Thursday, 31 May 2007
An IOU on Global Health News Coverage
Update: Here's the post with my remarks at the Global Health Council.
A Geographical Puzzle on HPV
Dr. Rebecca Kightlinger of the University of Virginia Health System told me that she was surprised to learn that the high prevalence of cervical cancer she found in one section of Guyana was linked to the HPV-35 subtype. Of course in the U.S., the predominant cancer-causing HPV subtyes are HPV-16 and HPV-18, which are included in Gardasil.
If the HPV subtypes that cause cervical cancer are different throughout the world, however, that means different vaccine formulations will have to be used in different parts of the globe..
It may also mean that different vaccine formulations may need to be used for different ethnic groups, who may have migrated to new regions.
Something to ponder if you're trying to reduce the enormous death toll due to cervical cancer throughout the world. (Or if you're expecting Gardasil to be a global blockbuster.)
There's A Place for Government After All
Interesting point from Joy Phumaphi, who used to be the Minister of Health in Botswana and who is now at the World Bank. "What I didn't appreciate while I was in government was the power of government," Phumapi says. "Developing country governments do not appreciate the extent to which they have the authority to direct the conversation. They tend to look for complete guidance from their development partners instead of realizing they can guide the development agenda themselves."
Phumaphi suggests governments of developing countries should be more assertive in saying, as she puts it, "This is not useful to me. This is what I need." She predicts much more effective results in global health programs if governments of developing countries claimed their authority to speak out and direct planning efforts more actively, rather than just listening quietly to what donors think they want to do.
History Repeats Itself
Shailor compared the infamous Triangle Shirtwaist Fire of 1911, in which so many women were trapped and killed, to another fire nearly a century later in a toy factory in Bangkok. Some 200 women were killed in the toy factory fire.
The implicit message: progress is made through activism, in this case labor activism. And the real issues, the truly fundamental issues, don't change that much over the centuries.
Wednesday, 30 May 2007
Paying for Better Results
Of course, the incentives being talked about in this afternoon's discussion were all for folks in the private sector, non-government organizatons and the like--and the panelists skipped any deep forays into the strengthening of public hospitals and clinics. But I guess you can't have everything.
In any event, the session was packed--standing room only, with a few participants sitting on the floor here and there. Intriguing reports about local programs in Haiti, Nicaragua and Afghanistan.
Also, it was the first time I ever heard anyone suggest making incentive payments to poor people getting treated for tuberculosis so that they will complete the full course of therapy and not just stop after two months when they feel better and decide they need to look for a job.
Update: For more information on treatment incentives for TB patients, Ruth Levine of the Center for Global Development suggests taking a look at a report one of the CGD's working groups has written on the subject. You'll find it here.
It's the Salaries, Stupid
And yet the panel for the GHC session on countering the brain drain actively avoided talking about salaries for health care providers.
Indeed, the moderator, Edward Elmendorf of the World Bank actually discouraged any talk about providing a living wage for doctors and nurses in the public sector of the poorest countries, because, goodness knows, then teachers and other civil servants will want better wages and that could lead to runaway inflation.
I would have liked to have seen more discussion on that point. What's the evidence that paying doctors, nurses, teachers and other public servants a living wage is counterprouctive? After all,the NGOs and various other research organizaions seem to be doing very well by providing their employees wit living wages. Why wouldn't such an effort in the publc sector pay dividends as well?
Certainly the panel seemed very earnest and well-meaning but I was disappointed that it was either unable or unwilling to get at the deeper issue of why the subject of salary should be off the table.
A Ratings Agency for Global Health?
Such an independent ratings agencies for program in global health would, for example, help businesses, foundations and governments decide which ventures to fund further, which to avoid and which could improve with help.
This idea was proposed by David de Ferranti, a senior fellow of the Brookings Institution and the United Nations Foundation.