Thursday, 30 August 2007

USAID Rule Changes Postponed

An e-mail update from the Global Health Council. . .

-----Original Message-----

From: Global Health Council
[e-mail addresses redacted]
Subj: Update: USAID Proposed Rule Changes
Date: Thu Aug 30, 2007 4:48 pm

August 30, 2007
Global Health Council Opposes Implementation of USAID's Proposed Partner Vetting System

The U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) announced Aug. 28 that it has delayed plans to implement a sweeping information-gathering and recordkeeping measure originally called the Partner Vetting System (PVS). The measure, which was to take effect on Aug. 27, has been postponed pending further comment from affected organizations and review by USAID.

The comment period has been extended until Sept. 21, 2007. Many Council members have voiced opposition to PVS and the Council recommends that communication to USAID on this issue continue. The Council strongly encourages members to contact both USAID and their members of Congress in opposition to the proposed change.

The PVS, which is now being referred to within USAID as the Anti-Terror Vetting System, would vet individuals, officers or other officials of nongovernmental organizations who apply for USAID contracts, grants, cooperative agreements or other funding, or who apply for registration with USAID as Private and Voluntary Organizations (PVOs).

If implemented, the PVS would require all organizations that apply for USAID contracts, grants and cooperative agreements to submit detailed information about directors, officers and affected employees, including full name, date and place of birth, government issued identification information, address, phone and fax numbers, country of origin and/or nationality, citizenship, gender and profession.

The rule change was issued to ensure that USAID funds are not being used to support activities or individuals "associated with terrorism." Although there is no evidence that USAID funds are supporting terrorist organizations or terrorist activities through USAID partners, the proposal was advanced, according to USAID representatives, in response to criticisms from members of Congress and US security agencies. The Global Health Council does not believe there is an adequate statutory basis for the proposed vetting system.

The Council believes that the PVS may endanger the safety of USAID partner organization staff, is overly burdensome for USAID's partners, unnecessary, and compromises privacy rights and due process. The Council will continue to work with USAID to recommend constructive and feasible measures to address legitimate concerns. Please see the Council's Statement on PVS for sample language to include in your letter to the USAID Chief Privacy Officer. View statement.

Please send your message opposing PVS as soon as possible. The deadline for comments is Sept. 21, 2007.

Please address your message to:

Mr. Philip M. Heneghan
Chief Privacy Officer
United States Agency for International Development
1300 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Office 2.12-003
Washington, D.C. 20523-2120
Email: privacy@usaid.gov

Please also send copies to your Member of Congress. www.senate.gov www.house.gov


This email was sent by the Global Health Council.
For more information about the Global Health Council, please visit our website.


Our postal address is
15 Railroad Row
White River Jct, Vermont 05001
United States

Web 2.0 Comes to Public Health

There's a lot about social networking and other Web 2.0 phenomena that Tom Sawyer would recognize--particularly the part about enticing other people to do your work for you. But more and more global health aficionados are taking those first baby steps to explore social networking, shared bookmarking, tagging and other interactive tools. It's still too soon to tell how much is short-lived fad and how much could truly be effective. But here are a few I've come across.

Beth Kanter reports on fund-raising for real non-profits in the virtual world of Second Life.

Emory MPH grad Aaron Wallace has a social networking/job posting site at www.swala.org

Heather and Amber have another public health job site at their worktraveleatsleep site.

Razoo.com hopes to attract more do-gooders with a prize of $10,000. Sign up 100 other like-minded people by Sept. 15 and you have a shot at the money.

Monday, 27 August 2007

ANC Goes for Broke on Madlala-Routledge

Who could believe a single, middle-aged mother of two kids could be such a threat?

Firing apparently wasn't good enough for axed deputy health minister Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge of South Africa. Neither was billing her for the airfare to Spain for an AIDS conference, including the penalty for coming back early when the permission she thought she had received was in fact revoked. The ANC government appears bent on devastating her financially.

Now the defense department is billing her for a trip it alleges was unapproved back when Madlala-Routledge was deputy minister there. Not to be outdone, the public works department is billing for her what it says was unpaid rent for her government housing, which she has since lost.

Meanwhile, in an interview published in the Sunday Argus, Madlala-Routledge likened working for Health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang to the pain and anguish she (Madlala-Routledge) had faced while in detention, including solitary confinement, under apartheid. Some of Madlala-Routledge's friends and supporters have started a fund to help her fight back.

I just can't help following every twist and turn in this conflict between admitting to any sort of a health crisis and the need to maintain political cohesion and demonstrate loyalty to a political party. South Africa's President Thabo Mbeki further laid down his thinking in his weekly online newsletter last week. His latest entry states that basically anyone who criticizes the ANC, including opposition parties, is doing the work of the underground apartheid movement. More to come, I'm sure.

Wednesday, 22 August 2007

Details of USAID Proposed Rule Change

Not sure why the hyperlink didn't come through on the last post, but until I can fix it, here's the citation from the Federal Register:

http://a257.g.akamaitech.net/7/257/2422/01jan20071800/edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/07-3330.htm


Update: links in original post "USAID Rule Targets Terrorists But Hits NGOs" are now fixed.

USAID Rule Targets Terrorists But Hits NGOs

Oh dear. More friendly fire in the war on terror.

Passing along this e-mail from the Global Health Council.

See also this update on the proposed USAID rule change.

