Monday, 20 August 2007

Manto Drama Enters Third Week

Just when you thought the news from South Africa couldn't get any weirder. The Sunday Times published a report yesterday that categorically declares that Minister of Health Manto Tshabalala-Msimang is an active alcoholic. Furthermore, it says doctors at a Johannesburg hospital where she received a liver transplant earlier this year covered up the fact that her own liver had failed due to alcoholic liver cirrhosis. The South African newspaper goes on to say that she has been seen drunk since the transplant.

Oh yeah and Tshabalala-Msimang was convicted of stealing jewelry and other items from patients at a hospital in Botswana, where she used to work in the 1970s.

As bizarre and damaging as Tshabalala-Msimang's pronouncements on AIDS have been, I'm troubled by how much of her personal medical records are being made public in this ongoing scandal. Privacy rules should cover everyone not just our friends.

On a personal note, I picked up a rental car over the weekend, packed up some clothes and my laptop and moved in to my new digs in Cambridge. Still learning where the post office, grocery store and other important services are located. Have already started to meet some of the other Nieman Fellows. Orientation begins next week.

Friday, 17 August 2007

CARE, Utah Mine Deaths, South Africa

CARE. Three cheers for CARE, which reject $45 million worth of food aid from the U.S. government, arguing it does more harm than good.

As the BBC reports,
"CARE criticised the way US food aid is distributed, saying it harms local farmers, especially in Africa. It said wheat donated by the US government and distributed by charities introduced low prices that local farmers are unable to compete with."
Utah Mine Deaths. True to its promise to try to take up where Confined Space left off, The Pump Handle has provided lots of good behind-the-headlines coverage of the mine disaster in Utah that has trapped six miners and now killed three rescuers.

See especially Celeste Monforton's post on the need for tracking systems for trapped miners. Monforton has a masters in public health and was part of a team that investigated the Sago and Aracoma Alma coal mine disasters on behalf of West Virginia Governor Joe Manchin.

South Africa. Meanwhile in South Africa, not even the conviction of apartheid-era security officials has stemmed the anger over the firing of deputy health minister Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge. Thobile Ntola of the South African Democratic Teachers Union criticized President Mbeki's handling of the whole affair at one of the union's branch meetings.
“Tell me what kind of a president would preach gender equality and at the same time fire a woman during Women’s Month?" Ntola was quoted as saying by the Daily Dispatch. “This proves that in this African National Congress that was formed to benefit the poor, you cannot voice what you believe will serve in the interest of one Mambhele on the street.”
While Xolela Mangcu writes in Johannesburg's Business Day that "President Thabo Mvuyelwa Mbeki has become an albatross around the neck of our political culture."

"At every turn, Mbeki has tried to pass himself off as an interesting intellectual, irrespective of whether his ideas are relevant to the reality of the population," Mangcu writes. "That surely must partly explain the instinctive denial. If it does not emanate from the "private lair of his skull" then it cannot be true. It's the perpetual intellectual quest for originality gone haywire.

I am from Eastern Cape and everyone there knows that you send your relatives to public hospitals only to die," Mangcu continues. "Not long ago, the distinguished writer Phyllis Ntantala described those hospitals as morgues after her harrowing experience there."

Today, President Mbeki responded to continuing criticism of his firing of former deputy minister of health Madlala-Routledge in his weekly "Letter from the President" as follows:

Some in our country and others elsewhere in the world, including the media, have acclaimed Ms Madlala-Routledge as a great heroine, before and after her dismissal, on the basis that she seemed to demonstrate intellectual and personal "courage" by defying the obligation to speak and act as part of a collective. In this regard, in her 10 August press conference, she made a point of emphasising her obligation to be accountable to the media.

Collective responsibility

With regard to all this, I must make the point absolutely clear, without equivocation or qualification, that while the ANC serves as government, in any of the three spheres of government, freely elected by the people, it will ensure that its members respect the principle and practice of collective responsibility.

None of the members of the ANC deployed in government will be treated by our movement as heroes and heroines on the basis of "lone ranger" behaviour, so-called because of their defiance of agreed positions and procedures of our movement and government.

For more posts on Madlala-Routledge, click here.

Thursday, 16 August 2007

Working For Water; Saving Lives


The scene: Cape Town’s world-famous Table Mountain, part of the spectacular sandstone spine of the Cape Peninsula.

The guy in the green National Parks jacket: Paddy Gordon (pictured above).

The out-of-towners: six journalists from the U.S. and U.K. on a traveling seminar sponsored by the Kaiser Family Foundation.

Gordon talked to us about how eucalyptus trees and other plants that were brought to South Africa over the past 300 years have played havoc on the natural ecology of the country's majestic mountains. Eucalyptus trees, in particular, suck up lots of water from the ground robbing the life-giving liquid from native plants.

But eucalyptus trees are very hard to uproot and get rid of. Although it’s easy to teach someone how to do it, you need lots of hands to accomplish the task. Hmmm. Anyone else see the makings of a good idea?

Enter Working for Water, an initiative of the South African government, which marries the need for ecological restoration with the demand for lots of jobs for unskilled laborers in very poor comunities like Khayelitsha.

