Monday, 26 November 2007

Stephen Lewis: UN "Sloppy" on AIDS Numbers

Stephen Lewis says the United Nations, where he used to work, "was stubborn and it was sloppy" in its compilation of global AIDS statistics. The result was last week's embarrassing need to restate the number of people living with HIV from 40 million to 33 million.

The tone is so blistering that one wonders if Peter Piot, head of UNAIDS, will take it as a personal attack from Lewis, the former UN Special Envoy for HIV/AIDS in Africa?

I'll have more to say in future posts, but wanted to post what Lewis, who is now co-director of something called AIDS-Free World, said as soon as possible. The speech itself has been making the e-mail rounds, but I have also received it from Lewis's executive assistant.

Here's what Lewis told the World Health Editors Network last Friday (Nov. 23) at the Imperial College in London:


"It’s fair to say that any speech designed to address leadership and AIDS must start with the events of this week: the publication of the UNAIDS Epidemic Update, 2007.

Let me get two matters out of the way at the outset. I think the new set of numbers is much closer to the truth of the pandemic, although I’m inclined to believe that they’re still too high and that another awkward revision lies ahead. Second, I don’t believe for a moment that UNAIDS inflated the figures for the purpose of extracting money. That seems to me too conspiratorial by half. If by some bizarre happenstance, Machiavelli’s apprentices were involved, they make lousy fund-raisers: we’re billions of dollars short of where we should be, old estimates or new.

I take issue with the report on different grounds. For years, knowledgeable epidemiologists have been telling the UN that the figures were too high. They didn’t whisper their criticisms: they wrote books and articles. They lobbied behind the scenes. No one paid them heed. It doesn’t take a Nobel prize statistician to guess that prevalence rates based on urban antenatal clinics should not be extrapolated to the entire country and presented as holy writ. That became compellingly clear when the spate of population-based household surveys, country after country, invariably showed lower prevalence.

But the UN chose a course of delay and dithering. It can never admit that it’s wrong. So finally, and predictably, came the moment of truth: the result is an overall prevalence rate that is lower by almost seven million than last year’s estimate.

Sure, it can be rationalized by arguing that it’s just a methodological adjustment, rooted in superior statistical-gathering techniques. And that might even be persuasive if there hadn’t been academicians and epidemiologists clamouring for revision for years. The UNAIDS explanation sounds good; the fine print has the ring of arcane scientific authority. But down here, in the mortal universe, where people aren’t easily taken in, it doesn’t wash.

The UN was stubborn and it was sloppy. In the process, it undermined public confidence in the reliability of the figures, introducing completely unnecessary levels of doubt, contention and confusion.
Where HIV/AIDS is concerned, there is no room for the jolting of confidence. The new estimates confirm a continuing apocalypse for sub-Saharan Africa: 22.5 million infections, 61% of them women, 68% of world-wide infections, 76% of all deaths, 11.4 million orphans … this is where the focus must be, this is where it should always have been; not a report cluttered by mathematical adjustments so that virtually every story that’s written begins with the news of a statistical volte-face. If the recording of data had been more scrupulous all along, we could have welcomed this report as the latest instalment in a record of declining numbers, showing some strong hints of progress, and plausibly leading to universal access for treatment, prevention and care by 2010.

Instead, all of us have to run to the trenches to remind the world that more money is still desperately needed and that the situation, in many places, remains grim, bleak, funereal.

As a matter of fact, at the risk of knocking the nail through the wall, allow me to add that I earlier used the word ‘sloppy’ advisedly. For a number of years in the 1990’s, I was the Deputy at UNICEF and oversaw a raft of publications. I would never have permitted this Update to go out as is.

Let me explain by way of example.

In one of the dense explanatory notes, there’s a statistical adjustment described that attracted little notice, but seems to me to be of enormous import. If I may attempt a straightforward simplification, the report seems to be saying that, on average, the population-based random household surveys in countries with generalized HIV epidemics produced estimates that were 20% lower than the estimates produced by antenatal surveys. Therefore, says the report, for all those countries with generalized epidemics that have not yet done random surveys, we’re applying a reduction factor of .8 … that is to say, the new figures will be 80 % of the old figures.

That’s quite a reduction! Don’t you think it might have been useful to produce a table (there were, after all, tables galore) to show what it might mean, in practice, country by affected country? No such luck.

