Sunday, 10 August 2008

Arrival in Neno



Have arrived safely at the PIH facility in Neno after about 45 minutes on a tarmac road and about an hour on a dirt road. I'm becoming quite the connoisseur of dirt roads. This one is more rocky as we climb the side of several hills whereas most of the others we have been on are more sandy.

The caps lock key on my laptop seems to have inverted itself somehow on the ride. So when the green light is depressed, I get normal upper and lower case but when it's out, THE LETTERS ARE ALL UPPER CASE. (Seems to have something to do with the "num lock" key. ) But other than that, we and our equipment seem to have survived the journey.

The other big news is that there is wifi in the guest house--the fastest connection we've yet had in Malawi--so I'll be able to post items throughout the week. Alas, no Celtel mobile service but Malawi Telekom is supposed to work.

Heading to Neno

The driver from Partners in Health is going to pick us up at noon. Once again, I think we will be beyond the reach of the Internet for a while and possibly even of text messaging. But by the end of the week, we should be back in Lilongwe and have internet access.

Linking the Local and the International Perspective


8 August

Arrived in Blantyre this morning. Spent this afternoon talking with Tulipoka Soko, the chief nursing officer at Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, and some of her colleagues.

I had tried to make arrangements from the U.S. to talk with nursing staff at QECH but hadn’t gotten anywhere. But when I showed up on Tuesday to set up the interview for today, Mrs. Soko was quite open and willing to talk. Some things you just can’t plan ahead.

This brings up another point. I have tried not to rely too much on expatriates in doing my reporting in Malawi. It’s not that I have anything against expatriates and indeed you have to talk to some international folks to get a good picture. But you can’t leave out the people who are working locally, in government, in hospitals, in local civic organizations. And even within Malawi, you certainly don’t want to talk only to people at the highest levels.

This is often harder than you might think. For one thing, expatriates often come at things from familiar perspectives, so it’s usually easier to get a good grasp on what they are saying. And expatriates are often easier to contact from the U.S. So there’s a built-in bias towards folks who have more access to international communications.

But by being here in Malawi, and spending nearly three months here, I have been able to meet lots of people—like Mrs. Soko—who are quite open about their experience, the joys and challenges of where they work.

That doesn’t mean you have a magic crystal ball and everything suddenly becomes clear. (Would love to spend more time at QECH to delve deeper into the daily experience of patients and ward nurses, for example.) But it certainly gives a better picture than if you limit yourself entirely to those with an international perspective and status.

Charcoal and Deforestation


Although my primary focus in Malawi is nurses and the health system, I can’t help but notice other issues—like deforestation. Many of the hills that I have seen in southern Malawi have been stripped bare of trees to feed the need for charcoal.

Even the forest preserves around Mulanje Massif are starting to show the effects. A new road from Blantyre to Mulanje has opened up—which cut the trip to less than an hour by car. But that has also meant charcoal sellers can easily bike their way up to Blantyre from Mulanje. The photo above is of a charcoal seller who has wrapped his wares in plastic so as not to get in trouble with the forest rangers.

The economics of the issue are compelling. Charcoal is less expensive for cooking than electricity. Charcoal in the rural areas may cost 300 to 400 MK for one of these huge bags but 800 MK in town and that could last you a month. So what happens when all the trees are gone? When you’re trying to make it to the end of the day alive, tomorrow is a luxury.

Saturday, 9 August 2008

Filling out the Picture

7 August 2008

When I first came to Malawi, one of the questions that was uppermost in my mind was why nurses leave the country to work in the U.K. or other English-speaking countries or why so many leave the public sector to work for non-government organizations or private hospitals and clinics. But in truth, that's pretty easy to understand. Much of it boils down to better pay, better working conditions (fewer hours, fewer patients, more resources), better housing and more opportunities for their children.

What has been a lot harder to get at is why nurses stay in Malawi, particularly why they stay in the public sector. Catherine Ndolo in Embangweni taught me to look at relationships, at how much the workplace demonstrates that it cares about both its patients and its staff. Others have talked about the opportunity to advance—that they stay with government positions because, after a few years, the Ministry of Health will pay to upgrade their education.

Then in just the past two days I spoke with two nurses—Grant Ngugluwe and Maureen Juma—who had almost diametrically opposed views. Both of them work in Mulanje. Maureen is a nurse tutor at the Mulanje Mission College of Nursing. Grant works in the male ward at the Mulanje Mission Hospital. I talked with each of them separately so it's a little unfair to compare their responses. But they stated their positions so eloquently like that I couldn't help but play one against the other.