But it doesn’t stop there. Working for Water, which was launched in 1995, also teaches job skills like basic book keeping and bidding for contracts so that workers can eventually create their own businesses. In addition, the initiative conducts regular AIDS training programs as well.

Good health requires more than healthcare workers and clinics. You also need clean drinking water, jobs, basic sanitation, jobs, adequate housing, jobs, education, jobs, legal rights, and jobs. Well, you get the point.

Regular employment makes a huge difference in how healthy a community--and often even a natural environment--can be. Working for Water is helping to make that difference.

Wednesday, 15 August 2007

Having Your Say: Pandemic Flu

Stock up on face masks. Before I left the U.S. (and my computer) last month, I put up a poll question asking you to guess when a flu pandemic might strike. Now without further ado, the unscientific results: 7 out of 15 loyal respondents believe that a pandemic flu will hit in the next five years. Five voters thought it would strike in five to ten years and three opted for 10 to 50 years. No one believed flu pandemics are a thing of history.

Madlala-Routledge Stands Alone

Party discipline holds--for now. All government officials and ANC members with political ambitions are distancing themselves from South Africa's fired deputy health minister, Nozizwe Madlala, who in the matter of a few short months had distinguished herself as an honest and refreshing voice on the HIV/AIDS crisis.

At a press conference last Friday, Madlala Routledge mentioned in passing that she had talked with three different government ministers who were concerned about conditions at Frere Hospital in the Eastern Cape. On Tuesday, all three released statements declaring that they had NEVER EVER invited her to check out the problems at the troubled hospital.

Madlala-Routledge visited the hospital on her "own initiative," they said, and they had NOTHING to do with it.

Can you spell Catch-22? Two doctors at Frere hospital were also suspended. One apparently got in trouble for writing directly to President Mbeki that conditions at the hospital really were bad. (She should have gone through channels) The other was suspended for allowing conditions at the hospital to deteriorate so badly. (Yes, even though an official health ministry task force decided things were quite normal at Frere.)

Race considerations often lurk beneath the surface of South African politics. And there's no doubt that the Democratic Alliance, a mostly white opposition party, is making a lot of hay over Madlala-Routledge's firing. But South Africa's minority whites aren't the only people who are upset.

Dr. Olive Shisana, who used to be director-general of the Ministry of Health until she was axed as well, has come out in support of Madlala-Routledge as has Zwelinzima Vavi, the General Secretary of the Congress of Southern African Trade Unions--although he apologized to the families of dead ministers after making a remark about deadwood in the Cabinet. And Dr. Kgosi Letlape of the South African Medical Association called Madlala firing "regrettable."

In truth, Madlala-Routledge's departure must be seen as a power play by President Mbeki and a warning to others who don't show him loyalty ahead of the ANC's December meeting to choose a party president. Although Mbeki cannot run for a third term as president of the country, there is apparently nothing to stop him from being chosen as head of the party for a third term.

It would be the height of irony if axing the deputy health minister--which seems to be achieving the desired political results so far--strengthens the hand of a populist like Jacob Zuma, a longtime Mbeki rival, who is positioning himself to be ANC's next leader as well as the head of the government. As I learned on my recent trip to South Africa, many people in the professional classes--black, white and other--fear that Zuma could become South Africa's own Robert Mugabe. They would rather bumble along with Mbeki than risk a Zuma election.

Meanwhile, Madlala-Routledge has been busy house-hunting. She loses her government-funded home and office at the end of September and will be taking a significant cut in pay as well. (She is still a Member of Parliament.)

For related blog entries on Madlala-Routledge, click here.

Tuesday, 14 August 2007

Lead Kills Whether in Toys or Jewelry

Say what?! It's against the law to put lead in toys but the U.S. still does not ban lead in jewelry. Lead-containing trinkets are particularly dangerous if swallowed since that can lead to acute lead poisoning, resulting in seizures, brain damage and even death.

Under growing public pressure, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission is now considering adopting a ban on lead in children's jewelry and has asked for comment.

Meanwhile, toy-making giant Mattel is set to announce another recall of lead-tainted products manufactured in China.

Update: complete list of toys in latest Mattel recall.

Cross-posted in The Health Media Watch.

Monday, 13 August 2007

South Africa's Health Minister Accused of Drinking in Hospital

Last week's media storm in South Africa over the firing of deputy health minister Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge shows no signs of letting up. President Thabo Mbeki took the unusual step of releasing his letter of dismissal to the media over the weekend. In it, he declared that Madlala-Routledge was let go because of her "inability to work as part of a collective, as the constitution enjoins us to."

Mbeki was responding to continuing outrage from the government's coalition partners and others that Madlala-Routledge, widely regarded as honest and competent, had been fired instead of her former boss, the often erratic Health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang.

But the President's move was quickly overshadowed by an explosive report in The Sunday Times of South Africa, accusing Tshabalala-Msimang of a "booze binge" while in the hospital two years ago for shoulder surgery.

Tshabalala-Msimang has in the past denied having an alcohol problem and press reports suggested she is considering suing The Sunday Times over the allegations. The newspaper's editors say they stand behind their story, which was based on a five-month investigation as well as leaked hospital records.

Read President Mbeki's letter to Madlala-Routledge on the official South African government site.

For related blog entries on Madlala-Routledge, click here.