Instead, the report notes that “Of the total difference in the estimates published in 2006 and 2007, 70% are due to changes in six countries: Angola, India, Kenya, Mozambique, Nigeria and Zimbabwe.” I was stumped by Angola because its prevalence rate is so low, it’s hard to imagine that it could make a great difference to the numbers. India everyone knows about. Kenya and Zimbabwe have oft been talked about (although the alleged decline in Zimbabwe seems to me to be complicated by the numbers of deaths, the out-migration, and the difficulty of reliable surveys in a sociological wasteland). Nigeria was clearly possible. But Mozambique was a mystery because I remembered from my last visit that the most recent data had shown an increase in prevalence.

This is no small matter. This is a report that is telling the world that the dramatic revision in the figures, and the figures themselves, are now the best that science has to offer.
Naturally, therefore, I looked at all the entries in the report dealing with Mozambique. On page 12, there is a section on “Recent HIV and sexual behaviour trends among young people” that chronicles reductions in HIV prevalence in various countries from Kenya to Malawi to Zimbabwe to rural Botswana. However the paragraph ends with these words: “There was no evidence of a decrease in HIV infection levels among young people in Mozambique …” (emphasis mine).

On page 13, there’s an elaborate table titled, in part, “2006/2007 analysis of trends among 15 to 24-year-olds in high prevalence countries: HIV prevalence among pregnant women, 2000-2006 in sentinel surveillance systems …” Mozambique is in the table. Below the list of countries, there’s an asterisk which reads: “Analyses of countries with more than three years of data based in the following number of consistent urban and rural sites …” For Mozambique there are 20 sites listed, South, North and Central. Beside Mozambique is another legend symbol which reads: “No evidence of decrease” (emphasis mine).

On page 15 we encounter the critical “Regional Overview”, leading with the section on “Southern Africa”. It indicates that this sub-region includes the eight countries with prevalence rates over 15%: Botswana, Lesotho, Mozambique, Namibia, South Africa, Swaziland, Zambia and Zimbabwe. The narrative then points out, with some gratification, that in Zimbabwe there is an actual decline in national HIV prevalence, and that “the epidemics in most of the rest of the sub-region have either reached or are approaching a plateau” The next sentence reads: “Only in Mozambique latest HIV data (in 2005) have shown an increase in prevalence over the previous surveillance period.” (emphasis mine).

Finally, on page 17, Mozambique is dealt with separately, as are all the countries of the sub-region. The opening paragraph reads “In the other lusophone country of this sub-region, Mozambique, the epidemic has again started to increase in all three zones after appearing to have stabilized in the early 2000s.” (emphasis mine … the three zones are south, central and north, and the other lusophone country is of course Angola.)

If I was in the Ministry of Health in Mozambique, I would want to know why all of the narrative evidence of the report seems to contradict the assertion that Mozambique is one of the six countries in the world that has most significantly contributed to the reduced numbers, 2007 over 2006. And if the explanation is --- as it must be --- the application of the new 80% rule applied to countries, ie Mozambique, that haven’t yet done population-based surveys, then those figures should be set out conclusively. Otherwise this report does what so many other reports have done: it slides casually over critical information. It confuses where it ought to be clarifying. It’s blurred where it should be coherent.

For me, the Epidemic Update, 2007, is simply a symbol, a symbol of insufficient leadership, within the United Nations, against the pandemic of AIDS. The time has come --- we’re just a week away from another World AIDS Day --- for the new Secretary-General to throw the full weight of his office behind a campaign to subdue the pandemic, with a particular consuming focus on Africa.
The agenda lies in the UNAIDS report.
For example, one of the most startling statistics is the revelation that women now constitute 61% of the infections in Africa … close to 14 million women infected. There are no words. It’s a catastrophe rooted in gender inequality, and everyone in the highest citadels of the United Nations knows it, but virtually nothing changes.

We have a report from a High-Level Panel on UN Reform, pointing out the lamentable UN record on women, and recommending the creation of a new international agency for women. The proposal lies dormant on the order paper of the General Assembly, crying out for leadership from the Secretary General. The Deputy Secretary General has spoken, strongly and bravely although, given the inevitable and nasty internal rivalries, her words are too often given to rhetorical sleight-of-tongue.

Where is the UN Secretary General when the AIDS pandemic rages, and the women of Africa need him most? No one pretends that the women’s agency is the sole answer, but you can bet that things would not be so excruciatingly horrendous if women had an international vehicle to draw upon, with resources and voice.

