Wednesday, 8 August 2007

Grandmothers Against Poverty

It was obvious everywhere we went in South Africa that grandmothers are the glue that holds most of society together, particularly in rural and impoverished areas. Before coming to South Africa, I had assumed that that was primarily because of the traditional role that grandmothers played in the care and rearing of their grandchildren while parents were busy at jobs far away.

While travelling to six of the country's nine provinces, however, it became clear that grandmothers also are a major economic force in large part because they receive a little over 800 Rand per month (about US $115) in old-age pension benefits. I met many older women--some of them in their 70s and 80s--who were caring for their grandchildren and even great-grandchildren, clothing them, feeding them, paying their school fees out of this modest pension benefit.


(Leonora Msikinya, 85, (pictured above) who I met in Ethembeni in the Eastern Cape has dedicated the remaining years of her life to fighting HIV by talking clearly in her community and church about sex, pregnancy and HIV. She has even been featured on anti-AIDS billboards throughout the country.)

What became very obvious to me, while visiting with these women and their families, is that they and their old-age pensions are also an important bulwark against poverty.

Indeed, a June 2007 study by Charles Meth, who is associated with both the University of KwaZulu-Natal and the University of Cape Town, concludes that of the three major social grants available in South Africa (old age, children support, disability), "old age pensions have the greatest impact on poverty. In 2004, the approximately two million pensions raised about 1.5 million people in 600 000 households over the poverty line."

Which brings me to my next questions: What hope is there for you if you're poor and don't have a grandmother in South Africa? Would a modest basic income grant for those living on less than a dollar a day--something that Archbishop Desmond Tutu brought up again at a church meeting in Johannesburg in July, but which doesn't seem to be getting much traction among the powers that be in South Africa--make a difference?

Using Search-Engine Journalism to Get Your Message Across

As I said back in June in a talk at the Global Health Council, search-engine journalism is changing the way interested folks get their topic in front of interested journalists. If you blog about your issues with insight and creativity, journalists will eventually find you, rather than waiting for you to cultivate them.

It's not that journalists necessarily read that many blogs or check that many web pages on a daily basis--there are just too many sites for that to be a practical approach. Our secret weapon is often a "Google alert" or a Yahoo keyword search that brings us some fairly well targeted urls that contain postings of interest. Indeed, I often create alerts based on people's names in addition to certain topics because I just like the way some people think--no matter what topic they write about.

Case in point: Ethan Zuckerman's ideas on incremental infrastructure, which he posted on his blog, caught the interest of an editor at the Boston Globe, who invited Zuckerman, a fellow at the Berkman Center for Internet and Society at Harvard, to write about the topic for the Ideas section of the newspaper. Basically, Zuckerman sings the virtues of small-scale, privately financed infrastructure that can be incrementally scaled up as opposed to many of the large-scale, government-and aid-financed programs that have become such white elephants in many parts of Africa.

Zuckerman's points on infrastructure are interesting and worth consideration. But as far as I can tell from his blog, he didn't call up a journalist to "pitch a story." An editor at the Boston Globe found him and his ideas in that incredibly democratic marketplace of ideas, the Internet.

For the record, I learned about Zuckerman's post through an RSS feed to my personalized iGoogle homepage. Mine is a modest iGoogle page that helps me follow my top about 50 news and blog sources for information. I use Google Reader, which also uses RSS feeds, to share some of those selections on a sort of mini-global health blog that also lives on the right hand side of the blog.

RSS--for really simple syndication--makes it more likely your creativity and insight will get picked up by people who are actually interested in your issues--and not just random searchers on the Internet.

Tuesday, 7 August 2007

Balancing Human Rights And HIV Testing

There's a growing movement to declare access to basic healthcare as a fundamental human right. And there's a lot to commend in this push. But great ideas and good intentions don't always guarantee desired results on the ground, as I learned in my recent trip to South Africa.

A case in point: the clash between those who champion voluntary counselling and testing (VCT) for HIV with the those who argue for the so-called opt-out model.

VCT grew out of the early days of the AIDS epidemic when people's legal rights were getting trampled right and left in housing, on the job, in schools and in clinics and hospitals. Back when there was no treatment for HIV, when AIDS was a new and terrifying scourge, it made a lot of sense to make sure that everyone understood before getting tested for HIV, what the test involved, what it meant to be HIV-positive, who could use that information and what your legal rights were.

But now that we have lived with AIDS for 25 years, now that there are treatments (albeit no cure or vaccine), now that anti-discrimination laws are stronger, voluntary counselling and testing may actually be doing more harm than good.

Or at least that's the feeling of a couple of doctors I spoke with in South Africa.

By making HIV testing such a big deal in that country, VCT has actually increased stigmatization, in their view, particularly in rural areas where all your neighbors go to the same clinic and know which chairs and which doors are designated for HIV testing and counselling. And in fact, studies show that under VCT programs fewer South Africans who actually are HIV positive opt for testing.

As an alternative, a few South African healthcare workers are trying the opt-out model for HIV testing. Patients still get counselled about HIV but it's part of a broader panel of tests--for example, prenatal tests that look for Rh factor, diabetes and high blood pressure. And instead of actively making a decision to be tested (call it opt-in), the active decision after the counselling is not to be tested. In other words, if you do nothing, you'll be tested. But your rights are preserved by an "opt-out" option.

The opt-out approach has worked in Botswana and is being championed by the Centers for Disease Control for use in the U.S. It's gotten some pushback from those who were trained in and have championed voluntary counselling and testing. There is a legitimate human rights concern here--AIDS discrimination is still rampant, particularly in areas of extreme poverty. But being inflexible about how human rights are expressed or sticking with the first human rights response for too long can also lead to harmful and even fatal delays in care.

