of photographs—should apply.
But that's not always the practice. One thing I learned while on my Nieman fellowship is how often the implied consent rule is used—such as when a patient is transferred to an ambulance after a car accident. (The video or still camera was obvious and no one tried to stop the shot.)
For my Malawi project, however, I resolved to get written permission for the use of people's likenesses in most cases and only occasionally rely on verbal or even implied consent. I see no reason to use one standard in the U.S. and a different one in Malawi.
Plus, since the consent form includes the use that will be made of the photograph, it provides reassurance to the subjects that their image won't be used to illustrate an entirely different theme. One story I heard from more than one person was about unnamed journalists taking pictures under one guise—such as work in a hospital—and then using them to illustrate a story on HIV, accompanied by a caption that said declared that everyone in the photo was infected with the AIDS virus. Whether that's a true story or not I don't know, but it sounds plausible.
Another benefit of getting written consent is that you get people to write their own names, making sure to get the correct spelling. Plus you can write good caption information for the photos right on the consent form.
In retrospect, I should have realized that a lot of the patients would be illiterate. Ended up using X's and thumbprints in most of those cases. Fortunately, the idea of giving written consent for operations is becoming more widespread in Malawi and so people understood the concept—even in translation.
Anyway, you don't have to go crazy with these consent forms. In my opinion, long consent forms tend to obfuscate rather than to clarify what you're trying to do. Here's the central wording for my form:
"I hereby consent to the use of my photograph, video footage and name to illustrate any articles by Christine Gorman—whether in print or electronic format—concerning the subject of ________________________________________________."
That's followed by spaces for the printed name, signature, the date, address and contact information (telephone or email).
I use a separate consent for children, which requires a guardian's signature.
NB: Check out Andrew Quinn's experience with consent forms in Kenya.
Thursday, 31 July 2008
Driving Lessons

Less than half an hour after we saw the “Heavenbound Funeral Parlour” today, we passed by the scene of this matola accident. Apparently a front tire blew and the driver lost control of the minibus. Fortunately no one was killed—which is a miracle when you consider how flimsy the vans are, the speed at which they are usually driven and how tightly packed the people are inside. The injured had already been taken to a hospital when we stopped.
One of the nurses at Kamuzu Central Hospital in Lilongwe told me that they treat groups of injured people from road accidents at least two or three times a day.
Before I left the U.S., I had planned to drive a rental car on the next leg of our venture—south to Mulanje and Neno. But after just a few weeks in Malawi I reconsidered and hired a driver instead for the part of the southern swing on paved roads and accepted a lift from Partners in Health for the section on dirt roads.
It wasn’t so much the driving on the left-hand side of the road that dissuaded me. I had done that in Australia. It’s the fact that there is so much to watch out for—the constant stream of people walking, biking, even running along the side of the main highway. And since there is no shoulder, they usually are right on the road until you come up behind them. And like youngsters everywhere, children have the worst tendency to suddenly decide to dart into traffic.
Add to that the cattle, the goats, the chickens and the occasional stray dog—each with its own predilection for suddenly taking a mind to cross the road in front of you. Well, you get the picture.
At any rate, we’re headed south tomorrow. Probably won’t have much luck connecting to the internet. But will keep filing offline and update the blog when time and access allow.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)