So, too, women in conflict zones. My colleagues and I carefully watched the Security Council debate on Resolution 1325 just a couple of weeks ago, and have read carefully the proceedings of the Security Council debate this week on the protection of civilians in armed conflict. The speeches are getting better: more feeling, more informed, more urgent (that is particularly true of the Undersecretary General for Humanitarian Affairs; on the other hand, the Secretary General’s speech last Tuesday on the protection of civilians in armed conflict was so pro forma as to make one weep. He managed to mention Sudan, Somalia, Afghanistan, Iraq and a passing aside to Darfur. Not a syllable on the Democratic Republic of the Congo). When you have a savage war on women, as in the DRC, with huge implications for transmission of the AIDS virus, speeches are the road to hell. When will the United Nations actually take hold? There are suggestions cited of the Secretary General leading a new campaign to eliminate violence against women. I recently saw an early draft of this potential Secretary General initiative, and I can categorically say that in more than twenty years of association with multilateralism, I’ve rarely seen anything more vapid, fatuous and insubstantial. It was as if the illusion of progress, dressed up in the Byzantine underworld of United Nations processes was sufficient unto itself. Public relations for inconsolable grief.

The Epidemic Update report acknowledges that only in a few instances has behaviour change played a serious role in the reduction of the numbers. In fact it says that the differences in estimates “result largely from refinements in methodology rather than in trends in the pandemic itself.” There is no question that a small proportion of the decline stems from changes in behaviour, but there is equally no doubt that the vast majority of the difference lies in the methodological adjustment.

Now, then, is the perfect time to rally the UN community to the side of prevention, with much greater focus on high-risk groups; on the increasingly persuasive thesis of concurrent partners; on the roll-out of male circumcision (which should have been pursued vigorously much more quickly, but like so much else in the response to the pandemic got caught up in the overweaning proclivity for excessive scientific inquiry when the case is already clear, not to mention the faint hearts in the face of potential controversy); on harm reduction around which there has been inexcusable ambivalence; on the Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission, possibly the easiest preventive intervention of all, and therefore the most grievous emblem of multilateral negligence; on the absolute, resolute need to pursue, with unflinching tenacity the continued quest for a microbicide and a vaccine, regardless the setbacks. This is the time for a crescendo of United Nations voices.

The Epidemic Update is also shocking in the information that 76% of the overall deaths lie in Africa: one million, six hundred thousand adults and children. It tells you everything you didn’t want to know about the painfully slow rollout of treatment, and how vital it is that keeping people alive not get lost in some senseless, artificial tension between treatment and prevention. Nor should we ever forget where so many of the deaths come from, and how silent were the voices of the United Nations leadership while President Mbeki pursued his fatal denialism. South Africa has far and away the highest number of HIV infections in the world: five and a half million. There are eight hundred to a thousand deaths a day. No one has ever been held to account. Talk about impunity.

And as always, there’s the question of resources. It’s hard to know how the donors will react to the new numbers published by UNAIDS. They may simply yawn, and give whatever they intended. They may feel bamboozled, and want to cut back. They may see possibilities in the reduced numbers, possibilities of greater progress because fewer people are involved. Whatever the reaction, we must somehow persuade the world that we’re way behind, billions and billions of dollars behind, when it comes to funding all the components of the pandemic, from orphans to second-line drugs.

All of these elements, so many of them flowing generically from the Epidemic Update, are the stuff of the United Nations. UNAIDS, the Joint UN Programme on HIV/AIDS, oversees or coordinates ten co-sponsors: UNHCR, UNDP, UNICEF, WFP, UNFPA, UNODC, ILO, UNESCO, WHO and the World Bank. That’s a compendium of multilateral aristocracy and power rivaled in influence only by the G8 and the International Financial Institutions. And yet, members of the UN family, in the face of the AIDS pandemic, have sometimes acted with a kind of catatonic passivity. There is no excuse for it.

More than twenty-five years into the pandemic, we have an epidemic update that is --- let’s face it --- horrifying in its implications. Whether it’s 40 million or 33 million, this plague continues to ravage humankind. I simply do not believe that the United Nations has done everything it can possibly do to turn the tide. And I don’t mean just the member states, I mean the agencies and the secretariat.

I’m a multilateralist to the core of my being. But that doesn’t mean that the UN is above criticism. And it most emphatically doesn’t mean acting as an apologist for those who are chosen to lead and who have failed to lead."

Friday, 16 November 2007

An Open Standard for Global Health?

Global health advocates need to pay more attention to issues of net neutrality, open-source standards and the growing movement to create a global commons.

Over the past several months at Harvard, I’ve started to delve much deeper into some fundamental questions about who owns the Internet and the information we are accumulating in the various computers sprinkled about the globe. Thanks to the ongoing exploration of these issues at the Berkman Center for Internet and Society, I now realize these issues have major implications for how we address some of the world’s pressing health and development needs as well.

