Friday, 23 January 2009

Links: Ebola, Toilets and Corruption, Iodized Salt

Filipino tests positive for Ebola
From Reuters in Manila: "At least one person has tested positive for the Ebola-Reston virus in the Philippines, where the disease has broken out in pigs at two farms north of the capital, the government said on Friday."

Are Working Toilets A Good Anti-Corruption Indicator?
From the BBC's Mark Doyle: Reading official reports about corruption can be so boring. Doyle's lighthearted look at whether working toilets indicate progress against corruption in Sierra Leone.

The Challenge of Iodized Salt
From Alanna Shaikh, who just moved to Uzbekistan Tajikistan: A quick look at why it is so hard to make iodized salt universally available.

Thursday, 22 January 2009

Broken Links at DotGov Sites

Are broken web links at U.S. government sites going to be a feature of all future changes in Administration? I'm having trouble finding some of the links I had saved on a couple of global health issues from official U.S. government sites. Shouldn't we have some web continuity between Bush and Obama Administrations?

I can no longer get at a press release about human rights from Dec. 10, 2008 that was on the whitehouse.gov site. I get redirected to the Obama briefing room, not even a "page has been moved" message. Very Ministry of Truth.

Yesterday, Maryn McKenna found a broken link to whitehouse.gov that used to tell about the President's Malaria Initiative. No refer pages to where the pages are archived (although the Malaria Initiative itself is still available at fightingmalaria.gov).

I thought, okay, that is the White House--a very political place. But then in writing up my post about the Iranian AIDS doctors who were just sentenced to prison terms for trying to foment a velvet revolution via international HIV meetings (you can't make this stuff up, unfortunately), I realized that a link to an official statement from U.S. State department about the Alaei case was broken. The error message read "We're sorry. That page can't be found and may have been moved."

Since the statement was made by the Bush Administration, the contents had been moved to an archive site. Okay, fine, but at least give me the refer. I had to go and search by eyeball (keyword search Alaei brought up nothing) to find the archived statement.

That's when I started to worry. What about all the press releases at the Centers for Disease Control? Are all those links broken, too? Fortunately, as of Jan. 22, 2008, the CDC's RSS feed for press releases about vaccinations, mortality data, etc. is intact.

I used to think saving links to U.S. government web sites was a safe thing to do because, well, it's the government, they have to preserve those web pages--right? It is a matter of public record. And press releases are part of the public record. But what if the government webmasters preserve the pages and destroy the links? Makes keeping track of things mighty difficult.

It's a different kind of way of politicizing the record--every bit as Orwellian as deleting the word "abortion" as a search term from the Popline database last spring. Fortunately, that was fixed.

Is there a technological fix for broken links, too? Can the new Administration put up their stuff without losing the links to the old information? It is the same government of the same country, after all--just different temporary leaders.

Do you have any other examples of broken government links about global health post-Obama transition?

Iranian AIDS Docs Get 3 and 6 Years in Prison

While the rest of the world was focused on the peaceful transition of power in the U.S., Iranian AIDS doctors Kamiar and Arash Alaei learned on January 20 that they had been sentenced to three years and six years, respectively, in prison, according to Physicians for Human Rights.

The Alaei brothers' case is one of several recently in which professionals and religious minorities have been falsely accused of fomenting revolution. Lawyer and Nobel Laureate Shirin Ebadi's Human Rights Defenders Center was raided and shut down by police in December (Los Angeles Times). Her former secretary was arrested earlier this month in a roundup of six B'hai women (B'hai News).

(Update: The LA Times says Sylvia Hartounian, 33, a reproductive medicine specialist, was sentenced along with the Alaei brothers.)

Radio Free Europe has a good summary article that ties all these moves to internal Iranian politics--trying to sow fear among the Iranian electorate ahead of presidential elections in June.

The Washington Post quotes an unnamed Iranian official as saying the brothers' treatment is part of a "full-fledged intelligence war" between the U.S. and Iran. "A soft revolution has been programmed against our country and carried out in some instances, but it was suffocated in the cradle," the Iranian official was quoted as saying.

Further update (1/29/2009): For deep context, listen to Jeb Sharp's excellent podcast on Public Radio International's "The World" about the long-term damage to US-Iranian relations caused by the 1953 coup engineered by the CIA.

Related posts:
Jailed Iranian Docs
Jailed AIDS Docs Tried in Secret
Sentences Expected for Iranian AIDS Docs

Monday, 19 January 2009

Who Hears a Prayer About Gays, Malaria and AIDS?

The decision to censor Gene Robinson's prayer at yesterday's pre-inaugural concert in Washington, D.C. meant HBO's television audience also did not hear his call to do more about "women [who are] raped because they want an education" and the "thousands [who] die daily from malnutrition, malaria and AIDS." Interestingly, the openly-gay bishop also reminded folks of something that many conservatives have been saying lately, too--sometimes more crudely than other times--that Obama is not the Messiah.

AfterElton.com reports that HBO says it was only following the Inaugural Committee's wishes not to air the pre-concert show.

Christianity Today posted a video of Robinson's prayer on Youtube. (Episcopalcafe has text of the prayer.)