-----Original Message-----

From: Global Health Council
Subj: Urgent: USAID Proposes Rule Changes
Date: Wed Aug 22, 2007 6:23 pm

August 22, 2007 Global Health Council Opposes Implementation
of the Proposed Partner Vetting System at USAID


The U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) proposed a sweeping information-gathering and recordkeeping measure, the Partner Vetting System (PVS), to vet individuals, officers or other officials of nongovernmental organizations who apply for USAID contracts, grants, cooperative agreements, or other funding or who apply for registration with USAID as Private and Voluntary Organizations (PVOs).

The Partner Vetting System would require all organizations that apply for USAID contracts, grants and cooperative agreements to submit detailed information about each employee including full name, date and place of birth, government issued identification information, address, phone and fax numbers, country of origin and/or nationality, citizenship, gender and profession. The proposed measure was printed in the Federal Register on July 17. Notice, Privacy Act System of Records, Federal Register, Vol. 72, No. 136, July 17, 2007, Pages 39041-39044. View specific guidelines

The rule change was issued in an effort to improve processes for making sure that USAID funds are not being used to support activities or individuals "associated with terrorism." There is no evidence that USAID funds are supporting terrorist organizations or terrorist activities through NGOs.

The Council believes that the Partner Vetting System is overly burdensome for NGO partners, unnecessary, and compromises privacy rights and due process as envisioned. Please see the Council's Statement on PVS for sample language to include in your letter to the USAID Chief Privacy Officer. View statement

Please send your message opposing the Partner Vetting System as soon as possible. The deadline for comments is Aug. 27, 2007 - the same date PVS is scheduled to take effect.

Please address your message to:

Mr. Philip M. Heneghan
Chief Privacy Officer
United States Agency for International Development
1300 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Office 2.12-003
Washington, D.C. 20523-2120

E-mail: privacy@usaid.gov

This email was sent by the Global Health Council.
For more information about the Global Health Council, please visit our website.

Our postal address is
15 Railroad Row
White River Jct, Vermont 05001
United States

ANC to Investigate Madlala-Routledge

The African National Congress now plans to investigate fired South African deputy health minister Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge for her implied criticisms of both President Mbeki and the ANC on AIDS and other matters.

You would think the party would let the whole thing drop instead of further fueling the media storm. All this does is stoke the anger about how Madlala-Routledge, a well-regarded government official, got the boot. But what do I know about politics?

Interesting tidbit: the person charged with investigating Madlala-Routledge also apparently advised her not to resign but instead to let herself get fired on principle.

Meanwhile, I keep reminding myself not to get too distracted by the personality clashes and drama. The key issue here--at least from a health point of view--is what happens to South Africa's National Strategic Plan on AIDS.

President Mbeki is on record as saying he still supports the NSP and that it doesn't depend on the whether or not Madlala-Routledge is in office. That's the prize we should all be keeping our eye on.

Thoughts on South Africa, the U.S. and Buses

There's nothing like going to another country to make you think more deeply about your own. My recent trip to South Africa has me pondering a lot of things here in the U.S. from a slightly different angle.

Economic disparity. While in South Africa, the biggest contrast between haves and havenots that I saw was in Cape Town. We didn't go inside any of the lovely mansions high on the hills hugging the coastline. But it was easy to imagine what they must look like inside.

Just a few miles away on the Cape Flats, at sea level, we visited Dunoon, one of the poorer neighborhoods, where the majority of families love and work and play in crowded metal shacks. They have basic sanitation--public outhouses--and electricity. But in many cases cooking food or washing clothes still occurs over open fires.

Not surprisingly, fast-spreading fires are a huge problem in these areas. As is flooding, given the location. The week after we left, Cape Town was hit by four big Atlantic storms in a row, causing a lot of devastation. Other problems include high rates of tuberculosis and other respiratory diseases, crime, the lack of economic and educational opportunities.

What do the folks living up on the hills owe, if anything, to the people on the Flats? Even the middle class have their rewards, a comfortable life, food on the table, a car or two. Do they have anything in common--other than their humanity--with the people on the Flats?

Now back to the other side of the Atlantic. You see tremendous contrasts every day in New York City, which is my home. They may not be as great as in Cape Town, but they are most assuredly there--at least until they start seeming familiar and disappear from consciousness.

And in the past few days in Cambridge, Mass., this great bastion of higher learning and privilege in the U.S., I'm struck by the contrasts.

Just one anecdote about buses to make the point. I have a whole theory about buses and what riding buses can tell you about a community, which I may expand on in another post some day.

Anyway, Harvard provides a shuttle bus from the university campus to the medical school and school of public health. The service is free to those with a Harvard ID. So yesterday, after I got my ID (I'm starting to feel more official now), I tested it out by taking the shuttle over to the school of public health.

I didn't think much of it at the time, but everyone on board looks very serious and pre-occupied, checking out their Treos, reading books, studying texts, listening to iPods. All very professional-looking.

Later in the day, I took one of Cambridge's public buses, along Massachusetts Avenue. There was a much greater mix of people and the French-speaking couple in front of me--possibly Haitian--were clearly none too sure exactly where they were going or which stop would bring them closest to their destination.

No great conclusions. It was just a flash, an impression of contrast while riding two different buses. But it made me wonder, What, if anything, would ever bring the passengers on these two vehicles--the shuttle and the public bus--together. What, if anything, do they owe each other?