Once upon a time, whenever pundits worried about a “digital divide” between rich and poor or the developed and developing worlds, they focused on the physical tools—like computers and broadband connections—for accessing the Internet. If we aren’t careful, however, an even greater divide may be written into the very backbone that makes the Internet possible, allowing powerful companies and countries a greater voice because they can pay for faster access to their websites while the rest of us languish in slow download hell. The many injustices of the real world would then be faithfully recreated in the virtual world as well.

The global health community has long argued that everyone should enjoy equal access to basic health care—regardless of income or social standing. But does that noble goal extend to access to information—in all its many forms as news, data or research results? When first-world consultants help a developing country create an electronic medical records system, for example, do they advise their clients to use a proprietary software program or an open source one? Is it possible to access international and national health and development databases, use the information gained and distribute the results without incurring monetary fees? (These are just two examples. The more you dig, the more you find.)

Why does this matter? Open source software is, of course, no panacea. But the tech support is worldwide, sustainable and typically comes at the right price. Too often, on the other hand, proprietary software leads to digital servitude and a stranglehold on innovation.

As for databases, I’ve learned quite a lot about them from reading Yochai Benkler’s The Wealth of Networks. (I found it easier to read the book but there’s also a complete version of Benkler’s tome on the web.) Apparently, since 1991 the U.S. government has not considered databases to be copyrightable. Access to them is free—although you may want to pay a subscription service to provide the information in a more user-friendly format.

By contrast, Benkler writes, the European Union passed a Database Directive in 1996, “which created a discrete and expansive right in raw data compilation.” As a result, “government agencies are required to charge what the market will bear for access to data they collect.” So where is the database industry thriving and growing faster? In the U.S., where databases are not encumbered by copyright restrictions.

Hmmm. An open standard leads to greater innovation and growth in business. Sounds like something the global health community ought to take to heart.

Sunday, 28 October 2007

Tuesday, 23 October 2007

What do Patents and Peanut Butter Have to do With Starving Kids?

There's been plenty of good press about Plumpy'nut, the "miracle" food that has saved countless starving children over the past few years. But not much has been written about the patent that sustains the small French company behind this humanitarian wonder.

Is Plumpy' nut another laudable example of doing well by doing good? Or will protecting the patent lead to yet another bottleneck in yet another under-served area of global health?

My interest in this topic started innocently enough with an offhand remark directed at me at a nutrition conference I attended two weeks ago.

The gist of the remark was that Nutriset, the maker of Plumpy'nut, was protecting its investment by warning other commercial enterprises, as well as humanitarian groups, not to produce their own versions of the therapeutic food. (The recipe is dead simple: so many peanuts, so much dried milk, a little oil and some vitamins and minerals. The innovation comes from realizing, among other things, that the right mix doesn't require dilution with water, which is often a problem in the developing world.)

A little search engine digging, a few e-mails and in-person conversations later, and it feels to this longtime health journalist that there is some meat in this story.

So, now I'm collecting information, original sources, suggestions for people to talk to, etc, at tightly focused web site called, straightforwardedly enough, Patents and Peanut Butter.

I'd like it to be a group effort--sort of an experiment in collaborative reporting. (I've been reading Yochai Benkler's The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom.) But am prepared to do a lot of the heavy lifting myself until things get going.

By creating a separate blog, I hope to counter some of the chaotic, hit-or-miss nature of the Web. But who knows, that may turn out to be an entirely unnecessary step. The great thing about being at Harvard for a year, is that I can try new things out while the Nieman Foundation foots the bills.

Wednesday, 17 October 2007

Can Malaria Be Eradicated?

Update: Larry Hollon, of the Methodist church and Perspectives, attended the Malaria Summit in Seattle and has a firsthand account on his blog.

I did a double take when I read that Bill and Melinda Gates have just challenged the world to eradicate malaria from the globe. I went back and looked at several news sources. Yes, they all agreed the word "eradicate," not "control" was used. Now that's a tall order, even for a pair of billionaire philanthropists. (Full disclosure, I'm at Harvard on a Nieman Fellowship in Global Health Reporting, which is funded by the Gates Foundation.)

Back in the 1960s, health experts were convinced that widespread use of DDT against mosquitoes plus treatment with chloroquine would eradicate malaria from the world. By the 1970s, however, the environmental damage caused by massive agricultural use of the pesticide caused a sharp reduction in all DDT spraying--including inside homes against mosquitoes. Malaria has been rebounding every since.

And yet, health experts I've talked to over the years have told me that even had indoor spraying continued through the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, malaria, at best, would have been controlled, not eradicated or eliminated from the face of the earth.