My two cents: I believe all prayers are heard by God. Whether or not the rest of us pay attention is another story.

Thursday, 15 January 2009

Proposed: Global Health Blogging Experiment

Reading Jon Shaffer's post on three top debates in global health gave me an idea. What if we organized a bunch of global health bloggers to coordinate their posts around a single topic and then picked a day where we agreed to post them all? It might increase the visibility of some of the deeper issues in global health.

Each blogger would take the part of the debate that had the most resonance to them. Say, for example, the topic were "prevention vs. treatment." Maryn McKenna might write about it in the case of antibiotic resistance. I might write about it in the community health vs hospital context. Alanna Shaikh might write about it based on her experiences in Central Asia. Then we would update our individual posts with links to what the others had to say.

You might think of it as a blog carnival (defined as "a rotating showcase of interesting writing from around the blogosphere within a particular discipline"), although that may be too organized for our first effort. The most exciting part is that we're starting to get enough of a critical mass of global health bloggers that this is even possible. What do you think?

Who Reads the Global Health Report?

Based on your comments, I would have to say you are all intelligent and thoughtful, if still a little bit shy. (To keep things civil, I delete the comments from trolls and hucksters.) Thanks to some basic web analytics software, here is what else I know about the people who visit The Global Health Report.

Just over 1500 unique visitors come to the site in December 2008, a monthly rate that has quadrupled in the past year. (Is that good or bad? You tell me.)

If I'm reading the charts right,

97% used a fast connection
2% used dialup
fewer than 1% accessed the blog from a mobile phone.

In the past year, visitors have come from 140 countries, with the following breakdown for the top five:

United States 71%
United Kingdom 6%
Canada 4%
South Africa 2%

If you have simple ideas on how to increase the international readership of the blog, please let me know.

11% of visitors accessed the site using computers on university or college networks, with the top five being:

Harvard University
Northwestern University
George Washington University
Bowdoin College
University of Washington

1% of visitors accessed the site using computers at U.S. government agencies, with the top five being:

The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
The U.S. Department of State
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
The U.S. Agency for International Development
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

Employees who use computer networks at the following press organizations (top 5):

BBC
Seattle Times
New York Times
Time Inc.
National Public Radio

Plus, a smattering of non-U.S. national and international agencies, several public relations agencies, some foundations and lots and lots of folks who I assume must be logging in from home on RoadRunner, Comcast, BellSouth, etc.

Related post:
Top 5 Blog Posts for 2008

Tuesday, 13 January 2009

Opposition to Gupta as Surgeon General

Opposition to the possible nomination of Sanjay Gupta as Surgeon General is building.

"CNN journalist lacks independent voice to be surgeon general," says Peter Canellos today in the Boston Globe. Representative John Conyers of Michigan is pushing a different candidate, Dr. Herb Smitherman, a public health advocate from Detroit.

I still find it hard to believe Gupta will take the position. He will have a much smaller staff and much tinier budget than he is used to at CNN. Sanjay looks good on television because he is talented but he also has some very capable producers helping him.

If the Surgeon General were just a health educator, then Gupta, who I like very much (for one thing, he never gave me grief when I edited his columns at TIME), would be a surprising but logical step. But there are also policy issues. The SG is supposed to lead the 6,000-person U.S. Public Health Service Commissioned Corps. (Per comments on one of my earlier posts, morale there seems very low.) There is also talk Gupta will play a role in the Office of Health Reform (Washington Post), perhaps as salesman for whatever national health care reform the Obama Administration offers?

I would also like to know a lot more about Gupta's relationship to the pharmaceutical industry. This is a question I would ask of any doctor or health journalist who is being considered for government office--and Gupta is both.

We all know that advertising and corporate sponsorship make mainstream media possible. That is why you need to look at the firewalls between the sponsors/advertisers and editorial side in any specialized field, but especially in health, to make sure they are solid.

This is especially true when there is a single sponsor for a television program or print column. Anyone who cared to flip through the pages of TIME Magazine from a few years ago would see that Gupta's column always ran next to ads from Pfizer. The New Republic has written about the pharmaceutical industry's sponsorship of CNN's AccentHealth.

In addition, the practice of accepting speaking fees from pharmaceutical companies is very controversial, to say the least, among health journalists. I have written about why I do not do it. Just last November, we learned that psychiatrist Fred Goodwin, host of NPR's Infinite Mind, received more than a million dollars in consulting fees from drug companies (New York Times). That little conflict of interest left a huge black eye on NPR.

So, I would also like to know a lot more about the speaking fees that Gupta has received over the years from pharmaceutical companies.

This is more than I had planned to write about Sanjay Gupta as Surgeon General. But this is something new for health journalism--a health journalist being tapped for a high government position.

The revolving door between government and politics is a lot more common for my colleagues in political journalism--where the potential conflicts there have been looked at in greater depth.

If Gupta and the Obama Administration are serious about the Surgeon General's position, then we need to examine this possible nomination more closely.

Related posts:
AIDS Docs, Gupta, Measles

Questions About Gupta for Surgeon General

Update: See also Gary Schwitzer's extensive critique of Gupta's journalism. Schwitzer used to be head of the medical news unit at CNN.