Both of them are from the younger generation of Malawians, who have graduated from nursing school in just the past five years. Neither has the sense of caution that I witnessed so often in older nurses—many of whom learned from bitter experience during the Banda era not to rock any boats.

Grant took the more cynical view. When I told him that many nurses told me they stayed because they loved their country—and who would look after their remaining family if everyone left—he told me he wasn't so sure patriotism played such a big role. "Maybe they don't know how to go overseas?" he said. "Much as everyone talks of professional dedication, everyone is looking for better jobs."

He confirmed my suspicion that one way many nurses make the contacts needed to emigrate is by first working for an international NGO. "If you work for an NGO, then you have access to the internet," Grant said. "You also have more access to information in general. You make contact with people in the field."

Then of course there are also friends and classmates who have already made the move abroad.

Grant thought family ties played a stronger role than patriotism in determining whether registered nurses stayed or left. (Nurse midwife technicians—who provide the bulk of Malawi's nursing care—do not have an internationally marketable degree. But it's impressive to see how many upgrade to a bachelor's in registered nursing.)

Maureen Juma, on the other hand, was passionate about the need to serve—and she sounded very sincere to me.

(I've also talked with several nursing students who clearly thought that the patriotic line was a good one and had probably used it for their nursing school interviews. I had to make sure not to smile during some of those interviews—especially when I heard the almost identical phrases coming out of different students' mouths.)

What's particularly interesting to me is to compare the transcript of what Maureen said to the actual recording of her words. Her passion really grabs you through the headphones in a way that the simple transcript doesn't. Comes back to that issue of what each medium does best. Audio is ideal for conveying emotion. Print is an excellent vehicle for giving detailed information—facts, figures and analyses.

One thing Maureen was especially passionate about was how often Europeans and Americans focus on what's missing in Malawi. She says she was particularly struck by this during a recent trip to Norway for advanced training in nursing education. One person very patronizingly started to explain to her what a computer was. "As if we didn't have computers in Malawi," she exclaimed. Another went so far as to ask "if they have cars in your country?"

Her words were coming out so fast by this point in the interview that some of them got a little jumbled up. But the point was clear. A lot of people come to Malawi prepared only to see the worst.

"These people take only bad pictures and they don't know that there's the good side of things," Maureen said. "They think that when you go to Malawi you are going to find people that are dying of hunger, people that are all HIV positive. That's not the news and that's not the situation. Malawi is also a country that has got its own potentials. And it's got things that are good—a lot of them. Apart from having the Lake [Lake Malawi], apart from having the Mountain [Mulanje Massif], we've got people like us who are willing to work in Malawi and stay here for good."

It was a message to the world but also a message to me and to Eileen about what we are doing in Malawi—about making sure we show both the positive and the negative.

I told Maureen I agree that photos and stories from Malawi often emphasize the negative at the expense of the positives that do exist. I've tried on this trip to get a much broader picture—no whitewashing but no unnecessary gloom either. Realize this could be a tough one to pull off. But I'm going to give it my best shot.


Drive to Mulanje



1 August 2008

Eileen and I left Lilongwe at 8 AM with a driver named Godfrey in the vehicle we rented from Sputnik Car Rentals. (Not, I hasten to add, the same Godfrey as the nurse in Embangweni who used to be a driver.)

Almost as soon as we left Lilongwe, you could see the vegetation changing. More water, more fertile. We stopped in Dedza to see the pottery factory there. Nothing earth-shattering but good quality nonetheless and a nice-looking guesthouse. Actually liked the tiles in the women's restroom the best.

Then we worked our way south on the M1. There are people along the highway practically the whole way—bicycles, pedestrians, the occasional ox cart—although the ox carts became fewer and fewer the farther south we went.

Asked Godfrey about the lack of oxen compared to the north and he said that after the arrival of multi-party elections in 1994, there was kind of a free-for-all in which many people thought democracy was the freedom to do or to take whatever you wanted. As a result lots of cattle were stolen in the south and they've never really recovered. That would be a good story to check into further but alas I don't have the time and it really doesn't have much to do with my project on nurses.