What's changed since the 1970s? A promising new vaccine that appears to be partially effective in children. Insecticide-treated bed nets. New combination drug treatments for malaria. Better education campaigns. The return, in some areas, of indoor spraying with DDT and other pesticides. The realization that there is no such thing as a silver bullet in fighting malaria. You need all of the above to control this disease.

But eradicate?
"Bill and I believe that these advances in science and medicine, your promising research, and the rising concern of people around the world represent an historic opportunity not just to treat malaria or to control it -- but to chart a long-term course to eradicate it," Melinda Gates told a gathering of international scientists and policymakers in Seattle, Washington (quote as reported in Agence France-Presse).

An eradication policy is very different--and much more costly--than a control policy. Just ask anyone who is trying to eliminate polio.

Tuesday, 25 September 2007

A Business Model for Global Health

What can business teach public health experts--and everyone else--about how to improve people's health around the world? One idea that's gaining ground around Harvard (and elsewhere) is the use of case studies--and not just the gold standard of scientifically controlled clinical trials--to figure out what works and what doesn't.

Some days I wonder if I'm at the School of Public Health or the Business School. Jim Kim--champion of the 3 x 5 initiative to get more poor people on anti-AIDS therapies--is working with Mike Porter--corporate strategy guru--on developing case studies of what does and doesn't work in global health. They'll both be teaching classes that tap into this approach in January.

Peter Piot, head of UNAIDS, brought up the case-study method in a keynote speech yesterday at, of all places, a symposium on "Meeting Children's Needs in a World with HIV/AIDS." You still need controlled trials, Piot was quick to point out when several journalists spoke with him after his speech. But there may be some ways to use case studies--to learn from past experience--to figure out how best to deliver on the promise found in controlled research studies.

Case studies, for those of us who don't have MBAs, are well-researched 3 or 4 page summaries that lay out a particular real-world problem that a real-world organization faced at some point and then ask the group to put themselves in the place of the chief executive officers or others and propose strategies for going forward.

Of course, case studies aren't going to tell you if a particular antibiotic works or not. That's the realm of a scientifically controlled clinical trial. But a case study may give insight into how to introduce a new antibiotic into the developing world, or decide between a couple of different choices of antibiotics as to which works best in the poorest parts of the world, what kind of health-care infrastructure is needed, what might happen when the antibiotic gets out into the gray market, and whether, on balance, these factors sway you towards one course of action or another.

But the use of case studies is just a piece of this business approach to global health. A more critical look at the costs and benefits of borrowing the business world's tools--which often includes a decidedly anti-government bias (very convenient for academic researchers and NGOs who are not in government)--is beyond the scope of one blog post. But it's definitely something to keep an eye on.

Friday, 21 September 2007

Listening for Sound Bites

Couldn't pick between four events yesterday after classes were over, so went to all four. We'll see how long THAT lasts.

Lots of high-falutin' ideas at MIT's forum on "What is Civic Media?" about whether social networking and distributive intelligence have killed or fostered democracy's "deliberative ideal." (Update: See Ethan Zuckerman's blog post on the "civic media" forum for more detail.) And really scrumptious chocolate cake at the meeting of the pre-med committee at Lowell House as well as great appetizers at the Knight Science Journalism Fellows reception at MIT. (Free food seems to be a theme at a lot of the events I've attended lately.)

But the thought that's still rattling around in my brain this morning as I hurry off to class is something that Ira Magaziner said at last night's student forum at the Kennedy School. I'm paraphrasing here, but basically he said, that if you love what you do, then you don't notice the hours that you put into your job and, by extension, away from your family. Specifically, of course, he was talking about his passion for global health and poverty alleviation in his capacity as chair of the Clinton Foundation HIV/AIDS Initiative. They don't worry too much about individual job satisfaction at the Clinton Foundation, Magaziner said. They're too busy saving lives.

At a minimum, that sounded to me like a recipe for burnout. And the more I thought about it, the more it also seemed like the kind of attitude that lets people off the hook too easily. If you have to be a Mother Teresa to do anything about global poverty or the wide disparity around the world in basic health care, then not much is going to get done. (And lately, we've learned that even Mother Teresa wasn't the kind of saint most people thought she was--she was privately wracked with doubt about both her faith and her mission.)

The point being that there will always be people like Paul Farmer, who was also at the Kennedy School forum, and Ira Magaziner who are driven to do something, driven to the point that their passion consumes their lives. But if we leave the vision of a more just and healthy world to people like this alone, the mission will never be accomplished.

Ordinary folks, the kind who do care about job satisfaction and vacations and having time for family, have to be part of the equation as well or the job won't get done. And it's okay to make room for ordinary folks with ordinary goals.