Jobs in Women's Health, PEPFAR, Climate Change

A few job listings that have come to my attention:

Senior communications advisor, President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief.

Director of Development, International Women's Health Coalition

Senior Program Officer, IWHC

Program coordinator for building resilience to climate change in Asia (based in Bangkok), Rockefeller Foundation

Friday, 3 August 2007

News Flash: Talking About Sex is Fun


I'm still trying to figure out what I think about loveLife, the ubiquitous sex education and teen-empowerment organization whose goal is to reduce HIV transmission among young people in South Africa. LoveLife's Y-Centers were frequent destinations for myself and my fellow journalists in July--all organized by the Kaiser Family Foundation for our traveling AIDS Seminar.

Clearly, Kaiser made a point of taking us to all these loveLife groups because the foundation is a major supporter--to the tune of more than $150 million about $80 million over the years. Some of us joked that we were going to know loveLife's slogans better than the kids did by the end of our trip.

More seriously, questions have been raised in the international press as to whether loveLife's approach has any effect on HIV rates. We also heard from parents who said their initial impression of loveLife was that it was a place where their kids went to find sex rather than to refrain from sex.

And it's absolutely true that loveLife's pamphlets and workbooks are pretty frank. One exchange between cartoon characters Miriam and Maxwell has Max telling Miriam that he has to have sex with her or his "balls will turn blue." Miriam replies, "Good. Then I can hang them on the tree this year for Christmas ornaments." That sort of no-holds-barred exchange probably goes a long way towards explaining why the Global Fund no longer supports loveLife.

Of course, anyone who has been around teenagers or remembers being a teenager knows that this is the way teens talk--the myth about blue balls, for one, having been around for generations.

Denying sexuality hardly seems to be the answer. Later in our trip, we heard anecdotal reports that anal sex rates are on the increase in South Africa because of the number of abstinence programs that promote virginity before marriage as well as the growing popularity of hymen examinations for young brides. Talk about unintended consequences. Unprotected anal sex is a much more efficient transmitter of HIV than unprotected vaginal sex. (See also this new report by Kristen Underhill and colleagues in the British Medical Journal, which concludes that abstinence-only programs have no effect on pregnancy or HIV rates in rich countries.)

Another challenge when trying to figure out how effective loveLife's programs are is the fact that official UNAIDS statistics are broken out by fairly large age groups. Teens are covered in the 15-to-24 year-old bracket. By not breaking out the lower end of the age group--15 to 17 or 18--you're not getting a good picture of whether prevention messages targeted at teens are working and then failing as they grow older.

I keep coming back to the energy and enthusiasm of the teenagers we met at the loveLife programs that we visited and the commitment of their peer educators--dubbed "groundbreakers" in the loveLife lexicon. There was certainly a sense of possibilities, of optimism for the future, of a life to live for and a reason to avoid becoming infected with HIV.

That positive spirit was quite a contrast with that of so many of the adults we met on other portions of our trip. I'm not a trained psychologist or anything but it certainly seemed to me there was a lot of depression amongst the adults we met. The end of apartheid did not magically erase the legacy of racism, extreme poverty, missed opportunities and mistrust. There is still so much left to do.

Sunday, 15 July 2007

Why Do HIV Rates Go Up After Graduation?


I'm in Limpopo Province with the travelling Kaiser Foundation HIV/AIDS seminar. This afternoon, our group visited the Lenyenye Youth-Center (or Y-Center), one of the benefactors of Kaiser funding. We learned that HIV rates seem to be declining among youngsters 15 to 17 but then they start climbing again, after age 18.

Several young people from Center explained it this way: once you're out of school, you're not as closely supervised as before. So the temptation to go a little wild, be a little irresponsible is great.

"When teenagers leave school, they say 'I am on my own,' " says 20-year old Itumeleng Hlokwe, a young man who has served as the Center's deejay and hopes to go to university to become a biochemist. " 'It's me against the world. My parents don't see me. My teacher doesn't see me.' " (That's Itu on the right in the photo above.)

Representing the girls' point of view is 19-year-old Katlego (pictured on the left in the photo, with me in the middle). "After school, many girls think, I have to do this," she says. They know what they must do to protect themselves against HIV and may have done so successfully throughout high school. But then, to many, it seems they have lost whatever power they had to negotiate sexual relations or safer-sex practices.

Listening to Itumeleng and Katlego it was easy to imagine that they won't be caught in the same trap. Their plans for the future--Katlego wants eventually to go into agriculture, either animal or plant production--sound so promising.

Next question: why did the Global Fund stopped giving money to loveLife, the South African NGO that sponsors the Lenyene Y-Center? The CEO of loveLife, David Harrison, mentioned that in brief remarks this afternoon. But that's a question for another day. I can feel the jet lag catching up with me.

Saturday, 14 July 2007

Read the Fine Print on Diaphragm HIV Study

Is it true that a diaphragm plus a condom is no better than a condom alone at preventing HIV transmission? That's what a study in the July 13 issue of the Lancet concluded. But there's an interesting detail that makes me wonder just what the study really shows.

Scidev.net reports that "The authors note that the proportion of women using condoms was significantly lower in the diaphragm group than in the control group (54 per cent as opposed to 85 per cent), possibly because of a perceived irrelevance of a second barrier method."

So is it possible a diaphragm alone offers similar protection to a condom? Or better protection than no condom at all? Alas, the study was NOT designed to answer that question but it makes you wonder.