Anyway, there were plenty of trucks, minibuses and pickups packed with folks sitting in the bed on the road. Just so much humanity. Plus chickens, goats, cattle and the like.
We stopped in Blantyre to pick up a few snacks for lunch. Still don't quite have the hang of making lunch ahead of time for the trip. Sandwiches or the like. Haven't really found cold cuts or lunch meats. Godfrey stopped at a supermarket in an area crawling with street kids and others who started begging before we were even able to get out of the car. Lost my appetite right then and there.

We drove through Blantyre. Saw the Queen Elizabeth Hospital and the College of Medicine from a distance. Could see new construction at the College. Billboards from various donors announcing their participation in funding this building or that.

At Limbe, we took the slightly longer route in order to go through the tea plantations. Beautiful light green, rolling hills. Godfrey pulled off in one area so we could stroll a bit between the tea bushes and get some photos. Later we saw some of the shacks that the workers lived in. Although they were stucco, it reminded me of sharecropper-cabins I had seen in Mississippi when I was a kid in the 1970s. Long blocks divided into living quarters for different families.

At any rate, we made it to Mulanje about 4:30 PM. A good day's travel. Glad I wasn't driving.

Practical Notes on Photo Releases

1 August, 2008

Web publishers need to pay more attention to getting formal permission to publish someone's likeness on the Internet. It may cut down a bit on spontaneity and it can be a hassle to manage the information but it's the right thing to do.

The Berkman Center for Internet and Society has just put out a legal guide especially geared to citizen journalists or participatory media. Although the guide is clear and well-written, you can tell it was put together by lawyers in academia and not by practicing journalists. No one would be able to follow all those rules and still meet a tight deadline.

That's too bad because there are a number of legal issues that you should be aware of when publishing on the Web or for a traditional media outlet. Still, the Berkman guide is a good starting place and you shouldn't be put off by its comprehensiveness.

One issue that I have focused a lot on in the past seven weeks in Malawi is getting written permission to publish a person's photograph—whether in print, broadcast or electronic format.

The principle is pretty simple to understand. It's one thing to take someone's photo for your own personal use. It's quite another to publish it.

You should have that person's permission to publish their likeness. How you prove that you received such an okay varies a lot from implied consent (the subject didn't try to block what was obviously a camera taking their photo) to spoken agreement to written consent.

There are also different standards based on the level of privacy one might expect in any given context. Then there's the issue of whether you are photographing a public personality or a private citizen.

In public places like the streets of Manhattan, there is not a reasonable expectation of privacy and so permission is implied. That's why you don't have to get even spoken agreement from all the folks featured in a crowd scene at a football game, for example, or at a demonstration.

In places like hospitals, where I have spent a lot of my career, there is an obvious expectation of privacy. And so, ideally, the highest standard—written permission for the publication of photographs—should apply.

But that's not always the practice. One thing I learned while on my Nieman fellowship is how often the implied consent rule is used—such as when a patient is transferred to an ambulance after a car accident. (The video or still camera was obvious and no one tried to stop the shot.)

For my Malawi project, however, I resolved to get written permission for the use of people's likenesses in most cases and only occasionally rely on verbal or even implied consent. I see no reason to use one standard in the U.S. and a different one in Malawi.

Plus, since the consent form includes the use that will be made of the photograph, it provides reassurance to the subjects that their image won't be used to illustrate an entirely different theme. One story I heard from more than one person was about unnamed journalists taking pictures under one guise—such as work in a hospital—and then using them to illustrate a story on HIV, accompanied by a caption that said declared that everyone in the photo was infected with the AIDS virus. Whether that's a true story or not I don't know, but it sounds plausible.

Another benefit of getting written consent is that you get people to write their own names, making sure to get the correct spelling. Plus you can write good caption information for the photos right on the consent form.

In retrospect, I should have realized that a lot of the patients would be illiterate. Ended up using X's and thumbprints in most of those cases. Fortunately, the idea of giving written consent for operations is becoming more widespread in Malawi and so people understood the concept—even in translation.

Anyway, you don't have to go crazy with these consent forms. In my opinion, long consent forms tend to obfuscate rather than to clarify what you're trying to do. Here's the central wording for my form:

"I hereby consent to the use of my photograph, video footage and name to illustrate any articles by Christine Gorman—whether in print or electronic format—concerning the subject of ________________________________________________."

That's followed by spaces for the printed name, signature, the date, address and contact information (telephone or email).

I use a separate consent for children, which requires a guardian's signature.

NB: Check out Andrew Quinn's experience with consent forms in Kenya.